Fareham, Hampshire: Nathan Daniels and Bradley Green

CONVICTED (2023) | Brad Green, born 19 November 1998, of 33 Salterns Estate, Fareham PO16 0SE and Nathan Daniels, born January 2001, of 27 Alexander Grove, Fareham PO16 0TU – broke into a zoo, threw a bottle at a giraffe’s head and vandalised enclosures.

Fareham men Bradley Green (left) and Nathan Williams broke into a popular zoo, persecuted the animals and vandalised the enclosures
Bradley Green (left) and Nathan Williams broke into a popular zoo, persecuted the animals and vandalised the enclosures

Nathan Daniels, who recently founded a company named Ripplesweets Ltd, cut the barbed wire fence at Marwell Zoo in Colden Common near Winchester. He and accomplice Brad Green then carried out the attack, leaving animals, including the giraffes, cheetahs and tigers “very distressed”.

Daniels pleaded guilty to damaging the penguins’ enclosure and a fence surrounding the zoo, while Green admitted damaging an enclosure containing the giraffes. Green also admitted an animal cruelty charge in relation to the giraffe, named Ursula. In her distress she had knocked herself against the door, sustaining two long gashes on her leg.

Charges against the pair’s friends Jason Huggitt, born c. 1998, and Coral Lock, born c. 1999, who were both present during the incident, were dropped. Huggitt had been charged with burglary with intent to commit criminal damage and causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal. Lock had been charged with assisting an offender, as she drove the other three thugs away from the scene.

Jason Huggitt and Coral Lock were present during the break-in, with the former initially charged with animal cruelty and burglary, but all charges against them were dropped
Jason Huggitt and Coral Lock were present during the break-in, with the former initially charged with animal cruelty and burglary, but all charges against them were dropped

Video footage posted to Snapchat at the time of the break-in on February 15, 2021, showed a bottle being thrown at the head of a giraffe.

A tiger was also filmed apparently being encouraged to approach a fence before being kicking out at and scared away.

Multiple police units, including armed response officers with night vision goggles, a dog unit and a helicopter were dispatched to catch the intruders following the incident, amid fears endangered animals were at risk.

The heard the yobs had cut through a ‘double chain link fence’ before entering the premises.

Animal abuser: Nathan Williams from Fareham, Hampshire. Pictured outside court. Image credit: Hampshire and IoW News.
Nathan Williams pictured during a court appearance. Image credit: Hampshire and IoW News.

Ellie Fargin, prosecuting, told the court the zoo’s exterior fence was cut so the pair could get into the grounds, while the doors of the giraffe and penguin enclosures were damaged.

Ms Fargin said the Snapchat video also showed the tiger in its enclosure.

The next morning, a plastic disinfectant bottle, sticks and stones were found in the tiger enclosure, while a bucket and another bottle of disinfectant were found in the giraffe enclosure, she said.

Ms Fargin said: “There is concern they had been thrown into the enclosure to cause distress as the tiger was behaving in a manner consistent with distress.

“Also, items were found in the cheetah enclosure.”

The injured giraffe was called Ursula, she said, while a door was found damaged with giraffe hair on it.

“The damage must have been caused by the giraffe or giraffes hitting it with force and that would have been done if they were in distress,” she said.

Ms Fargin said a life ring was found in the pool in the penguin enclosure and added: “The penguins displayed behaviour consistent with anxiety and distress from being disturbed.”

Daniel Reilly, defending Green, said to have attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, said his client has “deep regret and remorse” for his actions and threw the bottle at the giraffe “to get its attention”.

Brad Green (right) pictured with Jason Huggitt outside court. Image credit: Hampshire and IoW News.
Brad Green (right) pictured with Jason Huggitt outside court. Image credit: Hampshire and IoW News.

He said Green faced a “social media backlash” following the incident and got death threats.

Mr Reilly said: “He knows that what he did is something that is significantly serious and something he is shamed by, particularly because he is, at his very core, an animal lover.”

Graham Gilbert, defending Daniels, said: “The behaviour showed a marked lack of maturity on his behalf.”

He said his client has lost his job working for a contractor for Marwell Zoo.

Three of those involved in the break-in at Marwell Zoo were swiftly outed on social media
Three of those involved in the break-in at Marwell Zoo were swiftly outed on social media

Sentencing the pair the judge told them: “Almost two years ago, you two together had the idiotic idea of driving to Marwell Zoo during lockdown, when Marwell Zoo was closed to the public due to the Covid-19 pandemic.

“You, Green, broke a door at the rear of the giraffe house. You threw the bucket and bottle of disinfectant into the enclosure and you threw something at the giraffe which we see from the video that you took.

“It struck the giraffe on the neck. One of the giraffes had an injury to its leg, with two long gashes, which was discovered the next morning.

“It happened from the giraffe being distressed, knocking itself against the door.”

He added: “It caused a great deal of public outrage at your behaviour because people are rightly sensitive at behaviour causing damage to a zoo and to animals.

“You acted in a deplorable fashion for which you must be punished. Public outrage would be such that many members of the public would like to see you in prison for this behaviour.”

Sentencing | 12-month community order with 120 hours of unpaid work; £750 compensation each to the zoo.

The National
Express & Star


Additional Information

In early 2019 Brad Green admitted dumping the badly mutilated body of a goat in a supermarket carpark but claimed the animal was already dead when he found it.

The discovery of the animal’s brutalised remains followed a series of similar incidents in which at least five dead goats were dumped in towns and villages across Hampshire.

Daily Echo

Workington, Cumbria: David Meteer

CONVICTED (2023) | David Meteer, born December 1953, of West Ghyll Place, High Harrington, Workington CA14 5RS – threw his German Shepherd into a pool and hit him with a pipe.

Neighbours secretly filmed Workington man David Meteer terrorising his dogs
Neighbours secretly filmed Workington man David Meteer terrorising his dogs

Police were called to an address in High Harrington, Workington, at 7pm on June 17, 2022, to reports that a man was abusing his dogs.

Officers spoke to neighbours who provided videos of Meteer assaulting the dogs.

Pamela Fee, prosecuting, said the defendant was seen picking up the German Shepherd dog called Brody, and throwing him into a swimming pool.

Ms Fee said he was strangling the dog and hitting him with a blue pipe.

He was shouting at the dog, calling him a blonde bastard and a blonde tit.

Neighbours had captured the horrific abuse on their phones and the video footage was handed over to police.

The dog was seized by police and taken to the vet. He had breaking of the skin and whip marks.

Photos were provided by the vet which showed lacerations and injuries to the dog’s mouth, as well as other marks.

Meteer was interviewed by police and gave ‘no comment’ throughout. However, during arrest, he had admitted hitting the dog with a pipe and throwing him into a pool.

Ms Fee said the dog was ‘clearly terrified’ by the behaviour. She said it was a ‘deliberate attempt’ to cause suffering.

In an insane decision by the courts, these German shepherds were returned to the care of a man caught on camera abusing a terrified dog
In an insane decision by the courts, these German shepherds were returned to the care of a man caught on camera abusing a terrified dog

John Goodwin, defending, said Meteer had kept dogs for many years and had “lost it” following a fight between two German Shepherds which he owns.

District Judge John Temperley drew back from imposing a ban on keeping animals when passing sentence, after hearing numerous references which ‘spoke highly’ of Meteer, as well as the steps taken by a dog behaviour expert and with regards to anger management.

Meteer has now been reunited with five of the seven dogs.

Sentencing | 12-month community order with electronic tag; £6000 in compensation. No ban.

News & Star

Thames Ditton, Surrey: Jimmy Smith

CONVICTED (2023) | Jimmy Smith, born c. 1988, a traveller most recently of Thames Ditton, Elmbridge, Surrey but with links to Ashford, Hounslow and Feltham – killed two cocker spaniel puppies by repeatedly slamming them into a concrete floor.

Kent gypsy  Jimmy Smith killed two puppies by slamming them onto a concrete floor
Puppy killer: Jimmy Smith

Smith attacked the cocker spaniels – named Sky and Angel – in a despicable act of cruelty following a campaign of abuse against his partner.

Victims Sky and Angel
Victims Sky and Angel

“[Your partner] saw that you had both of her puppies on their leads and then heard a thud and the puppies screaming,” he said.

Judge Simon Taylor KC described the harrowing moment Smith took the lives of the two defenceless dogs at their home in Ashford, Kent.

Kent gypsy  Jimmy Smith killed two puppies by slamming them onto a concrete floor
Kent gypsy  Jimmy Smith killed two puppies by slamming them onto a concrete floor
Kent gypsy  Jimmy Smith killed two puppies by slamming them onto a concrete floor

“She saw you swinging the puppies by their leads and hitting their heads against the solid concrete floor, throwing them to the ground repeatedly.

“The next time she looked she saw that you were dragging the puppies along the floor by their leads.”

Kent gypsy  Jimmy Smith killed two puppies by slamming them onto a concrete floor

Following Smith’s fit of rage, one puppy died at the scene while the other was put down at a veterinary practice.

Kent gypsy  Jimmy Smith killed two puppies by slamming them onto a concrete floor

During the years prior to killing the dogs, Smith subjected his partner to persistent physical assaults, stalking, threatening and controlling behaviour.

Kent gypsy  Jimmy Smith killed two puppies by slamming them onto a concrete floor

Smith’s victim told the court in a statement she lived in “constant fear” during their 13-year relationship, and continues to feel terrified.

Kent gypsy  Jimmy Smith killed two puppies by slamming them onto a concrete floor

Smith pleaded guilty to two counts of causing unnecessary suffering to an animal, assault occasioning actual bodily harm, and controlling and coercive behaviour between August 2019 and August 2022.

Kent gypsy  Jimmy Smith killed two puppies by slamming them onto a concrete floor

The abuser, who has six convictions for 20 offences, was supported by about 20 family members in the public gallery.

They could be heard trying to console Smith after the judge passed sentence.

Kent gypsy  Jimmy Smith killed two puppies by slamming them onto a concrete floor

Representing Smith, Benjamin Hargreaves said he is illiterate, “finds language hard to comprehend”, and subsequently descends into aggression.

An RSPCA spokesperson said of the puppies’ deaths: “We are so sad to hear about this deeply tragic case.

“This shocking incident reminds us that pets sadly can be used as a way of controlling people, as a form of domestic violence.

“We would urge anyone experiencing these problems to seek help from the police or a domestic abuse charity, who will also be aware of any charities who provide pet fostering services to help care for animals while owners can get the support they need.”

Sentencing | jailed for seven years and five months. 10-year-restraining order.

Kent Online
Daily Star


Additional Information

In 2013 Smith was jailed for 90 days and banned from keeping pets for 10 years for failing to feed and get treatment for a sick lurcher puppy. The emaciated pup, dubbed Orphan Annie, was found weak, cold and barely able to stand due to ulcers on her paws.

Express

We are advised that these two cases are the tip of the iceberg when it comes to Jimmy Smith’s animal cruelty. More to follow.

Norton-le-Clay, North Yorkshire: George Turner

CONVICTED (2023) | George Turner, born c. 1986, of Village Farm, Broad Balk Lane, Norton-le-Clay, York YO61 2RS – left a filly to become so emaciated she could barely stand

Filly starved and neglected by cruel farmer George Turner from Norton-le-Clay, York
George Turner’s unnamed horse was euthanised after she became too unwell to be saved

George Turner denied causing unnecessary suffering and failing to meet the needs of the unnamed thoroughbred-type filly, but was found guilty of both offences after a two-day trial.

The RSPCA were alerted to the plight of the starving horse by a concerned member of the public. Inspector Alice Cooper subsequently attended the scene accompanied by an equine veterinary surgeon, two police officers and a representative from the charity World Horse Welfare.

When Turner arrived, he confirmed that the filly and four other thoroughbred-type horses belonged to him.

Filly starved and neglected by cruel farmer George Turner from Norton-le-Clay, York

Giving evidence in court, Inspector Cooper said: “The horse was very thin. Her spine was prominent and protruded like a ridge along her back, and the bones around her back end looked sharp and pointy. Her demeanour seemed very subdued, and she stood with her head bowed. When walking she appeared slow and quite weak.”

The young horse also had extensive rain-scald across her back and rump and had not been provided with any shelter to escape adverse weather conditions. The vet who examined the horse in Turner’s presence, confirmed the filly was suffering and she was seized by the police.

She was so poorly that she collapsed when transportation arrived and required support to get onto the trailer.

She was initially taken to a specialist equine hospital for treatment before being moved onto a boarding establishment where she had to be supported to stand up. Sadly her condition continued to decline and she was eventually put to sleep on welfare grounds.

A post mortem revealed she had an emaciated body condition, extensive ulceration of the stomach – which may have been predisposed by a lack of adequate food – and a heavy worm burden.

Filly starved and neglected by cruel farmer George Turner from Norton-le-Clay, York

Giving evidence, the vet told the court that clinical examination of the horse “showed an animal that was in extremely poor condition and was very obviously sick and in need of veterinary attention.

She added: “The horse was very dull and weak and it would have been obvious to even a lay person that she was in extremely poor body condition and emaciated. These factors were chronic in nature and a responsible, reasonable and caring horse owner would have recognised that the horse was failing to thrive and was becoming emaciated.

“The forage provided in the field for the horses was not enough to provide them all with their daily nutritional requirements. The filly may have experienced competition for food and as such should have been provided with ad-libitum food, endoparasite control and veterinary care.”

The vet said it was her professional opinion that it would have taken a minimum of six weeks for the filly to become emaciated and that she’d been caused to suffer unnecessarily for at least two weeks.

The court heard that Inspector Cooper made repeated attempts to contact Turner to interview him about the filly, but was told he was a “busy man”. In January 2021 a solicitor contacted the RSPCA to arrange an interview for Turner, but it never went ahead and Turner represented himself in court.

During the trial Turner stated he “had not done anything wrong” and that he did not want to be disqualified from keeping equines as “he had knowledge of horses and had been successful in raising them in the past”.

In mitigation he said he had financial difficulties, but did not produce any details to corroborate his circumstances.

After the case, RSPCA Chief Inspector Justin Le Masurier said: “This was a very distressing case and we would like to thank World Horse Welfare and other partner agencies for their assistance, as well as the members of the public who reported their concerns about this young horse to us.

“A responsible horse owner would have intervened and provided their animal with veterinary attention long before they had got into such an appalling state, but this didn’t happen and sadly this filly suffered unnecessarily for a long time as a result of Mr Turner’s neglect.”

Sentencing | 18-week suspended prison sentence; costs of £1928 plus victim surcharge. Deprivation order for the four other horses. Banned from keeping animals for 10 years.

YorkshireLive
Horse & Hound

High Wycombe, Buckinghamshire: Martin, Mary, Thomas and Winifred McDonagh

CONVICTED (2023) | travellers Martin McDonagh, born c. 1976, wife Mary McDonagh, born c. 1979, and their offspring Thomas McDonagh, born c. 1997, and Winifred McDonagh, born c. 2003, all of 5 Beechlands, Hazlemere, High Wycombe HP15 7FE- abused and neglected the puppies they illegally sold to the public.

Puppies rescued from a traveller puppy farm in High Wycombe, Buckinghamshire

Police officers attended a property in High Wycombe on July 29, 2021 and found a mix of 17 cocker spaniel and Cavalier King Charles spaniel puppies kept in crates and a van without a mother present.

They contacted the RSPCA for help and Special Operations Unit (SOU) officer Kirsty Withnall went to assist.

Puppies rescued from a traveller puppy farm in High Wycombe, Buckinghamshire

During the subsequent investigation police found adverts on Pets4Homes for cocker spaniels for sale at £1,300. The advert said the puppies were born to a ‘family pet’ and had been health-checked, vaccinated, and treated for fleas and worms. The advert said the puppies had been ‘raised in a busy household’.

Evidence suggested that Martin McDonagh had been trying to fraudulently sell the puppies as home-bred, despite them being sourced from elsewhere, possibly illegally imported from Ireland.

The council told investigators that the property did not have a licence for breeding or selling.

Puppies rescued from a traveller puppy farm in High Wycombe, Buckinghamshire

In June 2022, Martin McDonagh pleaded guilty to one offence of making false representations under The Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008. He was handed a seven month jail term and was disqualified from keeping dogs.

Further charges in relation to the abused dogs followed and in November 2022 all four McDonaghs were found guilty of failing to meet the needs of 17 puppies.

Puppies rescued from a traveller puppy farm in High Wycombe, Buckinghamshire

Martin McDonagh also admitted tying a cable tightly around an eight-week-old puppy’s neck, causing a painful injury.

Speaking outside of court, RSPCA Inspector Withnall said: “These puppies had been taken away from their mothers and moved to a strange location where they mixed with other puppies of differing ages. They were being kept in completely unsuitable conditions and one had a cable tie tight around his throat and had to be rushed to vets to have it removed.

“We know from evidence gathering that Martin McDonagh had been trying to sell the puppies but when police arrived at the property he was not present and the rest of his family were in charge of the dogs, who were in very poor conditions.

“Thankfully all of the puppies were removed, placed into foster homes and have since been rehomed, and are doing really well with their new families.”

Sentencing |
Martin McDonagh: 12-month conditional discharge order, prosecution costs of £500, a victim surcharge cost of £22. Disqualified from keeping all animals for 15 years.
Mary McDonagh: £150 fine, £500 prosecution costs. Disqualified from keeping all animals for 15 years.
Thomas McDonagh: 50 hours of unpaid work, £500 prosecution costs, a £100 fine. Disqualified from keeping all animals for 15 years apart from turtles.
Winnie McDonagh: 12-month conditional discharge. Disqualified from keeping all animals for two years.

Bucks Free Press

Brechin, Angus: John and Cynthia Stewart

CONVICTED (2023) | John Stewart, born c. 1960, and wife Cynthia Stewart born c. 1961, of Chapelton of Menmuir, near Edzell, Brechin DD9 7QN – subjected a dog and two cats to extreme neglect.

Animal abusers: John and Cynthia Stewart from Brechin, Angus, Scotland. Pictured outside court. Source: Courier\
During the court appearance of “cruel and neglectful” John and Cynthia Stewart’, the judge noted the couple’s lack of remorse for their actions. Image source: Courier

John and Cynthia Stewart were given a 10-year ban on keeping animals after all three of their pets were put to sleep on humane grounds.

The remorseless couple offered no mitigation as they were sentenced for shocking cruelty to a 17-year old border collie named Ben and cats Ruff and Tumble, aged seven.

Skeletal collie Ben was infested with fleas with the itching causing multiple skin lesions.
Starved and neglected: skeletal collie Ben was infested with fleas with the itching causing multiple lesions throughout his skin.

The stricken animals were rushed to a vet after being found in a state of suffering at the pair’s rural home by shocked Scottish SPCA investigators.

Collie Ben was severely emaciated. He had a cut on his leg so deep that the bone was visible, and was riddled with fleas. He was suffering from multiple skin lesions likely to have resulted from itching. He had severe alopecia and little muscle. His claws were overgrown with some curling painfully into his pads.

Ben’s body condition was given a score of 1/5.

Tumble was given a body condition score of 2/5. He was also suffering alopecia and skin excoriations. He had flea dirt throughout his coat and a heart murmur was detected.

He was given an ultrasound due to a bladder issue which had caused him to be pot-bellied. The cat was unable to fully empty his bladder.

Tumble also had a flea infestation, resulting in excessive itching and multiple lesions to the skin. He was also found to have a bladder condition which prevented him from urinating properly.
Tumble also had a flea infestation, resulting in excessive itching and multiple lesions to the skin. He was also found to have a bladder condition which prevented him from urinating properly.

The vet said Tumble’s flea infestation should have been treated and must have been bothering the cat for at least a fortnight.

Ruff had similar skin and flea issues.

After the vet’s analysis, it was agreed Ben and Tumble would be immediately euthanised.

Post mortems concluded Ben’s condition would have been “easily identifiable” to anyone who saw him.

An ulcer found on his right hip was a result of lying on a hard surface for a long period and would have taken days to weeks to develop.

Ben would have suffered from distress for days to weeks and from arthritis for months to years.

Sentencing the Stewarts Sheriff Krista Johnston said: “These matters are very serious and I take them very seriously.

“This was a prolonged, appalling, offensive, avoidable way to treat these animals, supposedly in your care.

“It’s inconceivable you didn’t notice.

“It appears to me you were cruel and neglectful.

“You’ve shown no remorse, no insight into the ways these animals were treated and no realisation of the pain and suffering they must have undergone.”

Speaking afterwards Scottish SPCA Inspector Karen Cooper, said: “We are pleased that the Stewarts received a ban and supervision order, given the severity of neglect that Ben, Ruff and Tumble experienced.

“Their sheer disregard for the welfare of their animals was shocking.

“Although Ruff was in a slightly better condition than Ben and Tumble, upon being transferred to one of our centres for further care and attention it was discovered that he had a cancerous tumour.

“The difficult decision was therefore made to put him to sleep on veterinary advice.”

Sentencing | 200 hours of unpaid work each, reduced from the maximum community sentence of 300 hours due to the timing of their guilty pleas; 18 months of supervision. Banned from keeping animals for 10 years.

Daily Record
STV News

Wincobank, Sheffield: Ian Collins

CONVICTED (2023) | Ian Collins, born c. 1970, of Hawkshead Road, Wincobank, Sheffield S4 9BB – caught on film repeatedly kicking one of his dogs.

Animal abuser: Ian Collins from Wincobank, Sheffield. Pic: Facebook

Footage of the incident showed Collins backing the dog into a corner outside his home and repeatedly kicked her in her side. The dog could be heard yelping in pain, before Collins shouted “get inside”, during the incident on November 11, 2022.

The footage was used as evidence against Collins, as he appeared in court where he pleaded guilty to causing suffering to a protected animal.

South Yorkshire Police Dog Legislation Officer Paul Jameson said: “We are currently dealing with our greatest demand of dog incidents, including those animals who pose a risk to our communities.

“Those who inflict pain and suffering on animals are not worthy of their loyalty and love.

“Incidents such as these can cause a dog’s behaviour to significantly change, and that behaviour can have an effect on people’s safety when a dog becomes scared and frightened.”

Collins’ dogs were removed from his care following the incident and will be looking for new, loving homes.

Sentencing | Banned from keeping dogs for four years (expires January 2027).

The Star
Yorkshire Live

Swadlincote, South Derbyshire: Gary Vivers and Gillian Clarke

CONVICTED (2023) | backyard breeders Gary Vivers, born c. 1959, and Gill Clarke, born c. 1961, of Cedar Grove, Linton, Swadlincote DE12 6QQ – kept seven badly neglected dogs in filthy kennels

Greeder Gill Clarke was convicted of animal cruelty in relation to seven dogs kept in disgusting kennels by her and her partner Gary Vivers. Picture: Facebook
Greeder Gill Clarke was convicted of animal cruelty in relation to seven dogs kept in disgusting kennels by her and her partner Gary Vivers

The seven dogs, which included Irish water spaniels and a springer spaniel, had been subjected to prolonged neglect by their owners, hobby breeders Gary Vivers and Gill Clarke, causing them to suffer both physical and emotional harm.

The couple's dogs were in a state of distress due to months of neglect which had affected them physically and emotionally
The couple’s dogs were in a state of distress due to months of neglect which had impacted their physical and emotional well-being

Vivers, who’s originally from Bathgate in Scotland, pleaded guilty to causing unnecessary suffering and failing to ensure the needs of the animals were met.

Kennels where Gill Clarke and Gary Vivers kept seven neglected dogs

The judge said of Vivers that “he had been responsible for prolonged neglect and that he had caused the dogs a high level of suffering”.

His partner Clarke was found guilty after a trial of offences involving the unnecessary suffering of the dogs. She was cleared of the lesser offence of failing to ensure the needs of the animals were met.

Badly matted dog rescued from greeders Gary Vivers and Gill Clarke from Swadlincote, Derbyshire

The pair’s animal cruelty came to light in August 2021 after a complaint was made to South Derbyshire about the constant barking of several dogs kept in kennels. The complainant also stated that the premises smelled strongly of urine and that they were concerned about the environment in which the dogs were being kept.

Council officers visited later that day and saw that there were numerous kennels in the garden of the property containing seven dogs.

Dog rescued from greeders Gary Vivers and Gill Clarke from Swadlincote, Derbyshire

The kennels contained large accumulations of dog faeces, smelled strongly of urine and were in a poor structural condition with potential physical risks of harm to the animals.

Some of the dogs had severe matting of their fur and appeared to be in a poor physical and emotional condition.

Dog rescued from greeders Gary Vivers and Gill Clarke from Swadlincote, Derbyshire

Council officers decided that the welfare conditions were so poor that they needed to make the very exceptional use of animal welfare powers to take immediate possession of the dogs, which were taken into the care of a local dog kennels.

Dog rescued from greeders Gary Vivers and Gill Clarke from Swadlincote, Derbyshire

The dogs were examined by a vet the following day who said they had been neglected over a long period of time and agreed that the dogs needed to be taken into possession to prevent suffering.

An eighth dog was later removed from the property in September 2021.

All of the dogs recovered and were rehomed.

Sentencing |

Vivers was sentenced to 10 weeks in prison, which was suspended for 18 months, made the subject of a rehabilitation order and was banned from keeping animals for five years (expires January 2028).

Clarke was banned from keeping animals for just two years (expires January 2025).

The couple were ordered to pay fines and costs totalling £4, 816.

Staffordshire Live
Derby Telegraph

Lancaster, Lancashire: Daniel Welbourne

CONVICTED (2023) | Daniel Welbourne, born c. 1964, of Thurnham Street, Lancaster LA1 – failed to get veterinary treatment for a young border collie found straying and in significant pain

Animal abuser Daniel Welbourne from Lancaster, UK. Photo: Facebook
Animal abuser Daniel Welbourne from Lancaster

Welbourne was found guilty of causing unnecessary suffering to the male border collie named Reggie.

He let the badly injured dog roam unsupervised in the city while he was in ‘significant pain and distress’ and had lost the use of both of his back legs.

Reggie was in immense pain and had lost the use of his back legs. Photo: RSPCA
Reggie was in immense pain and had lost the use of his back legs

Reggie was suffering from a severe flea infestation and a suspected broken pelvis when he was collected by an RSPCA officer after being found collapsed in a garden on August 14, 2022.

Despite his lack of mobility, he had been regularly allowed to wander the streets in the week before he was found and had not been seen by a vet.

In court, Welbourne admitted one charge of causing unnecessary suffering, following a prosecution by the RSPCA.

The court heard how Reggie was rushed to the RSPCA’s Greater Manchester Animal Hospital after the charity had been called by a concerned member of the public.

Reggie was in immense pain and had lost the use of his back legs. Photo: RSPCA
Despite the best efforts of RSPCA vets, Reggie didn’t recover and was euthanised to end his suffering

On arrival, he was reluctant to get up from a sitting position or attempt to get down from the kennel in the back of the officer’s van.

After being lifted out onto the ground, his body language was that of an extremely uncomfortable dog who was tense, hunched up, panting heavily and fearful of making any attempt to change position or walk, the court was told.

Severely lame in both back legs, Reggie would cry out in pain after trying to walk just three or four metres.

He was carried into the hospital and had to be sedated to allow vets to examine him.

Spinal or neurological problems were thought to be the most likely issues after x-rays ruled out chest, pelvic and rib injuries.

In evidence to the court, one of the examining vets said: “Reggie was likely to have been in significant pain and distress throughout this week.

“He was unable to express normal behaviour and was suffering significantly both with severe pain, and with fear and anxiety related to the expectation of further pain.

“His owner failed to present Reggie for veterinary care during this week, despite him showing clear evidence of pain and injury.”

Welbourne was interviewed by RSPCA inspector Amy McIntosh on August 22.

He told the officer he didn’t think he had done anything wrong and that he thought his dog would get better on his own.

Despite being given strong painkillers and anti inflammatories, Reggie’s condition sadly did not improve in the days that followed and he remained in significant discomfort, becoming distressed during handling.

The veterinary team who were caring for him advised Welbourne that he was suffering and the kindest thing to do would be to put him to sleep, which his owner consented to.

Animal abuser Daniel Welbourne from Lancaster, UK. Photo: Facebook

Speaking about the case Inspector McIntosh said: “This was an extremely sad case as Reggie was only a young dog and his owner should have sought veterinary help at a much earlier stage.

“His welfare needs were clearly not being met and despite the fact he was severely lame in both back legs, he was left to roam unsupervised, prolonging his pain and putting him in even further danger.”

Sentencing | 12-month community order with 200 hours of unpaid work. Ordered to pay a total of £250 in costs and surcharge. RSPCA’s costs of £1667.88 are to be paid from central funds. Four year ban on keeping dogs (expires January 2027).

Lancashire Post
ITV News

Garston, Liverpool: Christy Hewitt and Chantell Duvall-Gregory

CONVICTED (2023) | Christy Carl Hewitt, born c. 2001, and Chantell Duvall-Gregory*, born 24 January 2002, previously of Windfield Road, Garston, Liverpool L19 – abused and battered a young Belgian shepherd dog over several weeks and dumped his body when he died.

Dog killers Christy Hewitt and Chantell Duvall-Gregory from Liverpool

Hewitt and Duvall-Gregory, who are parents, pleaded guilty to a string of animal cruelty charges after the battered body of a two-year Belgian Shepherd, known as Snoop, was found stashed in a suitcase and dumped on the bank of the River Mersey.

The Belgian Shepherd as found dead inside a bright pink locked suitcase, which had the name ‘Chantell’ written on it

The pair pleaded guilty to inflicting blunt force trauma, physical violence and abusive behaviour on Snoop, to failing to provide an adequate diet, and to failing to take him to a vet when necessary. They also pleaded guilty to one count of breaching their duties as people responsible for ensuring the welfare of an animal.

The pair battered and abused Snoop, who was found dead inside a bright pink locked suitcase by a dog walker near the Speke and Garston Nature Reserve on January 11, 2022.

The offences took place between April 1 and December 22 2021 at the couple’s former home in Winfield Road, Garston.

The pair subjected the dog to months of abuse. The court heard there was evidence that both had punched, kicked and stamped on the dog. He had “extensive bruising and fractures to the ribs” and two fractured canines. It was clear the injures were non-accidental. The rib injuries were determined to be 6/8 weeks old as they had begun to heal.

Dog killers Christy Hewitt and Chantell Duvall-Gregory from Liverpool. The pair are pictured during their court appearance.

Prosecutor Peter Mitchell said: “As you know, the ribs are nature’s shock absorbers so it takes significant force to break them. They minimised exactly how much force they used on this dog”.

Snoop was also punched to the face, causing damage to his canine teeth, but it was not possible to determine exactly which of the pair caused which injury.

A youth witness previously stated she saw Duvall-Gregory once hit Snoop so hard with a wooden spoon it broke.

Dog killer Chantell Duvall-Gregory from Liverpool

Duvall-Gregory had admitted she would kick Snoop on the bottom, but not hard, and would give him a “slap on the nose”. Mr Mitchell said: “She accepted she caused a number of the injuries, but minimises how serious the injuries were.”

Similarly, Hewitt said he would “give it a slap if the dog was pissing and shitting in the house”, but not hard.

Mr Mitchell said: “The dog was not fed dog food at all, and was only given leftover food.”

Dog killer Christy Hewitt from Liverpool

It was determined Snoop had died of hemorrhagic gastroenteritis after eating a granola bar with raisins given to him by Duvall-Gregory.

Mr Mitchell detailed that on the day he died, “the dog had lost the use of its bowels, and black tar was coming out” of its bottom.

Vicky Balenski, defending, said Snoop had become ill and died on December 23, and Duvall-Gregory and Hewitt had called several vets to help the animal but no-one was available due to the proximity to Christmas.

She also said the dog had already passed away before being put into the suitcase, and they were not trying to hide anything when disposing of the body.

Ms Balenski said her clients claimed Snoop would not eat dog food, and that Duvall-Gregory thought she had removed all the raisins from the granola before feeding it to the dog.

Dog killer Chantell Duvall-Gregory from Liverpool

In sentencing, his honour Judge James Hatton said: “For a lengthy period of time, this dog has been beaten and abused”.

Addressing Duvall-Gregory, he said: “This is prolonged ill treatment and neglectful treatment of this animal and has resulted in its untimely death.

“It is abundantly clear that you beat that defenceless animal over a lengthy period of time.”

He said they left injuries untreated which caused more suffering for the animal.

Speaking to Hewitt, the judge said: “Much of what I have said to your co-defendant applies to you.”

He referred to the punching, kicking and stamping of the dog, and said it was your “default position to minimise your behaviour.”

Sentencing |

Duvall-Gregory: 22 weeks’ imprisonment suspended for 18 months; £128 victim surcharge and £450 prosecution costs.

Hewitt: 22 weeks’ immediate imprisonment.

Both were handed a ten year disqualification from owning an animal, and cannot apply to appeal this for five years.

Liverpool Echo


Updates

Duvall-Gregory is now calling herself Emily Cara Smith on Facebook. It’s not known if this is for social media purposes only or if she’s legally changed her name.