Tag Archives: suffocation

Orchard Park, Kingston upon Hull: Patricia King

CONVICTED (2022) | Patricia King, born c. 1975, of 24 Palmcourt, Orchard Park, Hull HU6 9TH – strangled and viciously stabbed her pet dog, causing fatal injuries.

Dog killer: Patricia King from Hull, UK. Picture: Facebook.

Evil Patricia King used a kitchen knife to stab the female Yorkie, known as Pepper, nine times during a repeated and deliberate incident that would have caused the tiny dog a lot of pain and distress.

Philip Brown, prosecuting for the RSPCA, said that King “inflicted deliberate and fatal cruelty” on the dog, who was aged between four and five, at her home.

King approached a woman that she knew and asked her for a cuddle. She told the woman that she had killed her dog.

Dog killer: Patricia King from Hull, UK. Picture: Hull Daily Mail.

Being aware that King did not always tell the entire truth, the woman asked King to show her the dog. She then made the “shocking discovery” of finding Pepper’s badly mutilated remains wrapped in an old blanket in a bedroom.

The woman managed to “secrete” the dog out of the property and alerted the RSPCA.

Pepper’s body was taken away and it was discovered that she had suffered nine stab wounds, likely to have been caused by a kitchen knife.

“The wounds led to significant internal bleeding,” said Mr Brown.

“The animal was also subject to strangulation and suffocation while it was still alive and the vet concludes that the stab wounds were inflicted while the dog was alive.”

The wounds included stabs to the back and side in quick succession and “trauma” would have been caused.

“Death was directly attributed to the stab wounds,” said Mr Brown. “The dog did not immediately die. There is evidence of strangulation in addition to the stab wounds. The animal going into shock would have speeded up death.

“This animal would have suffered, from this ordeal, an extreme pain reaction and would have been extremely distressed. There was a high degree of suffering and distress caused to the animal by the manner of its death.”

Dog killer: Patricia King from Hull, UK. Picture: Hull Daily Mail.

King’s lawyer said his client had no previous convictions and was at a low risk of re-offending. He added that the offence was “out of character” although she had misused drugs and had other problems including significant debt.

Presiding magistrate Lynda Carmichael told King: “Due to the deliberate and sustained injuries inflicted on the dog, Pepper, which led to a high degree of suffering, we do believe that this matter warrants immediate custody.”

King’s lawyer immediately gave notice of an appeal and requested that his client be released from custody pending the hearing, but this was denied.

She remained in custody to be taken to New Hall Prison, near Wakefield.

Sentencing | 16 weeks in jail. £120 victim surcharge. Indefinite ban on keeping any animal but this will be for a minimum of 10 years.

Hull Daily Mail
ITV News

Swadlincote, Derbyshire: Harry Thompson

CONVICTED (2019) | Harry Thompson, born 19/09/2001, of Burton Road, Woodville, Swadlincote DE11 – put a cat inside a washing machine overnight until she suffocated; laughed about what he had done

Cat killer Harry Thompson from Swadlincote, Derbyshire, UK
Vile thug Harry Thompson showed no remorse for causing a cat’s death

Thompson appeared at the youth court at North Staffordshire Justice Centre where he admitted causing unnecessary suffering to the cat, known as Squeak.

The court was told the next day when the cat was found dead there was “hilarity and mocking” from Thompson.

Cat killer Harry Thompson from Swadlincote, Derbyshire, UK

The court heard that between November 12 and November 14, 2018, at a house in Jennings Way, Burton, Thompson caused unnecessary suffering to Squeak by throwing her and placing her in a washing machine.

Cat killer Harry Thompson from Swadlincote, Derbyshire, UK

Magistrates noted that Thompson’s actions would have caused the cat prolonged suffering.

Sentencing: four-month detention training order – half to be spent in custody and the other under supervision. Ordered to pay £230 compensation and charges. Banned from owning animals for five years (expires October 2024).

DerbyshireLive

Methil, Fife: Linda McLauchlan

CONVICTED (2018) | Linda Alison McLauchlan aka Linda Thomson, born 07/03/1970, previously of  Seaforth Road, Falkirk but now of Main Street, Methilhill, Methil KY8 2DN – pleaded guilty to neglecting her pet dog before the dog’s suspicious death in June 2017.

Photo shows animal abuser Linda McLauchlan and the paw of her pet dog Missy, who died in June 2017
Linda McLauclan/Thomson was originally accused of beating her pet dog to death and asphyxiating her with a plastic bag, but her not guilty plea was accepted by the court

McLauchlan was originally accused of battering Missy then suffocating her by wrapping a plastic bag over her head. However, her not guilty plea to causing the dog to die from blunt force trauma and asphyxiation was accepted, and sentencing was for failure to provide proper care.

Dog killer Linda McLauchlan

Scottish SPCA Inspector Louise Seddon said: “The charge was dealt as McLauchlan caused Missy suffering by failing to provide adequate care and veterinary treatment for her health conditions, including a skin condition and overgrown claws.

“Upon veterinary post-mortem examination, Missy was found to have chronic dermatitis and massively overgrown claws, some of them were so long the nails had twisted round into a semi-circle type shape.

“This would have significantly and severely compromised Missy’s welfare over a prolonged period”.

She added: “We welcome the fact that this case has been dealt with by the court and the sentence handed down.

“However it further highlights our push for tougher and more consistent sentencing.

“This level of neglect didn’t happen overnight and could have easily been avoided.”

Sentencing:
130-hour community payback order. Five-year ban (unconfirmed).

Scottish SPCA 



We received an email from an animal lover who was in court during Linda McLauchlan’s hearing. This was her report:

I was in court …. Let me tell you this is one cold hearted bitch who sat giggling at other charges brought up for others in front of the judge that day. I’ll tell you exactly what I know. Her neighbour reported her to the SSPCA, after she said she had suffocated the dog using a carrier bag. The dog had died on the 17th June and was removed from her garden on the 22nd by the SSPCA for a post-mortem to be carried out. The dog had suffered for such a long time.

The procurator fiscal read out the SSPCA report stating that the dog was severely malnourished. It had suffered from skin conditions that had gone untreated. Its body was covered in open lesions and the report stated the poor dog’s nails would have caused it excruciating discomfort. They stated it would have been impossible for Missy to stand let alone walk. And the little dog had lay on hard surfaces causing sores on pressure points.

In her defence she had said she had treated the dog for fleas, and it had caused the lesions due to a reaction…. (bullshit).

She failed to produce any evidence that this little dog had been ever registered or taken to any vet.

I sat in court on Thursday, and could hear my own heart beating, I was hoping this bastard would have got a lot more. The judge banned her for five years from keeping any animals and told her to complete a 130 community payback order within 6 months.

Her lawyer was a woman who stated she now lives in Fife and is in a tenancy that doesn’t allow dogs.

When I saw the pictures of Missy’s feet I felt sick to the stomach and wished I’d punched her in the face.

Also in the court, in the SSPCA officers statement it said it was the worst case the officer had dealt with in 17 years.

When the judge asked why she hadn’t sought care for Missy, her defence said she had been on universal credit.

Kingston upon Hull: Luke Hodgson

CONVICTED (2018) | Luke Hodgson, born c. 1996, and as at November 2019 of Nicholson Street, Hull HU5 1EY – suffocated a dog to death in campaign of domestic violence

Dog killer Luke Hodgson originally from Manchester and now West Hull has multiple convictions for violence against women and others
Dog killer Luke Hodgson originally from Manchester and more recently West Hull has multiple convictions for violence against women and others, including an emergency worker.

Luke Hodgson, previously of Berkshire Street, east Hull, was sent to prison after he suffocated the terrier and assaulted a woman.

Hodgson was also found guilty of assault after beating a woman and grabbing her by the throat.

Magistrates said the offence was so serious because it involved the “death of [an] animal and fear of serious injury to complainant”.

Dog killer Luke Hodgson originally from Manchester and now West Hull has multiple convictions for violence against women and others
Luke Hodgson

Hodgson, who is originally from Radcliffe in Bury, Greater Manchester, has previous convictions for threatening with a bladed article, violence, a racially aggravated public order offence and having an imitation firearm.

A restraining order was issued preventing Hodgson from contacting the woman until October 15, 2020.

Sentencing: jailed for 12 weeks. Ordered to pay £115 surcharge. Banned from keeping animals for ten years.

HullLive


November 2019 update

Hodgson has been jailed again, this time for 12 months, after admitting three common assaults, possession of a bladed article, and assaulting an emergency worker. Hodgson’s lawyer told the court that his client had “a background of underlying mental health problems”.

Bishop’s Stortford, Hertfordshire: Alexander Phillips

CONVICTED (2018) | Alexander Charles Phillips, born 1 October 1999, previously of Barrells Down Road, Bishop’s Stortford and as at December 2021 of Oldfield Lane, Bath BA2 3NP – kicked, strangled and suffocated a family’s pet cat to “teach it a lesson”

Phillips, then a sixth-form boarder at Old Swinford Hospital School, Stourbridge, West Midlands,  abducted and tortured a school friend’s 10-year-old cat Mollie after she had scratched him.

Phillips repeatedly kicked Mollie, tried to strangle and drown her, before finally suffocating her and hiding her body behind a sofa.

The prosecutor said the sinister attack had ‘overtones of a Stephen King novel’, while District Judge Steven Jonas described Phillips’ actions as ‘one of the worst cases of animal cruelty I have ever come across’.

Mr Stephen Blower, prosecuting, said it was thought Phillips provoked the elderly rescue cat into scratching him.

Phillips returned to the house in Stourbridge a few days later and sneaked Mollie out in a bag.

Back at his school accommodation, he ‘kicked the cat as hard as he could until he saw blood coming from her mouth’ said Mr Blower.

Then he grabbed the animal by the neck and tried to strangle her.

Half dead, the cat was put in a drawer so she would not be found while he went to play on his Xbox with the owner’s son.

Phillips later told police he also placed the animal under a tap of running water.

The court heard that when he returned to his room, the cat was dead in the drawer, either from her injuries or having suffocated.

“But the unsavoury aspects of this case don’t end there as he took the cat back to the house and placed it behind the sofa in the living room,” said Mr Blower.

Expert opinions were sought from two vets. One said the animal had suffered ‘intolerable and extreme pain and suffering’ while the other described the cat’s fate as a ‘prolonged, sadistic attack amounting to torture.’

Phillips, who continued to visit his friend’s home in Stourbridge while the cat was missing, finally confessed what he had done to the school matron who informed the family.

He claimed to love the cat but told police he ‘felt rejected’ by her after she scratched him.

Mr Patrick Currie, defending, said Phillips suffered from mental health problems, including Asperger’s Syndrome and ADHD.

His father’s death from suicide had had a ‘substantial’ impact on him, leading to anger issues. Phillips had killed the cat on an ‘impulse’, he claimed.

Phillips pleaded guilty to causing unnecessary suffering and to criminal damage by destroying the animal.

Sentencing | 17 weeks in a young offenders institution.

Express & Star

Bournemouth, Dorset: Charmaine Collins

CONVICTED (2018) | Charmaine Victoria Louise Collins, born 02/01/1990, of Rosebery Road, Southborne, Bournemouth BH5 2JH – let 61 animals die in her maggot-infested flat.

Animal hoarder Charmaine Collins from Bournemouth, Dorset, UK

Mother-of-one Collins crammed 196 animals including cats, dogs, guinea pigs, rabbits, hamsters, gerbils and lizards as well as ducks and chickens in to her two-bedroom flat at 25 Hamilton Road in Boscombe before she was raided by police and the RSPCA. Some animals had gone without water and food for at least a week. Of the 196 animals, 61 died.

Animals in filthy cages at Charmaine Collins' flat

The court heard that Collins, who had started a degree in veterinary care, had established an animal breeding business called Fairytales with a friend. However, the friend backed out around two weeks before the flat was raided.

Officials found 48 animals in a small shed in the property’s communal garden. Many of the creatures inside – including 30 guinea pigs – were dead at the time, or died shortly afterwards.

Animal hoarder Charmaine Collins from Bournemouth, Dorset, UK

Entry was then forced to the flat, which was in darkness and without electricity. As RSPCA inspector Patrick Bailey panned a torch around the dark rooms, the beam fell on a severely dehydrated rabbit, which was “convulsing”.

Officers were cofonfronted with loosely-stacked crates and cages filled with animals and smaller creatures suffocating in plastic containers.

More rabbits were confined to these containers, unable to move in any direction.

An animal carcass infested with maggots was also discovered. Decomposition indicated the creature had been dead for some time.

The RSPCA had first become involved with Collins in April 2016 over “similar issues”. At that time, Collins sought help from officials and some months later had just two dogs and a lizard.

However, she then began buying animals from fairs and shows. Ten days after she was interviewed by police, she travelled to Holland to buy 70 rodents. All have now been seized by the RSPCA.

Collins admitted six charges relating to the care of the animals.

Sentence: 12-month community order and 30 rehabilitation activity requirement days; total of £330 costs and charges. Banned from keeping any animal for the next 10 years (expires July 2028).

Daily Echo
Daily Mail


Update 22 November 2021

Collins, who has now changed her name to Amy Tara White, was back before the courts for breaching her disqualification order.

The defendant, now said to be of Noble Close, Bournemouth, was reported to the RSPCA for being involved with caged birds despite being banned from any involvement with animals for ten years in July 2018.

She was alleged to have been involved with the keeping of 32 caged birds on or before September 1, 2020, at an address in Poole.

Court papers state that she pleaded guilty on the day of her scheduled trial to the single animal welfare offence on a basis that she accepted the offence but denied ownership.

She was sentenced based on her version of the facts.

RSPCA Inspector Patrick Bailey, who investigated for the animal welfare charity, said after the hearing: “Courts impose disqualification orders on people convicted of animal welfare offences to protect other animals.

“It is important for people to tell us if they believe someone has breached a ban. We depend on the public to be our eyes and ears and we take breaches of bans very seriously – as do the courts.”

Collins / White was handed another 12-month community order with a requirement to complete up to 25 days of rehabilitation activity requirement. She was ordered to pay a £95 surcharge and £400 costs.

Bournemouth Echo

Birkenhead, Merseyside: Kieran Haynes

CONVICTED (2018) | Kieran Haynes, born 19/01/1998, of Devon Gardens, Rock Ferry, Birkenhead CH42 4RF – beat a young kitten, suffocated him with a duvet and then hanged him from outside a block of flats

Kieran Haynes beat a kitten, smothered him with a duvet and then hanged his body outside his ex’s flat because he had scratched him

Haynes pleaded guilty to causing unnecessary suffering to the 11-week-old kitten named Niko.

RSPCA inspector Anthony Joynes investigated the case after Niko’s body was found hanging outside flats where Haynes’ ex-partner lived on November 23, 2017.

Inspector Joynes said: “This poor kitten was found hanging from a piece of rope outside the block of flats, clearly having suffered a horrific injury.

“The kitten was recognised as belonging to Haynes, as he had posted photos of the kitten on social media pages before the incident.

“When I interviewed Haynes, he admitted that he had hit Niko with the back of his hand after Niko scratched him.

“He said that afterwards, Niko’s face became swollen and he became wobbly – at which point Haynes went out for seven hours.

“When he returned, Niko was in the same spot and was lying in his own faeces.

“He was clearly severely injured with a broken eye socket and was suffering from swelling to the brain.

“Haynes said that as he approached Niko to check on him and attempt to stroke him that the kitten had attacked him. At this point he has then covered Niko with a duvet and held it there until the kitten stopped moving.

“Afterwards, Haynes took Niko’s dead body and hanged him from a piece of rope outside a block of flats where his ex-partner lived.”

A post-mortem examination found that Niko had suffered from a broken eye socket and that he had been smothered so hard that he had lacerations on his lip from his teeth.

He also had a large bruise on his skull.

He added: “When I joined this job nine years ago I knew I’d be dealing with difficult situations and seeing heartbreaking sights.

“Nothing however can fully prepare you for dealing with cases such as this one, where the animal is already deceased when you arrive.

“This case involved the purposeful infliction of immense pain and suffering by way of physical violence on a completely defenceless and vulnerable 11-week-old kitten.

“Animals can’t choose their owners and unfortunately poor little Niko found himself in the wrong place, at the wrong time and in the care of the wrong individual.

“This case will stay with me for a very long time and I’m just glad that through our investigation we have at least not allowed Niko’s suffering to go completely unanswered.”

Sentencing:
16-week prison sentence; £115 victim surcharge. Disqualified from keeping animals for life.

Wirral Globe
Liverpool Echo

Ashton-under-Lyne, Greater Manchester: Ian Czajkowskyj

CONVICTED (2017) | Ian Czajkowskyj (since deceased), born c. 1960, of Elgin Street, Ashton-under-Lyne OL7 – left his dog to die an agonising death in a boiling hot car while he drank in the pub

Dog killer Ian Czajkowskyj from Ashton-under-Lyne in Greater Manchester, UK
Ian Czajkowskyj claimed in court that he suffers from memory loss

Ian Czajkowskyj admitted causing unnecessary suffering after locking his dog inside his vehicle in 35.2C heat while he drank in a nearby pub.

He had already been warned twice by the RSPCA.

But on June 19, 2017, police discovered seven-year-old Staffy Carlo dead in the back of Czajkowskyj’s white Fiat 500.

Staffy Carlo died an agonising death after being left in a hot vehicle by his owner Ian Czajkowskyj from Ashton-under-Lyne in Greater Manchester, UK
Carlo may have been left in a roasting vehicle for as long as nine hours

He had died of a massive blood clot brought on by severe heatstroke.

Mark Harper, prosecuting, said: “It is likely that Carlo was subjected to monumental suffering for a minimum of one hour but for a maximum period of nine hours.

“This was a clear case of the owner placing his own needs before those of the animal, especially because he had been warned before.”

On April 4, 2017, an RSPCA inspector found Carlo locked in Czajkowskyj’s car and left an animal welfare warning notice on his windscreen, although the vehicle was in the shade and the dog was asleep.

Then on May 26 police were called about a dog in the same car at Ashton Leisure Centre car park.

Members of the public had managed to open the door and release Carlo, who they said appeared “hot and bothered”.

Czajkowskyj had been drinking in a nearby pub and on his return was warned by police.

But around 10pm on June 19 Carlo was found dead in the car in Ashton.

Mr Harper said: “Temperatures that day were very high, up to 35.2C and with an average of 28C.

“There was a two to three-inch gap in the window.

“The dog was slumped in the back seat and there was a lot of blood.

“It appeared the dog had been dead for some time because rigor mortis had set in and there was a strong smell. Both the animal and the car were warm.

“Officers said there was saliva on the window.”

Shortly Czajkowskyj returned to the scene and stated he had been in the pub “at least a few hours”.

He later said he had parked the car around 4.30pm and gone shopping, then gone for a drink.

He believed he had left the dog in the car for only up to one-and-a-quarter hours.

In an interview with police he said he suffered from memory loss due to a heart condition and the medication he took for that condition and depression.

A vet who examined the body concluded Carlo had died of disseminated intravascular coagulation, the widespread formation of blood clots, caused by severe heatstroke.

The dog suffered breathing difficulties, suffocation and respiratory failure.

Chairman of the bench Fiona Maynard told Czajkowskyj: “You deliberately left this animal to suffer despite previous warnings. You left a dog in a vehicle in severe heat which resulted in its death.”

After the hearing, RSPCA inspector Nicola Waterworth said: “It is horrible to think what Carlo would have gone through and it is sad to think that we are still having cases where animals are being left in hot cars.

“People have got to realise that even on a sunny yet cloudy day the inside of a car can still become the temperature of an oven.

“If they are in any doubt they should keep the animal out.”

Sentencing: 12-week prison sentence, suspended for 12 months. Ordered to pay a total of £415. Banned from keeping animals for life.

Manchester Evening News
Mirror

Middleton, Greater Manchester: David Holden

CONVICTED (2016) | David James Holden, born c. 1982, of Elmbank Road, Middleton, Rochdale M24 2FR – suffocated a kitten then buried the body in a local graveyard

Kitten killer David James Holden from Manchester

Holden confessed to neighbours he killed the young cat, called Minnie, and wrapped him in plastic bags and put him in their wheelie bin. He later took him to Rochdale Cemetery.

Holden’s neighbours alerted the RSPCA, who launched an investigation and later discovered the dead animal.

Kitten killer David James Holden from Manchester

Following his arrest, Holden claimed that the kitten had died when he tried to pull him out from underneath a kitchen unit to put him outside. He claimed he hadn’t meant to kill Minnie.

The kitten’s body was taken for a post mortem where the vet concluded the kitten had died from asphyxiation which was probably the result of chest compression or suffocation.

Holden later pleaded guilty to causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal resulting in death.

At the time of the incident, in May 2015, Holden was subject to a community order for assaulting his former partner.

Kitten killer David James Holden from Manchester

Sentencing Holden the presiding judge said: “We do feel that this offence is so serious only a custodial sentence is appropriate.

“You caused the death and unnecessary suffering to an animal while under the influence of alcohol and then disposed of it in the cemetery.

“But we have taken into account that you have turned your life around.”

Sentencing: 12 weeks in prison, suspended for 12 months; £340 costs. Banned from keeping animals for ten years (expires April 2026).

Manchester Evening News

Stockwell, London: Patrick Bell

CONVICTED (2015) | Patrick Bell, born 28/12/1962, of Morat Street, Stockwell, London SW9 0RP – beat a dog with a metal pole, then attempted to strangle her and suffocate her by putting her head in a plastic bag.

Abused dog Jinx
Jinx was in a pitiful state after being terrorised by her evil owner Patrick Bell from London

Bell pleaded guilty to animal welfare offences relating to a Staffordshire bull terrier called Jinx.

He admitted two offences of causing unnecessary suffering by subjecting the female white-and-tan dog to blunt force trauma, and not providing for her needs.

The RSPCA was called with concern in July 2014 after a witness reported Jinx being beaten.

RSPCA inspector Esther Lincoln said: “I arrived at the address to find Jinx a quivering wreck under a makeshift kennel in the back yard. She was so terrified she refused to move and had to be carried out of the address.

“This is hardly surprising as this sounded like an incredibly brutal and vicious attack. A witness saw the defendant hit Jinx multiple times about the head and body with a metal pole and then put her head in a carrier bag and attempt to strangle her. Horrible.

“A vet examining her found bruising all about her neck back and flanks, and several sore points which were tender to the touch – a classic sign of beating.

“The good news though, is that there has been a happy ending. Jinx has made a full recovery and built up such a bond with one of the girls looking after her in her boarding kennels that she has been permanently adopted by her.”

Jinx is now in a loving new home
Jinx now has the loving home she deserves

New owner Jessica Lynn said: “Jinx was so withdrawn at first – she would not respond to any of the staff’s attempts to comfort her.

“But when I was introduced to her, she just came up and licked me. It was as if she chose me. We have been inseparable ever since and it was obvious I had to adopt her.

“She is a lot calmer now but she still has her moments when there is a sudden movement and she has a bit of a panic attack until I calm her down. It will haunt her forever, what happened to her, but we have a happy life between us.”

Sentence: total of 14 weeks in jail, seven weeks in prison for each offence, to be served concurrently; £80 victim surcharge. Disqualified from keeping animals for life.

Standard