Tag Archives: financial penalty only

Compton, Wolverhampton: Richard Orton

CONVICTED (2024) | Richard Robin Orton, born 27 September 1985, of Westland Road, Compton, Wolverhampton WV3 9NY – trapped wild birds and kept them in squalid conditions in his garden.

RSPCA prosecution of wildlife persecutor Richard Orton from Wolverhampton, who trapped wild birds in his garden.

Prolific wildlife persecutor Orton used Larsen traps in his back garden to ‘trap and kill magpies’.

RSPCA inspectors visited Orton’s home after being contacted by members of the public with concerns about the welfare of birds kept in traps in his garden and found two magpies in shocking conditions.

RSPCA prosecution of wildlife persecutor Richard Orton from Wolverhampton, who trapped wild birds in his garden.

One was housed within a wire cage with access to only half of the cage. There was only a small amount of ‘very dirty water’ present and no food the bird could access.

There was a ‘significant amount of faeces’ within the cage and it was ‘extremely foul smelling’.

In the section of the cage the bird could not access, there was what looked like a piece of rabbit skin present. The bird was in ‘poor physical condition with the breast bone prominent and muscle loss’.

The second magpie, which a vet concluded was ‘even thinner than the first’ with no fat covering and a loss of muscle, was housed within a wood and chicken wire cage with access to only half of the cage.

There was some dirty water present, which was green in colour, and there was no food present in the area of the cage the bird could access. Again, there was a ‘significant amount of faeces within the cage and it was extremely foul smelling’.

RSPCA prosecution of wildlife persecutor Richard Orton from Wolverhampton, who trapped wild birds in his garden.

A vet’s report said: “Both birds would have suffered unnecessarily for a minimum of two weeks but in reality likely longer. They did not have their welfare needs met due to the failure to provide an appropriate environment.

“From the amount of faeces observed within the traps, it is my opinion that no cleaning or removal of droppings had occurred within the previous four weeks, but likely a considerably longer period of time. It must be stressful and distressing to-be-living-in-the-same area as you pass faeces with no-way to remove yourself from these conditions.”

RSPCA Inspector Ben Jones, who investigated Romany gypsy Orton, said: “Every year the RSPCA receives many calls from the public concerned about the use of Larsen traps to capture wild birds.

“Larsen traps can be made of wood or metal and contain two or three compartments to allow the use of a live decoy bird, like a magpie, to attract other magpies in defence of their territory.

“Although such traps are legal, strict controls relate to their use. If these are breached – and it is easy to do so – the trap setter loses the legal protection of a general licence for trapping and killing magpies and could face being prosecuted.”

He continued: “People who trap magpies could leave themselves open to prosecution should they infringe any one of a number of strict conditions relating to the use of Larsen traps. Trap setters have to provide the decoy bird with food, water, shelter and a perch and inspect the trap every 24 hours.

“Sadly there is great potential for suffering of wild birds in being contained in cramped, unsuitable spaces, as we’ve seen here with the two birds found in Orton’s possession.”

Following his conviction under the Animal Welfare Act, Orton, who is originally from Tipton and has links to Rowley Regis, can no longer use Natural England’s general licences.

The magpies were both released back into the wild.

Sentencing | ordered to pay £312. Banned from keeping birds and ferrets for five years (expires April 2029).

BirminghamLive

Hartlepool, County Durham: Levi Swift and Bethany Greener

CONVICTED (2024) |Levi Douglas Swift, born c. 2002, of Cornwall Street, Hartlepool, and Bethany Nicole Greener, née Bethany Murray, born 12 February 1989, of Hutton Avenue, Hartlepool – starved their pet lurcher.

Animal abusers Levi Swift and Bethany Greener from Hartlepool.
Levi Swift and Bethany Greener caused six weeks of suffering to a lurcher. Images: Facebook

The charges brought by the RSPCA related to a six-week period between October 20 and December 1, 2023, when oddball couple Levi Swift and Bethany Greener failed to provide adequate nutrition for their brindle-coloured lurcher, Elsie.

RSPCA prosecution of Animal abusers Levi Swift and Bethany Greener from Hartlepool, who starved a dog nearly to death

RSPCA Inspector Claire Wilson said in a statement to the court that she went to Hutton Avenue on December 1, 2023, after a complaint was made from a member of the public about two dogs left outside the property without shelter or bedding.

One was said to be very thin and the caller described her as being “close to death”.

RSPCA prosecution of Animal abusers Levi Swift and Bethany Greener from Hartlepool, who starved a dog nearly to death

The inspector said: “It was immediately obvious that Elsie was in extremely poor body condition and emaciated.

“I could see all her bones protruding through her rough coat and could see her full spine, ribs, pelvic bones and shoulder bones without putting my hands on her.

“When I did stroke her the bones were spiky to touch and she hardly had any muscle visible. She also had hair loss along her spine.”

RSPCA prosecution of Animal abusers Levi Swift and Bethany Greener from Hartlepool, who starved a dog nearly to death

Greener told the inspector the dog belonged to her partner and they had rescued her two months earlier when she claimed she was in a “much worse condition with very little fur and struggling to stand”.

The inspector added: “She (Greener) then said that she couldn’t afford to take the dogs to a vet as she only had £5 left from benefits at the end of the month once her bills came out.”

RSPCA prosecution of Animal abusers Levi Swift and Bethany Greener from Hartlepool, who starved a dog nearly to death

The couple consented for the inspector to take Elsie to a vets where she received treatment and she was later transferred to private boarding kennels used by the RSPCA. A vet expert report stated that Elsie would have been suffering for at least six weeks because she was in an emaciated state.

Swift and Greener pleaded guilty to the charges.

RSPCA prosecution of Animal abusers Levi Swift and Bethany Greener from Hartlepool, who starved a dog nearly to death
Elsie gained weight in the RSPCA’s care

The court ordered the permanent removal of Elsie from the pair.

Following two weeks in RSPCA care, the brindle-coloured lurcher put on more than 3kg in weight and made a good recovery.

Sentencing | Swift was ordered to pay a total of £337 while Greener is to pay £257, with the financial penalties to be deducted from benefits. Both were banned from owning, keeping, or having any control over animals for ten years.

TeessideLive
Northern Echo

South Shields, Tyne and Wear: Bryan Owens and Katrina Elstob

CONVICTED (2024) | Bryan Owens and previous offender Katrina Bernadette Elstob of 48 Fox Avenue, South Shields NE34 9RN – failed to address their pets’ health conditions and weight loss.

RSPCA prosecution of South Shields couple Katrina Elstob and Bryan Owens in relation to a dog called Jack and a cat called Jess.

Elstob, who was previously banned from owning animals, and partner Bryan Owens admitted cruelty to an elderly Jack Russell called Jack and a cat named Jess. Jack was in poor bodily condition, suffering skin inflammation and dental disease and was infested with fleas, while Jess had an untreated skin condition.

RSPCA Inspector Trevor Walker visited the couple in September 2023 and was immediately concerned about the poor condition of Jack and Jess.

RSPCA prosecution of South Shields couple Katrina Elstob and Bryan Owens in relation to a dog called Jack and a cat called Jess.
Jack was dehydrated after being denied water and had a number of untreated health conditions

In his witness statement he said: “I observed an aged and very lean, Jack Russell Terrier type dog, that would have been described as tri-coloured at one stage, but now appeared more yellow possibly due to a heavy flea burden and his age.

“The cat, a medium long haired brown cat appeared in better condition, but once I had picked him up I could feel the very scabby skin under his medium long haired coat.”

RSPCA Inspector Walker transported Jack and Jess to a vet for further examination.

RSPCA prosecution of South Shields couple Katrina Elstob and Bryan Owens in relation to a dog called Jack and a cat called Jess.
Jess had a severe skin condition, which had not been addressed by her cruel owners

Inspector Walker continued in his witness statement: “Arriving at the door to the vet’s surgery, I noticed [Jack] was lapping the rain water that had collected on the top of the drainage cover, indicating that he was dehydrated.

“This condition was confirmed inside the consultation room when he drank from a bowl of fresh water for an entire minute, before it was removed.”

The vet said in their witness statement about Jack the dog: “There were four main concerns which included a very poor body condition score, which would have likely been present for at least a few months, a heavy flea infestation, secondary skin inflammation and severe dental disease.

“Based on the examination and the further test results; Jack had experienced unnecessary and avoidable suffering.”

Following the case, Jack and Jess were officially signed over to the care of RSPCA, where staff will now look to find them both loving new homes.

Sentencing |
Elstob – ordered to pay a fine of £164, a £66 victim surcharge and £250 in costs.
Owens -ordered to pay a fine of £80, a £32 victim surcharge and £250 in costs.
Both were given a seven year ban on owning all animals, with no appeal for five years (expires April 2031).

Shields Gazette

South Shields, Tyne and Wear: Paul Georgeson

CONVICTED (2024) | Paul Georgeson, born c. 1982, of Devonshire Street, South Shields NE33 5SU – for the neglect of an elderly dog found covered in fleas and scabs.

RSPCA prosecution of dog abuser Paul Georgeson from South Shields, Tyne and Wear. Image: Paul Georgeson - Facebook

Georgeson failed to ensure veterinary treatment was provided for the 13-year-old Staffy known as Zeus, who was suffering from a skin condition and ear inflammation.

As well as neglecting to provide parasitic control, Georgeson had failed to look into Zeus’s weight loss.

The court heard that in August 2023, RSPCA Inspector Helen Nedley visited Georgeson’s property after animal welfare concerns were raised.

RSPCA prosecution of dog abuser Paul Georgeson from South Shields, Tyne and Wear. Image of victim Zeus: RSPCA

In a witness statement, she said: “Mr Georgeson opened the back door to the property and let the dog, Zeus, into the back yard. The dog was in poor body condition and was narrow behind the ribs.

“The dog was dirty and covered with live fleas and scabs … (he) had misshapen ears and one looked to be thickened. The dog had long claws, and was repeatedly scratching himself.”

RSPCA prosecution of dog abuser Paul Georgeson from South Shields, Tyne and Wear. Image of victim Zeus: RSPCA

In another witness statement, a vet who assessed Zeus – who was taken into RSPCA care – said he had a “severe flea infestation” and was “constantly shaking/scratching”. She said his skin was thickened and scabby and sore.

Zeus was treated for fleas and worms, and given anti-inflammatories to help with his itchy skin.

RSPCA prosecution of dog abuser Paul Georgeson from South Shields, Tyne and Wear. Image: Paul Georgeson - Facebook

In mitigation, the court heard that Georgeson was overrun with animals and was struggling to cope and was no longer capable of looking after them.

Magistrates heard that he no longer had any animals and he was remorseful for Zeus’s body condition.

Sentencing | ordered to pay a total of £978 in fine and costs. Five-year disqualification order on keeping all animals (expires March 2029).

ChronicleLive

Driffield, East Riding of Yorkshire: Jonathan Botterill

CONVICTED (2024) | livestock transporter Jonathan Botterill, born c. 1977, of Spellowgate, Driffield YO25 – filmed picking up a pig by her ears and flipping her onto her back.

Cruel lorry driver Jonathan Botterill picked up a terrified pig by her ears and flipped her onto her back

Botterill, an employee of Chris Waite Transport, pleaded guilty to using violence likely to cause unnecessary fear, injury or suffering and for using prohibited handling techniques when unloading pigs.

He was filmed on CCTV lifting a terrified pig by her ears and flipping her onto her back at Cranswick Country Foods in Preston on August 31, 2023.

Cruel lorry driver Jonathan Botterill picked up a terrified pig by her ears and flipped her onto her back

The court heard Animal Health Officers from East Riding of Yorkshire Council began investigating following a referral from a vet who worked for the Food Standards Agency.

Botterill was trained in the correct methods of handling pigs and other livestock and had 20 years of experience. During an interview, he admitted it was not an appropriate handling technique and failed to use his pig board or ask for assistance.

Sentencing | ordered to pay a £670 fine, a £268 victim surcharge, and £884.94 costs.

HullLive

Scunthorpe, North Lincolnshire: Bogdan Gruia

CONVICTED (2024) | Bogdan Gruia (aka Bogdan Gruya), born 28 June 1990, of 178 Frodingham Road, Scunthorpe DN15 7NN – part of a group of men that stole a pregnant ewe from a farm, slit her throat and left her to bleed to death.

Prosecution of Roma gypsy Bogdan Gruia of Scunthorpe, North Lincolnshire, who was part of a gang that stole a pregnant sheep and illegally slaughtered her.

Roma gypsy Gruia, who came to the UK from Craiova in Romania, indicated a plea of guilty to aiding and abetting “a person unknown” to cause unnecessary suffering to a protected animal by cutting her throat and leaving her to bleed to death.

The remains of the sheep and her unborn lambs were found in an alleyway near premises in the control of Gruia, a garage owner who gave the court an alternative address of Digby Street in, Scunthorpe

The sheep had been stolen from a farm near Epworth, and subsequently slaughtered in an inhumane manner.

Gruia was found not guilty of handling stolen goods.

Prosecution of Roma gypsy Bogdan Gruia of Scunthorpe, North Lincolnshire, who was part of a gang that stole a pregnant sheep and illegally slaughtered her. This is alleged accomplice Elvis Anghel.
Alleged accomplice Elvis Anghel

A second man called Elvis Anghel, born c. 2002, of Church Lane, Scunthorpe DN15 7HD, was charged in relation to the same incident but the outcome of the case against him is not yet known.

Three other suspects are still being sought by Humberside Police who have released images of them.

Alleged accomplices of Roma gypsy Bogdan Gruia of Scunthorpe, North Lincolnshire, who was part of a gang that stole a pregnant sheep and illegally slaughtered her.
Alleged accomplices of Roma gypsy Bogdan Gruia of Scunthorpe, North Lincolnshire, who was part of a gang that stole a pregnant sheep and illegally slaughtered her.
Alleged accomplices of Roma gypsy Bogdan Gruia of Scunthorpe, North Lincolnshire, who was part of a gang that stole a pregnant sheep and illegally slaughtered her.

Speaking after Gruia’s conviction, PC Grant of Humberside Police’s Rural Task Force said: “This is the first conviction for an incident relating to the theft of sheep in the North Lincolnshire area since it became a local problem in 2018.

“Operation Bo Peep has been running since 2021 to tackle this issue and has, over the last three years, reduced sheep theft by 80%.

“I hope this conviction gives the farming community confidence that the police take this matter seriously and will bring offenders to justice.

“Three suspects for this incident are still outstanding, so I appeal to the public again to identify them.

“Anyone who believes they can identify the outstanding suspects can call Humberside Police on 101 and quote investigation reference 22901960470. Alternatively contact Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111.”

Sentencing | fined £769, ordered to pay a £308 victim services surcharge and £85 in costs to the Crown Prosecution Service.

Humberside Police Facebook post
GrimsbyLive

Leicester: Benn Ryan

CONVICTED (2024) | Benn Ryan, born c. 1988, of no fixed abode, Leicester – caught on camera whacking his dog causing the pet to yelp in pain.

Ryan was immediately arrested after police officers witnessed him hitting the dog.

The incident, which happened on Monday, March 11, 2024, was filmed and later uploaded to social media.

He pleaded guilty to causing unnecessary suffering to an animal and to being in possession of Class B drugs and was fined £80. No mention of a ban.

Leicestershire Police and the Court and Tribunals Service Centre could not say what had happened to the dog after the incident.

LeicestershireLive

Cullyhanna / Keady, County Armagh: Aeneas Carragher and Wayne Smyth

CONVICTED (2024) | farmer Aeneas Carragher, born c. 1964, of 85 Skerriff Road, Cullyhanna, Newry BT35 0JW, and animal transporter Wayne Smyth, born c. 1988, of Annvale Gardens, Keady, Armagh BT60 2RS – for the callous disregard for the suffering of a dying dairy cow.

Cruel farmer Aeneas  Carragher from Cullyhanna, Newry, County Armagh
Cruel farmer Aeneas Carragher

On Monday, March 11, 2024, Aeneas Carragher was convicted of one charge of causing an animal to be transported that was not fit for the journey. Carragher was fined £500 plus £15 offender levy.

Wayne Smyth was convicted of one charge of transporting an animal that was not fit for the journey. Smyth was fined £500 plus £15 offender levy.

The case arose on February 13, 2023, when a DAERA Official Veterinarian (OV), at an abattoir, examined an animal that was presented by Smyth on behalf of Carragher.

The cow was very thin and shivering. A lairage worker attempted to make the cow walk, but the animal immediately fell in the pen.

The OV carried out an ante-mortem examination of the recumbent cow. The animal was emaciated with prominent transverse and dorsal spinal processes, and the OV estimated that the animal had a body condition score of “1” or less.

The animal was humanely destroyed, where she lay, to avoid any further suffering.

The OV’s professional opinion was that this cow was too thin and weak to have been transported and was caused unnecessary suffering by this action.

ArmaghI

Stockwell, South-West London: Zainab Ayinla

CONVICTED (2024) | Zainab Ayinla, born 14 May 1986, of Loughborough Park, Stockwell, London SW9 8TP – starved a bulldog to death.

RSPCA prosecution of Zainab Ayinla from Stockwell, London, who starved a dog to death.

The emaciated body of the dog, known as Patch, was admitted to a veterinary hospital on December 17, 2022. He had lost an alarming 13kg since his last visit to the vet hospital, just seven months prior and his condition was described by a vet as “shocking”.

The court heard that Ayinla had contacted the vet hospital two months earlier mentioning Patch’s concerning weight loss, but failed to attend a subsequent appointment.

On December 17, Ayinla called the vet again, reporting that her pet could no longer walk and was showing signs of distress with laboured breathing and sporadic twitching.

By the time Ayinla managed to get Patch to the vet, he had already died.

Post-mortem examination revealed that Patch had 92g of plastic material in his stomach, pointing to extreme hunger.

It was concluded the direct cause of death was severe malnutrition. There was no underlying cause; he was able to eat but had no access to food.

The vet said: “His condition at presentation was shocking: he was significantly underweight with an accountable weight loss of 13kg in the past seven months since the last time he was seen at the hospital in May 2022, with very long nails and bed sores and urine scalding.

“Considering Patch’s presentation on the 17 December and the missed appointment in November, is it my professional opinion that Patch went through a significant period of suffering until the time of his death.

“Would the owner have him brought to us sooner and probably we would have been able to help him, whether from a medical point of view or supporting the owner in providing care for her pet.”

Ayinla’s defence was that she “had done everything she could for the dog”, having sought advice about worming and Patch’s weight loss, yet there was no corresponding record of this in Patch’s vet hospital documentation.

RSPCA inspector Philip Norman, who investigated for the animal welfare charity, said: “Animals are completely reliant on their owners to ensure their needs are met. Providing food and water is an essential.

“Owning an animal is a privilege – and ensuring appropriate care is a key part of the responsibility we have towards them.

“It’s sad that, in this instance, the owner of Patch failed to provide him with a suitable diet and as a result allowed him to suffer for a prolonged period of time.”

Sentencing | fined £300 and ordered to pay £800 in court costs. 10-year ban on keeping dogs.

News Shopper
London Post

Eglish, Dungannon, County Tyrone: Eugene Daly

CONVICTED (2024) | notorious puppy farmer Eugene Daly, born 6 April 1982, of 88 Derryfubble Road, Dungannon BT71 7PW – transported very young and unwell puppies from Northern Ireland to Great Britain.

Prosecution of puppy farmer Eugene Daly from Eglish, Dungannon, County Tyrone, Northern Ireland

Company director Eugene Daly, operator of a dog breeding establishment (DBE) licensed for over 200 dogs by Mid-Ulster Council, was fined after admitting to a charge of ‘transporting a dog not fit for the journey’. The paperwork held by Daly was also inaccurate and fraudulent.

Daly, sole director of Hillside Kennels Ltd and Daly Transport Ltd, was prosecuted after a consignment of his puppies was stopped and examined at Belfast Port.

Prosecution of puppy farmer Eugene Daly from Eglish, Dungannon, County Tyrone, Northern Ireland. Pictured with dog groomer girlfriend Sandra Millar, who is alleged to sell puppies on Daly's behalf
Puppy farmer and transporter Eugene Daly is pictured with dog groomer girlfriend Sandra Millar who is alleged to sell puppies on his behalf

The case arose as part of Operation Paws for Thought, a multi-agency initiative led by the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA) aimed at clamping down on the low-welfare trafficking of puppies between Northern Ireland and Great Britain.

Checks carried out on exports made by Daly discovered that destination addresses held for the puppies were false.

Veterinary examination of the puppies found that some of them were not eight weeks old.

Prosecution of puppy farmer Eugene Daly from Eglish, Dungannon, County Tyrone, Northern Ireland. Pictured with dog groomer girlfriend Sandra Millar, who is alleged to sell puppies on Daly's behalf

Many seemed poorly socialised, had extended tummies and a pot-bellied appearance consistent with worm infestation.

The bedding in the cages appeared wet and quite heavily soiled. This contradicted Daly’s assertion that the puppies had only been loaded less than two hours previously.

Daly pleaded guilty and was fined £400 plus £15 offender levy.

ArmaghI


Additional Information

Daly’s partner is Sandra Millar of Stiloga Road, Eglish, Dungannon BT71 7QH. According to the anti puppy farming campaign group Do Better DoneDeal Millar, a dog groomer trading under the name Happy Tails, sells farmed puppies on her boyfriend’s behalf, while lying that they are home-bred.