Tag Archives: 2018 cases

South Shields, Tyne and Wear: Stuart Eunson

CONVICTED (2023) | serial animal abuser Stuart Eunson, born 12 February 1982, of Lucock Street, South Shields NE34 0NQ – neglected a dog found underweight, covered in faeces, with crusty eyes, leg and rib injuries and a severe skin condition.

Serial animal abuser Stuart Eunson from South Shields, Tyne and Wear. Picture: Facebook

Eunson was given a 10-year ban on keeping animals in 2020 in relation to another neglected Staffy. This followed a three-year ban imposed in 2018, which he had also breached.

In July 2022 the RSPCA received a tip-off that Eunson was keeping a dog at his home.

Neglected Staffy Rebel was traumatised in the care of serial animal abuser Stuart Eunson from South Shields, Tyne and Wear. Picture: RSPCA
Neglected Staffy Rebel was traumatised in the care of serial animal abuser Stuart Eunson from South Shields, Tyne and Wear. Picture: RSPCA

RSPCA inspector Rowena Proctor said: “When I visited Eunson’s home … [he] appeared at the door holding a white Staffordshire bull terrier which he handed over to me. The poor dog’s eyes were crusted closed, he smelled terrible and despite having a white coat, his legs were dark brown with what looked like faeces.

Serial animal abuser Stuart Eunson from South Shields, Tyne and Wear. Picture: Facebook

“Eunson confirmed that he understood that he was banned from keeping animals and while he allowed me to take the Staffie – called Rebel – to the vet, he refused to acknowledge the dog was his or to sign him over.”

The examining vet reported that Rebel had arrived in a very anxious and agitated state. He was underweight, had eye and ear infections as well as itchy, inflamed skin and a sore ribcage.

His skin and cat were soiled with faeces, he had overgrown nails and he was lame from a previous injury to his left forelimb.

Neglected Staffy Rebel was traumatised in the care of serial animal abuser Stuart Eunson from South Shields, Tyne and Wear. Picture: RSPCA

The vet concluded that the lameness following the injury to the left forelimb; the itchiness; the eyelid changes and the head shaking and ear rubbing along with the unsettled behaviour would have been a cause of distress to the animal and should have alerted the owner to Rebel’s poor health. It was the vet’s opinion that by failing to protect his dog from pain, suffering, injury and disease – which would have included seeking vet care for the dog – Eunson allowed Rebel to unnecessarily suffer.

Serial animal abuser Stuart Eunson from South Shields, Tyne and Wear. Picture: Facebook

Inspector Proctor said: “Not only did Eunson disobey court-imposed bans on keeping animals, but during this most recent incident, while it was still illegal for him to have a dog, he was keeping and clearly neglecting Rebel”.

Sentencing | 18-month community order, 15 rehabilitation activity requirement days and 19 ‘Thinking Skills’ sessions. Lifetime ban on owning animals.

Shields Gazette
Chronicle Live

Great Ayton / Stokesley, North Yorkshire: John Langan and Thomas McDonald

CONVICTED (2021) | serial wildlife persecutor John Alan Langan, born June 1986, of 12 The Hawthorns, Great Ayton, Middlesbrough TS9 6BA and Thomas Agar McDonald, born c. 1986, most recently of Riverside Nurseries, Stokesley, Middlesbrough TS9 5JQ – caught hare coursing.

Thomas Agar McDonald

On the afternoon of Saturday 23 January 2021, a vigilant member of the public called police to report that poachers were chasing hares with a dog in a field near Chapel Haddlesey, Selby.

Officers from North Yorkshire Police attended immediately. The suspects made off from the area in this Honda CR-V, and in the process drove through a red light. Officers followed them, and stopped them in South Milford, where they were both arrested, and their dog and car seized.

In court, Thomas McDonald, a convicted drug dealer, and John Alan Langan, who has racked up numerous similar offences, both pleaded guilty to hunting a wild mammal with dogs. McDonald also admitted an offence of failing to comply with a road traffic sign.

McDonald was fined a total of £239 for the hunting offence, as well as £100 and three points for going through the red light. Langan was fined £239 for the hunting offence, a forfeiture order was placed on the dog, and he was disqualified for five years from owning, keeping or being in control of dog.

Gazette Live


John Langan’s previous convictions:

In February 2018 John Langan was convicted of hare coursing alongside Tommy Jaffray from Thorntree in east Middlesbrough, a member of an organised crime gang currently serving a 13-year prison sentence for drug dealing.

Tommy Jaffray
Tommy Jaffray

In September 2017 Langan and Jaffray were spotted hare coursing by Lincolnshire Police

The court heard that Langan had previously been made subject to an antisocial behaviour order (ASBO) for similar offences.

In March 2010, he was arrested in Bridlington and charged with hunting a wild mammal with dogs.

He was found to be involved in a high number of other incidents of poaching and hare coursing between 2005 and 2010.

The ASBO lasted for three years, but he was again caught in the cruel act and fined at Lincoln Magistrates’ Court .

Two lurcher dogs, called Lucky and Spencer (pictured above), were seized and later rehomed.

Both Langan and Jaffray were fined £120 and ordered to pay £300 costs and £30 charges.

Both received driving bans and were given criminal behaviour orders (CBO).

Chief superintendent Mark Housley of Lincolnshire Police said: “We’ve waited for a result like this for some time but I’m very pleased now we have got it.

“Here in Lincolnshire we know that by seizing dogs we stop people wanting to come here for hare coursing, and it also prevents all the violence towards farmers and the damage to their property that goes with it.

“People living in urban areas wouldn’t believe how bad this is – it’s soul destroying for farmers and their families, many of who I know have struggled to sleep at night because of threats made by hare coursers.

“The welfare of the dogs is also very important to us.

“Only a week ago we came across a dog that had been left in a field to die as the hare coursers left her so they could escape from police officers.

“Our officers were horrified to see she had been fatally struck on her head.

“We will continue to make every effort to tackle this cruel and supposed ‘sport’, and get the animals into the caring home a dog should have.”

Gazette Live

Sutton-On-Hull, East Riding of Yorkshire: Susan Carmichael

CONVICTED (2021) | Susan C Carmichael, born c. 1948, of Dalsetter Rise, Sutton-on-Hull HU8 9JE – repeatedly breached a ban on keeping pets imposed for a 2018 animal cruelty conviction.

The “timid” cat has been rehomed and is now known as Cameron Poe.


Carmichael was found guilty of breaching a three-year ban on keeping animals imposed in relation to a 2016 cruelty case. This was her second breach.

In March 2018 Carmichael received a three-month prison sentence, suspended for 12 months, for the same offence by keeping two shih tzu-type dogs, known as Tia and Ty, and a budgerigar called Georgie. She was also found to have failed to protect the dogs from pain, suffering, injury and disease by not adequately grooming them; and failing to provide the dogs with a suitable environment.

She previously breached the ban In March 2018 after two Shih Tzu dogs and a budgerigar were found at her home and a further three-year ban was imposed.

RSPCA inspector Jilly Dickinson visited Carmichael’s home on 12 February 2020, following a tip-off that she had a pet.

There was no answer, but Inspector Dickinson returned to the house two days later accompanied by a council animal warden with a warrant to search the property for any pets.

Carmichael’s son was at the house and confirmed that a timid male chocolate-coloured Burmese/Siamese type cat belonged to his mother. The cat was taken into RSPCA care.

Carmichael denied owning the animal but this was not accepted by the court.

In sentencing Carmichael the District Judge said: “It is important that you understand one thing from your appearance today.

“Any more animals in your possession will result in you going to prison.

“That is the most important message you must take from today – there must be no more animals”.

Speaking about the case Inspector Dickinson said: “We rely on the public to notify us of any breach of bans and I would always urge them to report matters like this to us.”

Sentencing: 12-week custodial sentence suspended for 12 months; 12-month supervision requirement; a total of £538 in costs, fines and charges. A 10-year ban on owning animals (expires July 2031).

Hull Live

Lancaster, Lancashire: Andrew Rooney

CONVICTED (2018) | Andrew John Rooney, born c. 1973, of Mayfield Avenue, Lancaster LA1 2NY – found with two dogs, a cat, a budgie, a hamster and a guinea pig in breach of a 1997 ban on keeping animals.

Serial animal abuser Andrew John Rooney breached a previous ban.
Serial animal abuser Andrew John Rooney breached a previous ban.

Serial animal abuser Andrew John Rooney admitted breaching the lifelong disqualification between January 17, 2016, and July 17, 2018, by keeping two dogs, known as Shadow and Max, a cat known as Magic, alongside a bird, hamster and guinea pig.

Serial animal abuser Andrew John Rooney breached a previous ban.

Rooney pleaded guilty to causing unnecessary suffering to one of the dogs, a Labrador, by failing to seek adequate veterinary treatment for her skin condition between February and April 27, 2018.

Sentencing:
14 -week jail term, suspended for two years; rehabilitation activity requirement; 150 hours of unpaid work. Total of £615 costs and charges.

Source: Lancashire Post (article removed)

Malton, North Yorkshire: Anna Marie Sykes and Carly Sykes

CONVICTED (2018) | Anna Marie Sykes of Crabtree Drive, Malton YO17 7FQ and daughter Carly Marie Sykes, born 07/07/1994, of Dairy Way, Malton YO17 9FA – allowed their elderly Labrador to become emaciated.

Carly and Anna Marie Sykes and their neglected dog Bailey.

Anna and Carly Sykes both pleaded guilty to causing black Labrador Bailey (pictured) unnecessary suffering and to failing to investigate the cause of his poor body condition.

Bailey, who is said to be around 10/11 years old, was discovered, apparently abandoned, outside Anna Sykes’s property by the local authority who called the RSPCA. On attendance, inspectors found a dog that was so thin all of his bones were visible through his skin. He weighed almost half of what he should have done.

Bailey wolfed down any food put in front of him and after a fortnight on a normal diet, his weight had increased by a third.

Carly Marie Sykes
Carly Marie Sykes from Malton, North Yorkshire

The court heard that Carly Sykes was supposed to be looking after Bailey for her mother who had moved into a property where dogs were not allowed. She claimed in court that Bailey rejected all food put in front of him and she believed he was pining for her mother.

The RSPCA had asked magistrates to ban the pair from caring for dogs, but the request was declined.

They said because the daughter had another dog that was apparently healthy, she clearly could care for dogs properly and the mother had not had day-to-day care of Bailey..

Sentencing: Each woman was fined £200 and ordered to pay £150 prosecution costs and a £30 statutory surcharge. No ban.

Gazette & Herald

Taunton, Somerset: Haley Stratford

CONVICTED (2018) | Haley Anne Stratford, born 06/11/1982, of Trevor Smith Place, Taunton TA1 3RW – for cruelty to a cat

Cat abuser Haley Anne Straford

This is from the local newspaper’s round-up of court cases and no further details are currently available.

Sentence: £291 fine, £30 victim surcharge, £300 costs.

This Is The West Country

Bury, Greater Manchester: Kirsty Hamilton

CONVICTED (2018) | Kirsty Hamilton, born c. 1984, of Martin Street, Bury BL9 7SF – left an emaciated Arab mare with a severe hoof infection

Animal abuser: Kirsty Hamilton from Bury, Greater Manchester. Pic: Facebook.

Hamilton pleaded guilty to four counts of failing to meet the needs of Arab mare Blossom, under the Animal Welfare Act 2006.

Blossom was emaciated and suffering an untreated hoof infection
Blossom was emaciated and suffering an untreated hoof infection

The RSPCA was contacted by a member of the public who was concerned about Blossom, kept at stables at Nook Farm, Nook Lane, Tyldesely, Astley. On investigating, the mare’s bodyweight was rated one, the lowest on a scale of one to nine, and a vet found she had a bad case of thrush in all her hooves.

Inspector Danni Jennings, said: “The horse was clearly in an emaciated state and had other problems which had not been dealt with such as overgrown teeth.

“The infection in her hooves was awful and was caused by her standing in faeces in a dark and damp stable block for a long period of time.”

Kirsty Hamilton with boyfriend Joe Cannon. Cannon is from a notorious family of travellers.
Kirsty Hamilton with then boyfriend Joe Cannon. Cannon is from a notorious family of travellers, who deal in horses and also raffle them on social media.

In mitigation the court heard that Hamilton had personal problems and was pregnant.

Blossom was taken for treatment and is now in the care of the charity.

Sentencing: 12-month community order; curfew order; total of £1,585 costs and charges. Banned from keeping equines for just one year.

Leigh Journal

Atherton, Wigan: Aithne and John Declan Ashurst-O’Shaughnessy

CONVICTED (2018) | Aithne Ashurst-O’Shaughnessy, born 24/01/1995, of George Street, Atherton, Wigan M46 and John Declan Ashurst-O’Shaughnessy, born 14/10/1994, of Bolton Road, Atherton, Wigan M46 – allowed a pack of neglected ponies to roam on an industrial estate

Animal abusers: John Declan Ashurst O'Shaughnessy and Aithne Ashurst O'Shaughnessy from Wigan. Pics: Facebook

In a prosecution brought by the RSPCA brother and sister Aithne and John Declan Ashurst-O’Shaughnessy, whose mother is convicted horse abuser Lorraine Ashurst, pleaded guilty to a string of cruelty offences.

Horses neglected by Aithne Ashurst-O'Shaughnessy and brother John Declan Ashurst-O'Shaughnessy, both of Atherton Wigan

Aithne Ashurst-O’Shaughnessy admitted seven offences related to the care of seven Welsh-type ponies while her brother pleaded guilty to four charges involving looking after the same animals.

A grey mare was found by RSPCA inspectors with her feet in terrible condition. The animal was lame from severely overgrown hooves, had an abscess and suffered from chronic laminitis.

Horses neglected by Aithne Ashurst-O'Shaughnessy and brother John Declan Ashurst-O'Shaughnessy, both of Atherton Wigan

Five of the ponies were also not protected from pain and suffering because a farrier was not employed to look after their hooves.

The seven animals were also not provided with a suitable living environment.

Horses neglected by Aithne Ashurst-O'Shaughnessy and brother John Declan Ashurst-O'Shaughnessy, both of Atherton Wigan

John Declan Ashurst-O’Shaughnessy, who has a previous conviction for horse cruelty, admitted failing to provide suitable accommodation for the ponies, not providing them with daily care and supervision to prevent harm coming to them, neglecting the grey mare and not getting a farrier for two grey mares.

Most of the animals were pregnant and one sadly died from complications giving birth after the RSPCA had rescued them.

Animal welfare inspectors found the terrified creatures causing chaos at a glass manufacturer’s site in Hindley after escaping from their grazing grounds.

They had also crossed a main road streaming with traffic during their wanderings.

Animal abuser: Aithne Ashurst O'Shaughnessy from Wigan. Pic: Facebook

RSPCA inspector Alison Fletcher said: “This case highlights the need for responsible equine ownership. Horses need to be contained in a suitable and secure environment.

“There have been a lot of problems with straying horses in Wigan over the years and it causes a risk to the animals and to people.

“The ponies had got off the land where they were originally being kept, gone down a main road and ended up on an industrial estate. It was extremely dangerous for them and they were very fearful.

“This case also highlights the basic needs horses have, like regular foot trimming. If this doesn’t happen it can cause them immense suffering.

“You can’t just have a pet horse in a field. The costs of looking after them are extremely high and people need to think through what they are going to need before they take on an equine.”

The animals were so frightened they had to be sedated for inspectors’ safety during the operation to remove them on February 2, a day after the welfare charity was called about them.

Animal abuser: John Declan Ashurst O'Shaughnessy from Wigan. Pic: Facebook

Defending Aithne Ashurst-O’Shaughnessy, Paul Blanchard said ownership of the horses had been transferred to her from other family members in December 2017 and she had to take responsibility for what subsequently happened to them.

Peter Leather, representing John Declan Ashurst-O’Shaughnessy, said his client admitted neglecting the ponies after being tasked with maintaining the fences and keeping their enclosure secure as well as feeding them hay each day.

Sentencing:
John Declan Ashurst-O’Shaughnessy – 120 hours of unpaid work; £2,400 costs plus £85 victim surcharge
Aithne Ashurst-O’Shaughnessy – 70 hours of unpaid work; £1,200 costs plus £85 victim surcharge.

Both were banned from keeping horses for two years and deprivation orders were made to take the six surviving ponies and their foals away from the Ashurst-O’Shaughnessys.

Wigan Today

Sheffield: Ashley Cooper and Katy Gordon

CONVICTED (2018) | Ashley Cooper, born c. 1967, and Katy Gordon, born c. 1985, both of Ronksley Road, Shiregreen, Sheffield S5 0HF – failed to treat their dog’s painful skin condition

Animal abusers: Katy Gordon and Ashley Cooper from Sheffield. Pics: Facebook

The RSPCA first contacted Ashley Cooper and Katy Gordon about their cross-breed dog, Sasha, in 2016, after concerns were raised about her skin condition and general welfare.

Sasha the dog neglected by Ashley Cooper and Katy Gordon from Sheffield. Pic: RSPCA

Prosecutor Andy Cash said the couple initially heeded the RSPCA’s advice and took her to the vet, which led to her condition improving.

But in September 2018, the charity were contacted about Sasha’s welfare once again.

Sasha the dog neglected by Ashley Cooper and Katy Gordon from Sheffield. Pic: RSPCA

“She was [found to be] very low in weight, and her skin condition was frankly appalling…her skin was pustulating,” said Mr Cash, adding: “It’s the Society’s case that she was suffering for a considerable amount of time.”

He added: “Mr Cooper signed the dog over to the Society straight away, and with proper care, the dog has made a full recovery.”

When interviewed, Cooper and Gordon both admitted responsibility for Sasha, and described how they could not afford to take her to the vets, so attempted to treat her condition with products they had bought instead.

“There would have been all sort of alternatives available to them [to help with veterinary care], as I’m sure you will understand,” Mr Cash told the magistrates.

Sasha the dog neglected by Ashley Cooper and Katy Gordon from Sheffield. Pic: RSPCA

Mr Cash said the couple also owned cats and a Chihuahua dog; and said that while their cats were found to have fleas, there was no evidence of them being mistreated.

As a result, he asked for them to be banned from owning dogs specifically, which would allow them to keep their cats.

Cooper and Gordon were not represented in court.

Sasha has made a good recovery in the care of the RSPCA.

When asked if there was anything she would like the magistrates to take into consideration when passing sentence, Gordon said: “I’m really, really sorry.”

To the same question, Cooper replied: “I’m really, really sorry about what’s happened to Sasha. We have a disabled daughter and the Chihuahua is hers. She suffers from learning difficulties, and it’s going to be hard for her to understand where the dog has gone.”

Sentencing |
Katy Gordon: 40 hours of unpaid work and 15 days of a rehabilitation activity requirement
Ashley Cooper: 60 hours of unpaid work.
Each was ordered to pay £185 in costs.

Banned from owning dogs for five years (expires December 2023).

Sheffield Star

Wakefield, West Yorkshire: Kathryn Harpin

CONVICTED | Kathryn Elizabeth Harpin, born 01/01/tbc, of George-a-Green Road, Wakefield WF2 – left poorly 10-year-old cocker spaniel to suffer for at least five days in his bed when he was unable to move

Humphrey shortly before he died
Humphrey shortly before he died

Kathryn Harpin pleaded guilty to an offence of causing unnecessary suffering to a cocker spaniel called Humphrey.

The court heard that the RSPCA became involved in May 2018 when a member of the public contacted the charity with concerns about the dog’s welfare.

When RSPCA inspector Jenny Bethel visited Harpin’s address, she found 10-year-old Humphrey lying in his dog bed unable to move.

“He was in a very bad way,” said Inspector Bethel. “What struck me straightaway was how lethargic he was, he didn’t respond to anything and was clearly too ill to stand.”

Inspector Bethel took Humphrey to a vet, where examination showed he was underweight – weighing 16kg instead of the 23kg he should have weighed – as well as being covered in fleas. Blood tests showed he was anaemic.

“He also had severe dental problems and some of his teeth had completely worn down leaving pulp exposed,” said Inspector Bethel.

“We were shocked to see that he had a large ulcer on his backend which was infected, and as he’d been bedridden for at least five days he’d also developed a large and infected pressure sore on his left leg.

“Humphrey was clearly suffering and he was close to death. The vet believed the level of weight loss, muscle wastage and size of the ulcers had taken a significant time to develop, and they believed he had been lying in his bed with no movement for five days, just suffering.

“His prognosis was poor, and the vet made the difficult decision to put him to sleep as it was the most humane thing for Humphrey, who was in so much pain and discomfort.”

The court heard in mitigation that Harpin had no previous criminal record, that she was suffering from stress at the time of the offence and that she regretted what happened to Humphrey, who she had owned since a pup.

Sentence: 12-month community order to include 40 hours of unpaid work, costs of £300 and an £85 victim surcharge. Banned from keeping dogs for 12 months.

Source: Yorkshire Post (article removed)