Tag Archives: Orkney Islands

Stromness, Orkney Islands: Malcolm Leask

CONVICTED (2023) | Malcolm J Leask, born 17 September 1987, from Stromness, Orkney Islands – committed a decade-long campaign of violence and cruelty towards animals, women and children.

Former butcher Malcolm 'Beefy' Leask perpetrated a catalogue of violence and abuse of animals, women and children over 11 years.
Rapist, woman beater and child abuser Leask also caused suffering to animals by kicking, punching and choking two pet dogs and a puppy

Malcolm Leask, originally from Orkney but with links to Alva in Clackmannanshire, Stirling and Hartlepool, was convicted of three offences of animal cruelty alongside six assault offences, six of rape, one of attempted murder, two of threatening or abusive behaviour and one breach of the peace.

The crimes were committed at addresses in Orkney and Clackmannanshire between 2008 and 2019.

Rapist and child abuser Malcolm Leask also caused suffering to animals by kicking, punching and choking two pet dogs and a puppy.

The former butcher and amateur musician subjected a family Labrador to repeated brutality, punching and kicking the animal on her head and body, kneeling on her stomach, deliberately blowing smoke in her face, putting his hands round her throat and choking her.

Rapist and child abuser Malcolm Leask also caused suffering to animals by kicking, punching and choking two pet dogs and a puppy.

He kicked a border collie in the head and side, breaking one of his ribs. He also put a black bin bag over the dog’s head and tried to suffocate him.

Another time he picked the “scared and yelping” collie up by his armpits and threw him onto the floor, leaving him with permanent damage to his back legs.

Rapist and child abuser Malcolm Leask also caused suffering to animals by kicking, punching and choking two pet dogs and a puppy.

He also attacked an eight-month-old German Shepherd puppy, punching him on the head and ribs and “stamping” on his head.

The dog’s owner said she once came in to find Leask “strangling” him.

Leask told her the pup “had been bad and needed to be punished”.

Rapist and child abuser Malcolm Leask also caused suffering to animals by kicking, punching and choking two pet dogs and a puppy.

An allegation that he had battered two terrapins to death with a hammer was withdrawn by the prosecution.

Leask, nicknamed Beefy, because he previously weighed 31 stone, raped two women and tried to murder one of the victims by holding her head under water. He used his enormous weight to pin down one of his rape victims.

One woman told the court that she was repeatedly raped by Leask and subjected to physical violence when he punched, kneed and choked her.

Rapist and child abuser Malcolm Leask also caused suffering to animals by kicking, punching and choking two pet dogs and a puppy.

He also lifted her toddler daughter and threw her on to a chair.

A second woman said she was subjected to “pure nastiness” by Leask.

He had shouted and swore at her young daughter and chased and grabbed her son.

Leask, now married, denied 19 charges but was convicted following a trial.

Defence counsel Gordon Jackson KC said Leask had no previous convictions and suffered traumatic experiences earlier in his life.

Sentencing Leask, Judge Lord Scott told him that his offences show “a serious, violent and abusive course of conduct.” The judge also remarked that he was “unrepentant” and lacking in insight into the considerable damage he caused.

Sentencing | 12 years’ imprisonment with eight years of supervision following his release. Placed on the sex offenders register indefinitely.

Alloa Advertiser
BBC News
Daily Record

Deerness, Orkney: Jimmy Moar

CONVICTED (2023) | farmer James Robert Moar, born December 1955, of Rosebank, Deerness, Kirkwall, Orkney KW17 2QL – neglected cattle so badly, two cows had to be put down

Councillor Jimmy Moar kept livestock in hazardous conditions and failed to feed them properly. Despite this, he wasn't banned from owning animals
Councillor Jimmy Moar kept farm animals in hazardous conditions and failed to feed them properly. Despite this, he wasn’t banned from owning animals

Moar, councillor for Orkney’s East Mainland, South Ronaldsay and Burray, pleaded guilty to two animal welfare charges dating back to spring 2022.

Both of the incidents took place at Moar’s home address in Deerness, where he kept around 50 cattle and several sheep.

Livestock on councillor Jimmy Moar's farm were left to suffer because he had "too many plates to spin"
Livestock on councillor Jimmy Moar’s disgusting farm were left to suffer because he had “too many plates to spin”

In court, Moar admitted to causing unnecessary suffering to two cows, between April 7 and May 5, 2022, by failing to provide them with veterinary treatment or pain relief for their foot infections.

He also failed to provide them with sufficient nutrition which led to them becoming emaciated and requiring euthanasia.

The second charge said he failed to ensure the needs of a number of cattle were being met.

Several emaciated cows were found on Jimmy Moar's farm and two had to be euthanised on welfare grounds
Several emaciated cows were found on Jimmy Moar’s farm and two had to be euthanised on welfare grounds

He admitted to failing to provide them with comfortable, clean and dry resting areas; feed that was free of faecal contamination; and failed to seek veterinary treatment for their lameness.

This second offence took place between May 6 and 17, 2022.

Following Moar’s guilty plea in December 2022, the court had deferred his sentence to see if there was any evidence of him improving the condition of his animals and making significant changes at his farm.

Further inspections from the Animal and Plant Health Authority (APHA) took place ahead of sentencing.

According to Moar’s solicitor, these found that significant improvements had been made.

The solicitor said, at the time of the offences, Moar had been running for council, while also working on his farm and as a builder.

This had resulted in “too many plates to spin” and Moar becoming “overloaded.”

The solicitor conceded that “animals suffered as a result.”

In light of ‘improvements’, having been made Sheriff David Sutherland decided not to disqualify Moar from keeping animals.

In a separate case, Moar was sentenced to a further 40 hours of unpaid work on a charge of assault dating to January 2021.

Sentencing | 120 hours of unpaid work to be completed within one year; two-year supervision order.

Daily Record
BBC News

Laurencekirk, Aberdeenshire: Gail Vines

CONVICTED (2021) | Gail Vines, born c. 1957, of Kinnear Square, Laurencekirk AB30 1UL – banned from keeping horses after pony found in terrible condition covered in lice and open wounds

Vines is well known to the SSPCA who have dealt with her in the past and provided guidance on how to care for her animals.
Vines is well known to the SSPCA who have dealt with her in the past and provided guidance on how to care for her animals.

Vines, who is originally from Shapinsay in Orkney, admitted causing unnecessary suffering to her pony, Eve, who would have died without treatment.

She pleaded guilty to failing to provide adequate care and treatment, including nutrition, leading to the pony becoming emaciated and suffering from poor body condition, chronic diarrhoea, skin lesions and an infestation of lice.

The court heard Vines had been juggling a divorce, childcare and work, so had only been checking on her field of nine horses on the way home, shining a torch to check they were all there.

Eve was emaciated and suffering from skin lesions and lice when SSPCA inspectors found her
Eve was emaciated and suffering from skin lesions and lice when SSPCA inspectors found her,

She failed to notice Eve had become unwell and underweight due to redworms causing digestive issues and diarrhoea.

The SSPCA arrived at Sunnyside Farm in Drumoak, Aberdeenshire, on Sunday February 28, 2021, after a receiving a call from a concerned member of the public.

Inspector Fiona McKenzie said: “On attending we noticed the field was in a state of disrepair with numerous hazards that the ponies could become injured by such as loose fence posts and electric fencing wire on the ground.

“It also immediately became apparent that one of the ponies, Eve, was in extremely poor condition.

“She was standing on her own by the hay ring feeder with her head hanging down. Eve was emaciated and her hip bones and spine were clearly protruding. She was so weak, she had no energy and was listless.

“Eve was also covered in lice and had skin lesions. She was suffering from severe diarrhoea, which was later found to be caused by a heavy worm burden.

“It would have taken some time for Eve to get into this condition and it would not have happened overnight. She is incredibly lucky that she was found when she was as had she not received treatment she would have died.”

Eve is now doing well at an SSPCA animal rescue and rehoming centre and it is hoped she will be able to find a forever home soon.
Eve is now doing well at an SSPCA animal rescue and rehoming centre and it is hoped she will be able to find a forever home soon.

The Inspector continued: “We are pleased that Vines has been banned from keeping horses for five years and hope she will seriously consider her ability to look after any animal in future.

“I was absolutely shocked and disappointed by this case. Vines had received advice and assistance from the Scottish SPCA previous to this and should have prevented or recognised issues with her horses and addressed them.

“Eve was undoubtedly caused immense suffering over a period of several months. This suffering could have easily been avoided had the owner displayed good horsemanship. Her lack of daily care and feeding, along with routine worming, is good practice known by responsible horse owners.

“Vines’ failure to adhere to Scottish SPCA advice shows total disregard for her animal’s health and wellbeing.”

Sentencing: banned from keeping horses for five years (expires July 2026). Deprivation order in respect of Eve. The sheriff otherwise admonished Vines, meaning she faces no further punishment.

Daily Express