Swindon, Wiltshire: Ebony Eve

CONVICTED (2016) | Ebony Eve, born 23 August 1988, of Frobisher Drive, Swindon – fatally injured a Shar Pei after battering him with a hammer and stabbing him 20 times with a kitchen knife

Dog killer: Ebony Eve from Swindon and victim Nettles the Shar Pei
Ebony Eve killed subjected Shar Pei Nettles to a horrific death

Magistrates heard how Eve’s brother had been with her the night before the killing when she gave the dog ,Nettles, a bath because she said he smelled.

The following morning he found the dog’s bloodied body on the living room floor of their home and raised the alarm.

Police found blood splattered on the floor and walls next to where the dead pet was lying.

Eve admitted killing the dog straight away but could give no explanation for her actions.

Dog killer: Ebony Eve from Swindon, Wiltshire, UK. Picture: Facebook
2020 image of Ebony Eve who may also use the name Ruby Todd

In court, Eve admitted causing unnecessary suffering to the dog and was remanded in custody for her own safety.

She was later transferred through the Mental Health Act to an NHS medium secure unit.

During the sentencing hearing, magistrates said Eve, who was said to have severe mental health issues, will not be sent to prison but will remain in a secure psychiatric unit.

Dog killer: Ebony Eve from Swindon, Wiltshire, UK. Picture: Facebook

Chairman of the bench Felicity Dowell said: “We have read the two reports from the psychiatrists and we feel what they are recommending is the most sensible option.

“Therefore you are going to continue with the hospital order where you are now and you will remain there and you will get the treatment you need there.

“You will stay in hospital as long as it takes depending on how you respond to the treatment.

“We are not making any costs because of your situation nor are we awarding a victim surcharge.”

Sentence: to remain in a secure psychiatric unit indefinitely.

The Sun
Swindon Advertiser

Neilston, East Renfrewshire: Ryan Wallace

CONVICTED (2016) | Ryan Wallace, born 24/09/1983, formerly of Stewart Street, Barrhead and more recently Hillside Road in Neilston G78 3ER – starved and neglected a dog over six months

Dog abuser: Ryan Wallace from Neilston, East Renfrewshire, Scotland.

Lifelong loser Wallace, who lives on benefits with partner Claire Weir and their four children, caused unnecessary suffering to Diesel, who was found in an emaciated state by Scottish SPCA inspectors.

Diesel was starved by Ryan Wallace from Neilston, East Renfrewshire, Scotland.

When the distressed animal was examined by vets, he had lost a quarter of his body weight.

Diesel had been consistently undernourished and the animal’s bones were “sticking out of its paws”.

The pooch also had no muscle or body fat and vets said his torso and tail was covered in sores, and he was so hungry it had been “eating its own faeces”.

Wallace pleaded guilty to causing the dog unnecessary suffering and also failing to provide adequate nourishment, allowing him to become almost emaciated.

The offences took place between June and December 2013.

Diesel was starved by Ryan Wallace from Neilston, East Renfrewshire, Scotland.

Fiscal depute Franke Clarke told the court: “The accused contacted SSPCA about an unwanted dog. He clearly wanted it re-homed.

“Inspectors attended his home on more than one occasion.

“He said he was no longer able to care for the dog. It was dirtying the house and eating its own faeces.

“When the inspector asked to see the dog, she found its condition poorly and bad.

“Its paw bones were prominent, where sores could be seen on its tail and on its hind legs and both front legs.

“The inspector had immediate concerns for the dog and had him sign papers removing the animal.

“Thereafter the dog was admitted to a local veterinary service, where a report was sought to explain the condition of the dog.”

The vet’s investigation revealed Diesel had not received “nourishment for a matter of months”.

And after six days’ care, the dog had put on 1.7kg, or almost 4lbs in weight.

The court heard that Wallace had previously spoken to vets’ charity PDSA over his concerns about Diesel and he was asked to bring the animal in. However, he failed to do do.

Sheriff Simon Fraser said: “This dog was in a terrible condition. Photographs taken make horrendous viewing.”

He then told shocked Wallace the maximum punishment he faced was a year in jail and or a £20,000 fine.

He added: “However, you will not get custody, but you did neglect that dog for a considerable period of time.”

Diesel recovered from his ordeal and was rehomed.

Sentence: fined £475 (payable at £10pw). Banned from keeping animals for five years (expired June 2021)

Daily Record

Croydon: Paul Turner

CONVICTED (2016) | Paul Turner, born c. 1965, of Brookmead Road, Croydon CR0 3AR – left an emaciated elderly German Shepherd to die in a filthy kennel.

Neglected German Shepherd Max was put to sleep to end his suffering

Collapsed, emaciated and matted in filth, German Shepherd Max was found barely alive at the bottom of his owner Paul Turner’s garden.

The RSPCA had been tipped off that a dog had died in his squalid kennel on a grim winter’s evening.

Tragically, nine-year-old Max was so poorly that there was nothing that could be done other than end his suffering.

For Inspector Anthony Pulfer the sight of Max in his pitiful state will live long in the memory.

Paul Turner’s gypsy wife Jane Turner, who also uses the surname McArdle, did not face prosecution despite also living at the property where a horrifically neglected dog was found.

Turner, who shares the property at Brookmead Road with wife Jane Turner, aka Jane McArdle, and their two sons, pleaded guilty to animal welfare charges of causing unnecessary suffering to Max and not taking steps to ensure he had a suitable environment.

Speaking after the case, Inspector Pulfer described how he had gone to Turner’s address in Brookmead Road, Croydon, on January 4, 2016, after concerns that there was a dead dog in the garden.

The inspector said: “I can understand why the caller thought Max was dead.

“When I arrived he was completely collapsed in an emaciated state in a dirty kennel at the bottom of the garden but alive – just.

“He was in a shocking condition, the worst I have ever seen. He was not moving and I had to carry him to my van and take him straight to the vet.

“Sadly, there was nothing they could do to save him and he was so poorly that he had to be put to sleep to prevent further suffering.

“This was a horrible case of extreme neglect and I don’t think I will ever forget the sight of the poor dog lying there in filth in such a collapsed state that winter’s evening. Who knows how long he had been lying there in that terrible way?”

Sentence: jailed for six weeks (though he was bailed pending an appeal, the outcome of which is unknown). Banned from keeping animals for 10 years.

Evening Standard

Dalton-in-Furness, Cumbria: Michelle Brown

CONVICTED (2016) | Michelle Brown, born 19/09/1977, previously of Wellington Street, Dalton-in-Furness and as at March 2020 of Lancaster Street, Barrow-in-Furness LA14 5HX – abandoned four dogs, leaving them living in squalor.

Police and Barrow Borough Council raided Michelle Brown’s previous house in Thornton Park, Dalton, after concerned neighbours raised the alarm about the distressed animals on December 28, 2015.

Four dachshund-type dogs – Vince, Bo, Floyd and Tia – were rescued by the authorities and checked over by a vet and found to be dehydrated and underweight.

Brown was found guilty in her absence after she failed to turn up at court, but appeared for sentencing.

Michelle Brown from Dalton-in-Furness, Cumbria, UK, abandoned four dachshund-type dogs in squalor.

RSPCA prosecutor Mr Steven Marsh said Brown had been warned about the welfare of the animals several times since 2014 by their inspector Will Lamping.

He told the hearing: “Neighbours became increasingly concerned about the animals as they were licking condensation off the windows. They looked skinny and in distress. Initially the dogs were barking but that got quieter and quieter.

“When police went in they were hit with the overwhelming smell of faeces. There was faeces all over the floor and furniture which was getting mouldy. There wasn’t one clean area in the house for the dogs to sleep and rest without touching faeces. there was an empty bag of dry dog food in the bathroom and empty water bowls. They had drank the water out of the toilet.

“On a scale, three of them were level three of nine and the other, four of nine. One was emaciated.

Mr Trystan Roberts, defending, said: “Miss Brown is extremely distressed at the condition the dogs were found in. Sadly the last two years of her life things have spiralled out of control.

“She was in a relationship and had two grown-up children living at home and she became ill and had anxiety and depression.

“Her life became chaotic and she was having issues with her neighbours and moved to live with her parents. She didn’t like going back to the house because of the memories but would go there at night and give them water and food.”

Mr Lamping said: “I’m pleased she has been disqualified from keeping animals. These dogs were neglected over a long period of time and she shouldn’t be allowed animals in her care.

“She had many opportunities to work with us but refused.

“I would like to thank the neighbours who contacted us.”

Sentencing: 12-week curfew; costs and charges totalling £560. Banned from keeping animals for eight years (expires June 2024).

The Mail

Birkenhead, Merseyside: Kai Tomlinson

#MostEvil | Kai Louis Dale Tomlinson, born 07/09/1997, previously of Wallasey and more recently of King Street, Birkenhead CH42 2AJ – kicked a Cavalier King Charles spaniel named Holly to death after a row with his girlfriend

Dog killer Kai Tomlinson and victim Holly
Kai Tomlinson and victim Holly

Tomlinson pleaded guilty to causing unnecessary suffering to 14-month-old Holly, which led to her death.

Wirral magistrates’ court heard that Tomlinson’s ferocious attack on the defenceless animal would have caused her “physical suffering and mental terror.”

Dog killer Kai Tomlinson pictured outside court with his mother, who gesticulated rudely at photographers
Tomlinson pictured outside court with his mother, who gesticulated rudely at photographers

The body of the dog was put in a bin liner and was recovered by an RSPCA officer from a hole in the back yard of the premises which Tomlinson shared with his girlfriend.

Chris Murphy, prosecuting on behalf of the RSPCA, said Tomlinson initially lied about the incident when interviewed by police. He later admitted he had argued with his girlfriend and subsequently launched the attack on the dog after she had gone to school.

Dog killer Kai Tomlinson

Mr Murphy said Tomlinson “admitted he had anger issues and said he wanted to lash out at something close to his girlfriend.”

He added: “The dog was kicked repeatedly. This led to the head injuries and blunt force trauma which caused its death.”

Holly’s body was sent for examination at the University of Liverpool pathology lab, where she was found to have suffered a catalogue of non-accidental injuries.

Dog killer Kai Tomlinson

A veterinary surgeon who commented on the pathology lab’s report said Holly had suffered “unprovoked physical violence causing physical suffering and mental terror on an unimaginable scale.”

Zoe Keene, defending Tomlinson, said he had experienced a ‘momentary loss of temper’ which resulted in the dog’s death.

District judge Michael Abelson said Tomlinson had carried out an ‘unprovoked, vicious and brutal attack on a defenceless animal.’

He added: “This is as bad an example of animal cruelty that I have come across. It was a despicable act of brutality.

“One cannot imagine what would prompt any human being to act like this towards a poor, defenceless animal.”

Mr Abelson said the maximum sentence he could impose by law was six months’ imprisonment, and he also had to give credit for Tomlinson’s guilty plea.

Sentence: jailed for 22 weeks; banned from keeping animals for life.

Liverpool Echo
Daily Mail

Portglenone, County Antrim: Jeffrey Greer

CONVICTED (2016) | Jeffrey James Alexander Greer, born 12 May 1970, of Hiltonstown Road, Portglenone, Ballymena BT44 8ER – allowed his pet dog to starve to death

Dog killer Jeff Greer walked free from court with little in the way of punishment for his vile cruelty.
Dog killer Jeff Greer walked free from court with little in the way of punishment for his vile cruelty.

Animal rights campaigners reacted with fury after Jeff Greer walked free from court despite allowing his eight-year-old Rottweiler cross, Bailey, to starve to death.

Greer was given a conditional discharge after pleading guilty to failing to ensure Bailey’s welfare.

An interim ban on Greer owning animals was revoked.

Bailey died a slow, agonising death but the man who allowed it to happen wasn’t banned from owning animals.

Speaking about the Greer case Daniel Barclay of the campaign group Northern Ireland Says No To Animal Cruelty (NISNTAC) said that Bailey appeared “to have been subjected to torturous and agonising periods of starvation before being given one large meal which the body was not equipped to tolerate and the result was death.

“If you take on the commitment of an animal, you have a responsibility to ensure you have the correct knowledge and means to properly care for the animal.

“Another precious life has been ended through a conscious and deliberate choice, made every single day, not to adequately care for this dog.”

Mr Barclay called for tougher sentencing. “The harrowing image of this dog paints a picture of neglect and suffering and we are very interested to hear on what grounds the charge of causing unnecessary suffering was dismissed,” he said.

A spokeswoman for Mid and East Antrim Borough Council said they were “disappointed with the outcome of this case”.

Sentence: 18-month conditional discharge; £274 costs. In an outrageous decision by the Ballymena court, a previous interim disqualification order granted in October 2015 was revoked meaning that Greer is not disqualified from owning animals.

Belfast Telegraph

Whalley Range, Manchester: Shaan Malik

CONVICTED (2016) | Shaan Malik, born c. 1991, of Clarendon Road, Whalley Range, Manchester M16 – stabbed a dog with such ferocity he fractured her skull and ripped one of her ears off.

2019 police mugshot of Shaan Malik
2019 police mugshot of Shaan Malik

The five-year-old Shar-pei, named Boo, barely survived after being repeatedly knifed by career criminal Shaan Malik, who had broken into her owner’s Hapurhey home.

Malik stabbed Boo repeatedly and with such ferocity he fractured her skull and ripped one of her ears off completely.

Boo suffered appalling injuries after being attacked with a knife during a burglary
The sweet-natured Shar-pei suffered horrific injuries after her home was burgled by twisted career criminal Shaan Malik

In an ironic twist, Boo’s actions helped police crack the case. She nipped Malik on the finger, causing him to bleed as he ransacked the householder’s bedroom. A drop of blood on a glasses’ case he handled provided officers with the DNA sample that placed him at the scene.

Malik admitted burglary and a separate offence of handling military memorabilia taken in another break-in.

He was blasted by Judge Richard Mansell QC as he was sent down for three years and nine months – as much as the guidelines, the circumstances, and his guilty plea would allow.

The sentencing hearing was told Malik comes from a decent family, but had gone off the rails after developing a cannabis problem.

Shaan Malik, described as the black sheep of his family, showed no remorse for his vile cruelty towards a defenceless dog.
Shaan Malik, described as the black sheep of his family, showed no remorse for his vile cruelty towards a defenceless dog.

In a rare, touching courtroom scene, his relatives apologised to Boo’s owner and her supporters, who gave them each a hug after he was sent down.

Judge Mansell told Malik: “You appear to me to demonstrate little or no remorse for this offence. The truth is, Shaan Malik, you are a dishonest young man who will stop short of nothing to steal valuable property.

“You have also demonstrated a nasty violent streak, you attacked this poor dog, inflicting these injuries. You’re the only member of your family to take this path in life. I have to say they have my every sympathy.”

Boo's recovery was badly injured but slowly recovered although she may suffer long-term impact.
Boo was lucky to survive the attack.

Boo made a good recovery but may suffer seizures and sight problems as she ages as a direct result of Malik’s attack on her.

Sentence: jailed for three years and 9 months (for offences including burglary).

Manchester Evening News


Update February 2019

Malik was jailed for a further four years following yet another burglary. He was out of prison on licence at the time.

Telegraph and Argus

Sheffield: Simon Shepherd

CONVICTED (2016) | Simon Shepherd, born 19/07/1983, of Raeburn Way, Sheffield S14 1BX – terrorised an American bulldog, brutally beating him with a metal pipe and broom and leaving him outside in all weathers

Evil: convicted dog abuser Simon Shepherd from Sheffield, South Yorkshire
Evil: convicted dog abuser Simon Shepherd from Sheffield, South Yorkshire

Four-year-old American bulldog Bronson was abused for most of his life by his sadistic owner Simon Shepherd. The terrified animal was brutally beaten with a metal pipe and broom handles and made to stay outside on a balcony with no shelter in all weathers.

Neighbours even saw Shepherd beat Bronson severely and then throw cold water over him before leaving him outside in the cold for hours. He was rescued by the RSPCA.

Shepherd was found guilty of causing Bronson unnecessary suffering and banned from keeping animals for 25 years.

Bronson was subjected to regular violent attacks at the hands of his cruel owner Simon Shepherd from Sheffield, UK
Shepherd’s victim Bronson was made available for rehoming after his recovery.

Bronson is now being looked after in a foster home but is looking for a forever family.

Sentence: 200 hours of unpaid work and 20 days of rehabilitation activity; total of £260 costs and fines; banned from keeping animals for 25 years

Source: The Star but original news item removed.

Great Haywood, Staffordshire: Victoria Hollinshead and Neil Hough

CONVICTED (2016) | Vicky Hollinshead, born c. 1983, and Neil Hough, born c. 1978, of The Uplands, Great Haywood, Stafford ST18 0SH – failed to ensure the welfare of an underweight greyhound found covered in lesions and cigarette burns.

Animal abusers Victoria Hollinshead and Neil Hough
Drug-addicted Vicky Hollinshead and (inset) Neil Hough are banned from owning animals until 2026 following their ill-treatment of a greyhound.

The case against the couple was brought by the RSPCA who visited them three times in late 2015 when they were living in Stafford Road, Cannock.

On the first visit the greyhound, named Red and thought to be aged between eight and 10, was said to be in normal condition although there was concern about some loss of fur. Hollinshead told the inspector he had had an allergic reaction to a change in his diet and by the next visit the fur had started to grow back but Inspector Mark Crutchley advised he be taken to a vet if it persisted.

A social worker visited the defendants and expressed concerns about the greyhound and about a man who was staying at the house. There were suggestions the man had mistreated Red and had been seen to hit him and throw him across the room. He was told the man had been seen to stub a cigarette out on the dog.

Prosecutor Roger Price said: “This raised concerns. The next day he attended with a police officer and spoke to them. He noticed Red was very thin and missing fur.”

The pair are pictured during their appearance in court.
The pair are pictured during their appearance in court.

Hollinshead told them the dog had been to a vet and she had a letter from the vet but couldn’t produce it.

“The inspector saw lesions on the dog’s body, back and leg that were red and sore. The social worker) said it looked like a cigarette burn but (Hollinshead) said the lesion had been caused by the dog rubbing on the stairs.”

The court heard the animal was taken away by the social worker and the RSPCA arranged a visit to a vet.

The vet said the dog was emaciated, weighing 21kg when the norm was 25 kg.

A probation worker told the court Hollinshead had been diagnosed with bi-polar disorder and had not been taking her medication at the time of the alleged offences between November 23 and December 23, 2015. She said there were discrepancies in Hollinshead’s account and that the defendant was currently attending a course to control her heroin misuse.

Of Hough, who also has a heroin habit, she said: “He said the animal had been mistreated by (the lodger) and this had been allowed to happen. He feels he is partly responsible for the animal and he should have been there to protect it.”

Hollinshead told magistrates: “I would love to have animals again, I absolutely adored that dog. He saved me.”

Sentence: 18-month community order each, including a 30-day rehabilitation activity period. Total fines and costs each of £490. Banned from keeping animals for 10 years (expires June 2026).

Express and Star

Gosport, Hampshire: Janet Robinson

CONVICTED (2016) | Janet Robinson, born 8 November 1966, of Prideaux-Brune Avenue, Gosport PO13 0UE- kept a sick hoard of child abuse and bestiality images and shared twisted fantasies with a paedophile rape gang

Paedophile Janet Robinson. Picture: Facebook.

Police raided grandmother Robinson’s home after discovering chat logs on the now-jailed gang’s computers.

In court, a judge heard Robinson had a sick hoard of images, including a movie of bestiality with a girl aged between 12 and 13.

Robinson, who the court heard had been ‘shunned’ by the community since admitting her crimes last month, talked to men on Skype and Yahoo.

There was no suggestion she abused any children.

Janet Robinson pictured during her court appearance.
Janet Robinson pictured during her court appearance.

The court heard she made full admissions to police when arrested and told them she had performed a sex act with a dog before.

Judge Ian Pearson said: This was a sick fantasy of yours, you got your sexual gratification from the male with who you were discussing rather than the images.’

Janet Robinson. Picture: Facebook.

Hannah Duncan, for Robinson, said she had never been in trouble and had nausea from remorse. She added Robinson had lost her job, was told not to come back to a fitness group she attends and that a Facebook page had been set up highlighting her crimes.

Robinson pleaded guilty to 14 charges of possession of indecent images and one charge of possession of extreme pornography.

She had been charged with intercourse with a dog but pleaded not guilty and this was accepted by the court due to lack of evidence.

Sentence: 16-month suspended term for the child image offences and a four-month concurrent term for the bestiality –  suspended for two years. 50 days of rehabilitation activities; £350 costs. Robinson was put on the sex offenders’ register for 10 years. Banned from contact with children under 16 and from having a dog for 10 years (expires June 2026).

The News