Dunfermline, Fife: Michael Stobbs

CONVICTED (2023) | Michael Stobbs, born 17 December 1987, previously of Lumphinnans, near Cowdenbeath, but now living in homeless accommodation in Dunfermline – neglected his loyal pet dog over several weeks and left him alone in an empty property for four days.

Fife dog abuser Michael Stobbs walked free from court with a paltry fine. He was not banned from owning animals in future.
Dog abuser Michael Stobbs walked free from court with a paltry fine. He was not banned from owning animals in future.

Stobbs, now of Segal House, Segal Place KY12 8AZ , admitted that between January 10 and February 10, 2021, he caused Akita cross Samson unnecessary suffering by leaving him unattended for four days without food or water.

Akita cross Samson was locked in a kitchen with no food and water and left there for four days

He also failed to seek appropriate veterinary attention for the dog’s ear, eye and skin infections.

There was a request for disqualification but this was refused by the Sheriff.

SSPCA Inspector Nicola Liddell said, “On 10 February 2021, we attended Mr Stobbs’ property in response to calls to our helpline about a dog that had been left alone in the property for a number of days.

“On knocking hard at the door a muffled bark was heard indicating the dog was shut away in another room. Stobbs wasn’t home but returned to the property shortly after our arrival.

“Stobbs freely admitted to having left Samson unattended for four days, blaming the weather conditions for preventing him from tending to his dog.

Fife dog abuser Michael Stobbs walked free from court with a paltry fine.

“Samson was locked in the kitchen and the door was secured shut with a screwdriver jammed into the door surround which Stobbs used a hammer to remove.

“Samson was very friendly in nature and was delighted to see us. He was obviously underweight with his ribs and hips easily seen from a distance. His skin was very itchy and infected over his back with noticeable hair loss.

“Both eyes were leaking a yellow discharge and both inner ears appeared tender and infected. Samson’s claws were also very overgrown and were beginning to displace the alignment of his toes.

Fife animal abuser Michael Stobbs' filthy kitchen where he left a dog to starve for four days

“The kitchen was strewn with litter and hazardous items such as cutlery, potato peelings, old food containers, cans and mouldy milk cartons. There were faeces on the floor and up the kitchen units.

“There were no dog bowls, just empty plastic food containers. When given water, Samson drank thirstily. Stobbs also gave him a small amount of food which he ate ravenously. Even though he was so thirsty and hungry, Samson sat and waited until he was told to take it.

“We took Samson to be examined by a vet who found no underlying health problems that could explain his low body weight.

“During his ear examination, Samson howled in pain. The chronic eye infections will also have caused him considerable discomfort and irritation for a minimum of three to four weeks but likely much longer.

“Samson was then taken to one of our animal rescue and rehoming centres to receive the care and veterinary treatment he needed.

“Despite numerous attempts to contact Stobbs to arrange an interview, we received no response nor has he contacted us to check how Samson is doing.

“Thankfully, Samson responded well to medication for his skin, eyes and ears, and he also gained weight. No special or veterinary diets were necessary to improve his body condition.

Fife dog abuser Michael Stobbs walked free from court with a paltry fine. He was not banned from owning animals in future.

“We are disappointed that Stobbs only received a £400 fine this occasion as we do not feel this reflects the suffering caused to Samson.

“We hope he will be more conscientious in future about ensuring any animal he owns receives the appropriate care and veterinary treatment they require.”

Sentencing | fined £420.

Dunfermline Press
Scottish SPCA News

Garthamlock, North-East Glasgow: Henry Chrystal

CONVICTED (2023) | “puppy butcher” Henry Chrystal, born c. 1989, of Tillycairn Drive, Garthamlock, Glasgow G33 – failed to treat his puppies’ mutilated ears.

Greeder and puppy butcher Henry Chrystal from glasgow

In January 2023 Chrystal pleaded guilty to causing unnecessary suffering to puppies Donut and Dumpling through failing to provide veterinary treatment for injuries caused by a prohibited procedure, namely ear cropping.

Donut and Dumpling had their ears cropped by cruel Glasgow breeder Henry Chrystal
Mutilated for profit: Donut and Dumpling had their ears cropped by cruel breeder Henry Chrystal

A Scottish SPCA Special Investigation Unit (SIU) inspector involved in the case said they were alerted by a member of the public.

He said: “Both dogs had injuries to their ears. The wounds were red, crusted and looked recent.

“We immediately removed the dogs due to concerns for their welfare and took them to one of our centres to be examined by a vet. The vet examined their wounds and found they were still in a stage of healing and appeared to cause some discomfort when touched.

Donut and Dumpling had their ears cropped by cruel Glasgow breeder Henry Chrystal

“This illegal procedure would have caused these puppies considerable pain and discomfort, for purely cosmetic reasons.

“The procedures are likely to have taken several minutes and there will have been a lot of bleeding. Both puppies were then left in chronic pain until they received the care they needed at our centre.”

Donut and Dumpling had their ears cropped by cruel Glasgow breeder Henry Chrystal

The inspector said Chrystal had claimed he had owned the puppies for two weeks and that their ears were already cropped when he received them. He claimed they were given to him ‘on breeder’s terms’, meaning he would keep them as a pet until the breeder required them back for breeding.

When asked why he hadn’t sought veterinary treatment for the puppies he said that he didn’t take them to the vet because they were ‘not his dogs to take to the vet’. Both pups have been rehomed.

Sentencing | 40-day restriction of liberty order. Two-year ban on keeping animals (expires January 2025).

Daily Record


Additional Information

Henry Chrystal’s brother is Andrew William Stuart Chrystal, born 3 April 1998, and according to the 2022 public electoral roll living at Townend Farm, Kilsyth, Glasgow G65 0QE. Andrew Chrystal is sole director of Dog Food Bull Brand Ltd, which was founded in September 2022.

He and partner Melissa Brodie, born 11 September 1998 and a nursery nurse at Happy Days Nursery in Kirkintilloch, also breed and sell dogs – their ears routinely cropped – under the trading name Variety Bulls or VBulls. Facebook page here. Instagram profile here.

Andrew Chrystal is an associate of Thomas Rayment, a county lines drug gang leader, and Ryan Howard, who were exposed in a 2023 BBC Panorama investigation into extreme breeders (available on the iPlayer or via the YouTube link below). Rayment and Howard own and run Muscletone Bullys, a canine fertility clinic based in Wigan, Greater Manchester.

Variety Bulls’ Instagram profile is private but here’s a selection of images from the various Facebook profiles. No words needed

We now understand that the two puppies for which Henry Chrystal was convicted were actually bred and (allegedly) mutilated by Variety Bulls. This being the case, it would seem that the wrong brother was prosecuted and the authorities now need to take a close look at Andrew Chrystal, assuming he’s not already on their radar.

Rothwell, Northamptonshire: Claire Jones

CONVICTED (2023) | Claire Jones, born 28 September 1973, of Market Hill, Rothwell, Kettering NN14 6BW – kept horses in ‘cruel and degrading’ conditions.

Horse abuser: Claire Jones from Rothwell, Kettering, Northamptonshire. Picture: Facebook

Jones was prosecuted by the RSPCA after inspectors found two of her horses with lice, cracked hoofs and urine scalds. Both were so lean that bones were visible.

Horses starved and neglected by Claire Jones from Rothwell, Kettering, Northamptonshire.
Claire Jones’s were found with lice, urine scalds and cracked hoofs

On April 14, 2022, an officer from World Horse Welfare attended the Rothwell yard where Jones was keeping her horses and found the stable to be very dirty with a strong smell.

Prosecuting, Janita Patel said: “Both [horses] were found to be in a very poor bodily condition.”

The filthy stable where neglected horses were kept by Claire Jones from Rothwell, Kettering, Northamptonshire.
The horses were kept in a dark and dirty stable in their own faeces, with no straw bedding.

The officer gave Jones advice on the horses and cleaning up the stable.

On two occasions over the next 10 days the RSPCA attempted to visit but the gate was locked. They applied for a warrant, before returning with police and a vet on April 28.

They found 12-year-old mare Pixie and two-year-old colt Gary in conditions which were ‘unsuitable and unhygienic’ with no proper bedding.

Horses starved and neglected by Claire Jones from Rothwell, Kettering, Northamptonshire.

Pixie was so thin that her ribs, hips and spine were clearly visible. She had patches of hair loss, obvious evidence of a lice infestation and her hoofs were overgrown, cracked and split.

Gary was excitable when he came out of the stable. His bones were clearly visible with hair loss and lice. He had hard matted faeces stuck to his hair because there was no bedding and he had to lie on the stable floor. Gary also had urine scalds on his leg and his hoofs were also overgrown, cracked and split.

The ground of the stable was saturated with urine .

Ms Patel said: “It’s shocking [that] they could be kept there 24/7.”

Horses neglected by Claire Jones from Rothwell, Kettering, Northamptonshire.

A vet said that they had suffered for several months. A farrier who examined the ponies in May was of the opinion that their hoofs hadn’t been trimmed for between six and eight months.

Ms Patel said warning notices had been sent to Jones but that she had failed to accept the advice.

She said: “They have fallen on deaf ears.”

When she was interviewed Jones said she had little equine experience and that she used to use straw but that Gary would eat it.

The court heard she thought the skin issues were caused by fleas and treated it with white vinegar but that she didn’t notice the sores.

Ms Patel said Jones agreed that the horses were a bit lean and that the stable was a ‘shit tip’.

She told the RSPCA that money wasn’t an issue and that she didn’t know why she hadn’t got a vet out.

She later signed the horses over and admitted three animal welfare offences, including two of causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal.

District Judge Amar Mehta told Jones she was lucky the animals survived and that her offending crossed the custodial threshold – but that she had escaped going to prison by ‘a whisker’.

He said: “You kept these horses in a condition which, when one looks at the photographs, makes the court shudder.

“That is not how to keep animals. You kept them in cruel and degrading conditions.”

Sentencing | 26 weeks in prison, suspended for 18 months; 150 hours of unpaid work; costs and surcharge totalling of £654. Disqualified from keeping animals for 10 years.

Northamptonshire Telegraph

Brecon, Mid-Wales: Jac Jones

CONVICTED (2023) | Jac Elliot Jones born 5 January 1995, of Newgate Street, Llanfaes, Brecon, Powys LD3 but with family links to the village of Llandrinio – attacked his pet dog while high on drugs.

Violent dog abuser: Jac Elliot Jones from Brecon, Powys, Mid-Wales. Pic: Facebook
Persistent thug Jac Jones

Jones, who has at least one previous criminal conviction, launched a “drug-fuelled, unprovoked attack” on French bulldog Tommy in November 2022. His actions on the defenceless pet were described as being “of a serious nature … involving multiple kicks to the head and body”.

French bulldog Tommy was repeatedly kicked by animal abuser: Jac Elliot Jones from Brecon, Powys, Mid-Wales
French bulldog Tommy survived a drug-fuelled brutal attack by his owner

Jones admitted causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal and was jailed for 18 weeks.

A deprivation order was also made against Jones, preventing him from ownership of Tommy in the future

Violent dog abuser: Jac Elliot Jones from Brecon, Powys, Mid-Wales. Pic: Facebook

A disqualification order was also made, relating to all animals, and this will last for 10 years. It prevents Jones from owning any type of animal, keeping them, participating in keeping them and from being party to an arrangement under which the defendant is entitled to control or influence the way in which they are kept, during this period.

In addition, he was ordered to pay a surcharge of £154 and £85 costs, which are payable on his release from prison.

Powys County Times

Lancaster, Lancashire: Joe Whittam

CONVICTED (2023) | persistent wildlife persecutor, dog abuser and all-round scumbag Joseph Shaun Whittam, born 7 June 1990, previously of Carnforth, Lancashire, but now of Greenset Close, Lancaster LA1

Cat killer, wildlife persecutor, dog abuser: Serial animal abuser Joe Whittam from Lancashire
Joe Whittam Whittam was disqualified from keeping all animals for life in December 2018, but officers discovered three dogs and four ferrets as his Lancaster home

Whittam, who was previously jailed in December 2018 for setting fighting dogs on a pet cat and a fox and failing to treat his dogs’ injuries, was caught breaching his lifetime ban on keeping animals.

In court on Friday 20 January 2023 he pleaded guilty to the following offences.

  • causing unnecessary suffering to a brown Patterdale terrier known as Thugly by failing to provide veterinary treatment for injuries following an encounter with a wild mammal
  • failing to take steps to ensure that Thugly’s needs were met in that he let him engage in an encounter with a wild mammal, leading to him becoming injured
Thugly had facial injuries consistent with fighting wild animals
Thugly had facial injuries consistent with fighting wild animals

He was also in breach of a disqualification order which banned him for keeping animals for life by keeping four ferrets and a dog.

In April 2021 officers from the RSPCA’s Special Operations Unit joined officers from Lancashire Police when they executed a warrant in Greenset Close, Lancaster,, due to a suspected breach of a disqualification order.

Thugly had facial injuries consistent with fighting wild animals

RSPCA inspector Jason Bowles said: “In the yard there were three hutches and two of those hutches were contained in a brick-built shelter and were positioned one on top of the other. In the top hutch, there were three adult ferrets that looked to be in normal body condition.

“Adjacent to the house by the back door there was a hutch on its own with a single adult ferret inside that looked to be in normal body condition.

“I was informed by a police officer that this ferret had just been transferred to this hutch at the start of the warrant being executed as it was loose.”

Cat killer, wildlife persecutor, dog abuser: Serial animal abuser Joe Whittam from Lancashire

A woman at the address claimed to own three dogs found at the home while Whittam admitted owning the ferrets. He was told to rehome them immediately.

Sentencing | four custodial sentences to run concurrently – 23 weeks’ custody for two offences in regard to Thugly and 18 weeks’ custody for each of the breaches of the disqualification order.

Lancaster Guardian

Birkenhead, Merseyside: Leanne and Jon Brookshaw

CONVICTED (2023) | backyard breeders Leanne Brookshaw née Griffiths, born c. 1990, and Jonathan Marc Brookshaw, born July 1986, of Bebington Road, Birkenhead, Wirral – left a dog to starve to death in an empty flat.

Bulldog Coco starved to death after her owners, newly married couple Leanne and Jon Brookshaw moved out of their flat in Dorset Gardens, Birkenhead, leaving her behind. A police officer attending the filthy property found the dog’s remains and alerted the RSPCA.

Prosecutor Peter Mitchell told the court: “[the officer] saw the flat was in a total state, with dog faeces on the floor and no sign of any food or water for the dog.”

RSPCA inspector Anthony Joynes visited the scene. He reported an “overwhelming smell of decomposition, faeces and urine”, and saw the body of the black-and-tan dog.

Dog killer: Jon Brookshaw from Birkenhead, Merseyside, UK. Photo: Facebook

Faeces and dried diarrhoea were on the floor of the flat, and Inspector Joynes saw there was no food and several dry, empty water bowls.

The flat was registered to Leanne Brookshaw in her maiden name of Leanne Griffiths and Inspector Joynes met with her and husband, Jon Brookshaw.

Jon Brookshaw immediately said: “What’s going on, how is she, is she dead? I’ll kill him”, referring to his wife’s brother Kyle Stephen Moore, who was also prosecuted in relation to Coco’s death.

Image posted to Jon Brookshaw’s FB profile in February 2021. The fate of this dog, believed to be named Fifi, is unknown.

It was confirmed the couple were responsible for the dog, but Leanne Brookshaw said she had been paying Moore to care for her.

When questioned, Leanne Brookshaw said: “We’ve been struggling yeah, I was there three or four days ago, she was skinny but she was alive.

“She couldn’t come with us because she was shitting and pissing everywhere.”

During formal interview, the mother-of-three said she had been given the dog on breeding terms months earlier, but admitted it may have been more than five days since she last checked on the dog.

She said she and her husband hadn’t taken Coco with them because she would be attacked by their other dog, Molly.

She said she had visited Dorset Gardens since moving, and saw water and biscuits but agreed the “place was a shithole”.

She agreed last time she checked on the animal, the dog was skinnier and had lost weight. She described the animal as having access to water but no food, and acting lethargic and weaker than usual.

She also said the dog had diarrhoea but she “thought it just needed feeding more”, before admitting the bulldog did eat when fed.

On May 17, 2022, Jon Brookshaw was formally interviewed. and said he visited Dorset Gardens when the body had been found but admitted that was the first time in months he had done so.

He moved out of the property in November 2021, and his wife moved March 2022. The dog had been left at the property for two months. He said his dog Molly was protective and this was the reason they couldn’t bring Coco with them.

Malcolm Gregg, defending, said: “The thought of them being sentenced to imprisonment horrifies them and terrifies them.”

“Clearly Coco was taken into their care for breeding.

“Clearly they should have taken proper care of Coco.

“All are equally culpable for the distress and suffering to the poor animal.”

Regarding Leanne Brookshaw, Mr Mitchell said: “She is very sorry, she does express deep remorse and she does have empathy for the loss of Coco. She does try her best but has clearly failed immensely in Coco’s welfare.”

He explained she was caring for her ill father at the time, including visiting him in hospital.

Similarly, Mr Mitchell said Jon Brookshaw was “extremely devastated by the impact of what has happened in this case”, and was “ashamed and embarrassed”.

Jon Brookshaw’s dog Molly was found to have a skin condition, but has now been safely rehomed.

Sentencing | 18 weeks; imprisonment each, suspended for 12 months; 100 hours of unpaid work each; rehabilitation activity requirement; a total of £628 in costs and surcharge. A FIVE-year ban on owning an animal (expires January 2028).


Kyle Stephen Moore of Oldfield Road, Ellesmere Port, was charged and pleaded guilty to the same charges. Details of his sentencing here.

Liverpool Echo

Lemington, Newcastle upon Tyne: Mark Gallagher

CONVICTED (2023) | Mark Gallagher, born 1990, of Gladstone Street, Lemington, Newcastle upon Tyne NE15 8DJ – locked his pet dog in a filthy room with little food and no water.

Animal abuser Mark Gallagher from Lemington, Newcastle upon Tyne

Crossbreed Tyson was just days from death when he was rescued by the RSPCA. The room in which he’d been trapped by his callous owner Mark Gallagher was covered in faeces and urine. The only furniture was an old dilapidated sofa with no cushions.

Tyson was starved almost to death by Mark Gallagher from Lemington, Newcastle upon Tyne
Tyson was starved almost to death by Mark Gallagher from Lemington, Newcastle upon Tyne

The court heard RSPCA inspectors were called to the address where Tyson had been spotted looking out of an upstairs window.

As no one seemed to be in, an inspector placed some sticky tape on the door and returned the following day.

Inspector Terri-Ann Fannon visited the address again and found the tapes were still intact – suggesting nobody had entered the door since.

Tyson was spotted at an upstairs window of the property

Tyson could again be seen in the upstairs window and appeared to be in an ‘extremely poor condition’ and was unable to make his way downstairs to the front door.

Filthy room where Tyson was trapped

Terri-Ann requested police assistance who forced entry and found Tyson with a small amount of food and no water in a room covered in faeces and urine.

After being seized and taken to the vets Tyson drank 1.2 litres of water in about three minutes and ate food given to him in seconds.

Prosecutor Alex Bousfield told the court Tyson was “extremely emaciated” when rescued with most of his ribs visible through his fur.

Tyson was starved almost to death by Mark Gallagher from Lemington, Newcastle upon Tyne

Mr Bousfield described how the dog “drank all the water it was given, very quickly. It drank 1.2 litres of water and just wolfed the food down in seconds.”

An examining vet found that Tyson weighed just 20.6kg and was given the lowest body condition score of 1/9. Vets found no underlying medical cause for his dramatic weight loss and it was due simply to lack of food.

His claws were also overgrown from a lack of wear through exercise.

In interview Gallagher admitted the dog had gone from being stocky to “looking like a whippet” but he had failed to take him to the vet.

This is Tyson before his owner effectively abandoned him
This is Tyson before his owner abandoned him. Source: Mark Gallagher / Facebook

He said his partner had left some months earlier and he now had a new girlfriend. He admitted he never took the dog out and left him behind as he spent time at the home of his new partner.

This is Tyson before his owner effectively abandoned him

In court, he admitted causing unnecessary suffering to Tyson by failing to adequately explore the cause of the weight loss. He also admitted breach of duty to ensure the animal was provided with a suitably hygienic environment.

Tyson was starved almost to death by Mark Gallagher from Lemington, Newcastle upon Tyne

Judge Robert Adams said: “In a couple of days the dog would have died. The dog was effectively starving to death. It is thought it would not have survived much longer.

“The pictures are dreadful, the state of the premises is dreadful. It’s just terrible. Any animal lover looking at those pictures would be appalled.

“He has abandoned a dog to meet its fate and in a couple of days the dog would have died.”

Judge Adams said the animal’s weight, at just over 20 kilos, was “as low as it could be without the dog being dead.”

Brian Mark, defending, told the court Gallagher has a history of mental health problems and added: “All this offending is entirely as a result of his mental health and the treatment of that mental health.”

The court heard Tyson, as well as a fish and parrot that were at the house, were signed over to the RSPCA and the dog has been rehomed.

Sentencing | eight months’ imprisonment, suspended for 12 months; rehabilitation requirements; £500 costs. Banned from owning an animal for five years (expires January 2028).

Chronicle Live
Daily Mail

Egremont, West Cumbria: Stephen Graham and Samantha Bagley

CONVICTED (2023) | Stephen Graham, born 1 December 1988, and Samantha Bagley, born 31 July 1992, of 8 Milton Road, Egremont CA22 2HD – starved their dog until he was reduced to “a bag of bones”.

Dog abusers: Cumbria couple Samantha Bagley and Stephen Graham are banned from owning animals
Dog abusers: Samantha Bagley and Stephen Graham are banned from owning animals

The RSPCA in Whitehaven received a rehoming request from Stephen Graham during November 2022 in relation to a Staffy named Keanu.

Graham, a career criminal with 42 criminal convictions to his name, claimed the dog had been losing weight over several months but this had escalated after a house move.

Keanu was skeletal after months of neglect
Keanu was skeletal after months of neglect

He said Keanu had been vomiting and losing control of his bowels, which he said was “ruining his expensive carpets”.

When asked why he hadn’t taken the dog to a vet, Graham said he couldn’t do so due to an ongoing dispute.

Graham said he had been feeding the dog baby milk and putting water in his dry food to fill him up.

The RSPCA offered to help but Graham said he no longer wanted the dog.

Keanu was examined by a vet who found that he was extremely underweight, weighing just 9.6kg against an ideal weight for his breed of 16kg. His bodily condition was poor and he received the lowest assessment score of one out of five.

In court Graham and his partner, 30-year-old Samantha Bagley, admitted causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal.

The pair, who arrived late for their sentencing hearing, were said to have various difficulties in their lives, including childcare responsibilities.

Passing sentence Recorder Tony Hawks told the couple he suspected “poor decision-making is typical of the way the pair of you live your lives”.

He went on: “As any normal person understands, taking possession of a dog — or indeed any animal — as a pet is not something that is to be done on a whim. It requires thought, planning and commitment.

“That animal put its trust in the pair of you and you betrayed that trust.”

Keanu is now healthy and enjoys going out for walks and playing with toys.
Keanu is now healthy and enjoys going out for walks and playing with toys.

Keanu has since been taken into foster care in West Cumbria. His foster carer said after the hearing she had been shocked by the couple’s neglect.

“I couldn’t believe, the state he was in, that he was even still alive,” she said. Keanu was now healthy and enjoyed going out for walks and playing with toys.

“He is really, really loving, and loves people,” she added.

After the case, Inspector Fletcher said the charity was always there to help people and their pets.

“The message is that the responsibility of animal ownership if a serious one. When you don’t take that responsibility seriously and don’t seek help when you need it, the consequences can be serious,” he said.

Sentencing | six-month custodial, suspended for 18 months. Graham was ordered to undergo probation service rehabilitation. Both defendants were banned from owning or keeping any animal for 10 years, and prohibited from applying to have that lifted for five years.

Cumbria Crack
ITV News

Crediton, Mid Devon: Liam White

CONVICTED (2023) | Liam White, born 6 July 1988, previously of Tarka Way, Crediton – used a hammer to kill a cat with unexplained injuries.

Cat killer and domestic abuser: Liam White from Crediton, Devon

White claimed he found his pet cat dying and decided to put her out of her misery with a hammer. He then dumped her body in the communal bin area of his block of flats.

Cat killer and domestic abuser: Liam White from Crediton, Devon

His lawyer told the court his actions were inappropriate but “well-intentioned”. She conceded her client had made the wrong decision by not taking the cat to a vet to be euthanised and acted in a brutal way.

The cat’s body was found about two weeks later in a bag for life with her litter tray.

A post-mortem found she had a fractured jaw and femur.

Cat killer and domestic abuser: Liam White from Crediton, Devon

The attack on the unnamed animal came a few weeks after a witness saw White headbutting his then partner. He had subjected the woman to domestic violence on other occasions.

White pleaded guilty to assault causing actual bodily harm, battery and causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal.

The court heard that White, who is said to have unstable personality disorder, has 17 previous crimes on his record, some for violence, but nothing domestic.

His lawyer said he had now moved on with his life and a new partner.

Cat killer and domestic abuser: Liam White from Crediton, Devon
Cat killer and domestic abuser: Liam White from Crediton, Devon

Judge Anna Richardson said the background to the violence was a volatile relationship. She said how the cat became injured was not part of her sentencing but she accepted White found it that way.

“Rather than take it to a vet you believed it was not going to survive. You did not know that and you responded by killing it using a hammer. I accept you were trying to prevent it suffering further.”

She said White is a good prospect for rehabilitation and made no order to disqualify him from keeping animals in the future.

Sentencing | 20-week suspended sentence with an alcohol abstinence requirement of 120 days. He was also made subject to a five-year restraining order not to contact the victim. He was ordered to complete a Building Better Relationships programme.

Devon Live

Methil, Fife: Mary Walton and George Todd

CONVICTED (2023) | Mary Walton, born c. 1960, and partner George Todd, born c. 1951, of Byron Street, Methil, Leven KY8 3JG – starved and neglected their pet dogs.

Animal abusers: George Todd and Mary Walton from Methil, Fife, Scotland. Image source: The Courier
Unremorseful serial animal abusers George Todd and Mary Walton are now banned for life from keeping them. Image source: The Courier

Mary Walton and George Todd, who had received a fiscal warning for animal neglect in 2017, received a lifetime ban on keeping animals after Rottweilers Beau, aged 4, and Nala, 2, were found starving and neglected.

Beau's skeleton was visible through his fur
Beau’s skeleton was visible through his fur

Beau was described as emaciated and scored just one out of nine for body condition. Nala was little better, scoring just two out of nine in the assessment.

Procurator fiscal depute Catherine Stevenson told the court two Scottish SPCA inspectors went to the couple’s home on June 28, 2022, after receiving a report of concern about the welfare of dogs at the property.

The court heard the dogs were in the kitchen and Walton needed her partner to help get them out, describing the pets as “wild”.

The fiscal depute said: “When the dogs were allowed out of the kitchen, they threw themselves into the room and began rummaging around and started licking anything that resembled a bowl.”

The dogs were removed and taken to a vet in Livingston, West Lothian.

The fiscal depute continued: “Beau was found to be extremely underweight, scoring 1/9 for body condition, with visible bones – including ribs and pelvis – and muscle loss”.

The court heard Nala scored a 2/9 for body condition.

Beau's skeleton was visible through his fur

The vet found the dogs’ ribs and pelvic bones were prominent, they ate “greedily” when offered food, had head wounds consistent with fighting and Beau had sores on the pelvis due to lying on hard surfaces.

By September 2022 the dogs were reported to be “doing well” and had gained 22% of body weight in just over nine weeks.

The cruel couple, who represented themselves in court, pleaded guilty to causing Beau and Nala unnecessary suffering by failing to provide them with adequate nutrition.

They admitted failing to seek veterinary treatment for weight and muscle loss.

They admitted a third charge of failing to meet the needs of the animals to the extent required by good practice, on June 28.

Sheriff Maryam Labaki described it as a “harrowing case” in which two animals “were starved and neglected”.

The sheriff said Walton had given an explanation of “not coping” but Todd had shown “no remorse”.

She added: “Your attitude is quite frankly despicable in the face of suffering you have caused.

“The court will, in relation to both accused, impose lifetime disqualification from owning or keeping any animal”.

Scottish SPCA inspector, Robyn Gray, said, “We’re pleased that Mary Walton and George Todd received a lifetime ban on owning or keeping animals.

“The couple previously received a fiscal warning in 2017 and we are glad that this outcome will prevent further harm to animals in their care.

“Both dogs were caused unnecessary suffering which could have been prevented.”

Sentencing | lifetime ban on keeping animals.

The Courier