Tag Archives: elderly animal

Dudley, West Midlands: Emma Spooner

CONVICTED (2013) | Emma Michelle Spooner aka Emma Hope, born 14/11/1980, as at March 2019 of Owen Street, Dudley DY2 7HT – left an elderly rottweiler to starve in his own excrement for five years

Animal abuser Emma Michelle Spooner, now of Dudley, West Midlands, and Kane the dog she left to starve
Animal abuser Emma Michelle Spooner, now of Dudley, West Midlands, and Kane the dog she left to starve

Emma Spooner admitted failing to make sure that her 11-year-old dog, named Kane, was provided with a suitable diet and environment.

The grandmother was slammed by a judge for neglecting the elderly animal and exposing her children to the dangerous possibility of being savaged when he became feral.

Spooner kept Kane alive by throwing him scraps in the back yard of her then home in Peel Way, Tividale, near Birmingham.

Animal abuser Emma Michelle Spooner, now of Dudley, West Midlands, and Kane the dog she left to starve
Spooner spent much of her time out in nightclubs, while her dog was abandoned to starve

Summing up at her trial, Judge Graham Wilkinson: ‘You left this dog to fester in the back yard. This poor animal, for five years, lived in a small space, unloved and mostly neglected.

‘He goes feral, because he is not getting love and attention. He is left to lie in his own filth. He’s occasionally thrown food and he wastes away.

‘Had it not been that someone locally alerted the RSPCA, eventually you would have realised you had not seen him for a few days, because he would have wasted away to nothing.

‘He was left to starve slowly and would probably have died a sad, lonely death. All this time, you allowed your children to be at risk.’

At one stage, the judge also halted the proceedings, ordering Spooner to leave the court because she was chewing gum, although he called the case back about 30 minutes later.

The aging dog was forced to sleep in a damp, open shed in the faeces-strewn back garden of Emma Spooner’s then home in Tividale, near Birmingham.

Prosecuting for the RSPCA, Gaynor Sutton said Inspector Steve Morrall had called at Spooner’s home on January 29, 2013, and could see the dog was ‘very lean’. The yard was covered in faeces.

Inspector Morrall threw some food to the starving animal, who quickly gobbled it up.

Speaking to her local newspaper, Spooner said she had tried to get the RSPCA to put him down, but they had wanted £200 to do the job. She was only willing to pay half.

Spooner, whose 14-year-old daughter had a baby son 17 months earlier, said: ‘The dog belonged to my ex-partner.

‘I was under the impression he would look after it and he should have taken it when he left but he didn’t.

‘I was made out in court to be bad but the dog wasn’t kept outside for five years, like they said. He used to come in at night.’

She added: ‘The dog didn’t like women or children and, apart from biting two of the kids, he went for my throat.’

Sentencing: curfew; costs of £1,000. Banned from keeping an animal for five years (expired September 2018).

Express and Star

Dover, Kent: Suzanne and Mark Bunyard

CONVICTED (2013) | Suzanne Dorling Bunyard, born 23/02/1971, and husband Mark Bunyard, born 27/03/1960, both of Boston Close, Dover CT16 2BP – kept a dog trapped in a filthy cage for more than five years and left another to wander in foul conditions

Dog abusers Suzanne and Mark Bunyard
Suzanne and Mark Bunyard are banned from keeping animals for life after failing to care for their pet dogs

The Bunyards let an elderly flea-riddled Jack Russell named Spike run loose in their squalid, dilapidated house. Another dog known as Jasper was kept in a filthy cage. When rescued he was emaciated and his legs were covered in sores.

Photo of Jasper in the cage where he was kept by his cruel owners
Jasper had been kept in a cage for more than five years

RSPCA inspector Caroline Doe said: “I am disgusted to think that Jasper, the dog in the cage, had led a life of misery for more than five years.

“There is no excuse for keeping animals like this. They admitted that neither dog had received any veterinary treatment and both had suffered badly from neglect.”

Neglected and abused Jack Russell Jasper after his recovery
Jasper has recovered from his ordeal

Both defendants pleaded guilty to failing to meet the needs of the two Jack Russells.

Sentencing: total of 21 weeks in jail, suspended for 12 months; costs of more than £1,071. Disqualified from keeping animals for life.

Kent Online

Warrington, Cheshire: Karen & John Anderson

CONVICTED (2013) | Karen Mary Anderson, born 08/09/1954, and husband John Anderson, born 07/06/1961, both of Kingsway South, Warrington WA4 1LS – kept two dogs in a cage behind a sofa for 22 hours a day for two years leaving them covered in sores and scars

Convicted animal abusers Karen and John Anderson are banned from owning animals until August 2023
Vile: Karen and John Anderson are banned from owning animals until August 2023

The Andersons kept Staffies Jet, aged 10, and Tye, aged 12, locked in a small cage 22 hours a day for two years.

John and Karen Anderson from Warrington shunned their elderly dogs Jet and Tye.
John and Karen Anderson shunned their elderly dogs Jet and Tye.

When rescued by the RSPCA on January 20, 2013, both dogs had damaged teeth and were covered in sores and scars from trying to escape the cage.

Inspectors found the broken wires of the cage were bent back into place by the pair to keep the pets contained, concealed behind an old sofa in a dirty, disused bedroom.

Both dogs were emaciated with ribs, spines and skulls all visible.
Both dogs were emaciated with ribs, spines and skulls all visible.

Kevin Worthington, prosecuting, said both dogs were ‘emaciated with ribs, spines and skulls all visible’.

They were rarely fed while trapped, with paws stained from urine and faeces. Neither dog could walk.

The court heard how the defendants had two other dogs, both Dogue de Bordeaux, who Mrs Anderson described as her ‘babies’.

They slept in the bedroom with the couple and were treated as part of the family. The couple also kept barn owls and tropical fish.

All pets were seized by the RSPCA.

At Halton Magistrates Court, District Judge Bridget Knight said: “This case is truly shocking.

“I have seen the photographs of these two dogs that were family pets kept as prisoners.

“I can’t conceive how you as human beings and dog owners could sleep night after night when you knew these two animals were suffering greatly.

“You had grandchildren visiting and I can’t bear to think of young children knowing animals were being treated in this way.

“I almost despair.”

All pets have now been seized by the RSPCA.

Jonathan Conder, defending, said the dogs were separated because they started to fight.

He said: “The defendants fully accept the cage was completely inadequate accommodation for the dogs.

“That wasn’t the right way to keep them.

“The treatment of the dogs is an aberration for people who have kept pets all their lives.”

Sentencing: 18 weeks in prison, suspended for two years. 26-week curfew. Banned from keeping animals for 10 years (expires August 2023).

John Anderson, on long-term sick from self-employed work as a removal man, was told to pay £600 towards a £4,000 vet bill.

Karen Anderson, who is on benefits, will pay £520.

Warrington Guardian
Daily Mail

Bradford: Kathleen and Vanessa Crowley and David Wright

CONVICTED (2013) | Kathleen Ann Crowley, born 07/11/1964, partner David Wright born c. 1967, and daughter Vanessa Chantelle Crowley, born 23/09/1990, previously all of Canterbury Avenue, Bradford BD5 – convicted of animal welfare offences after a starving dog was found buried under a pile of bikes in garden and three others in filthy condition.

Dog killers Kathleen and Vanessa Crowley from Bradford, West Yorkshire, UK. Photos: Facebook

Kathleen Crowley, who as of 2019 is living in Curlew Street, Bradford BD5 9RE, subjected a German shepherd found buried under a pile of bikes in her garden to months of despicable neglect. The unnamed dog was so malnourished and unwell he had to be put down.

The Crowleys' dog had been starved and neglected for momths
The Crowleys’ dog had been starved and neglected for months

Crowley’s daughter Vanessa Crowley, most recent known address Little Horton Lane, Bradford BD5 9DG, and partner David Wright also lived at the address and joined her in the dock. They both pleaded guilty to failing to provide dogs with a suitable environment.

Cruel Kathleen Crowley, daughter Vanessa Crowley and partner David Wright all of Bradford left an elderly German Shepherd to starve  in a filthy cluttered garden

The dog was discovered by an RSPCA officer who visited Crowley’s home.

Three bull terriers were also discovered living in poor conditions at the property.

Nigel Monaghan, prosecuting for the RSPCA, described how floors in the house were “filthy” and the kitchen “covered with dirt and grime”.

Maria Temkow, mitigating, said she had health difficulties and was unable to look after herself or animals.

Dog killer Vanessa Crowley from Bradford, West Yorkshire, UK. Photos: Facebook

A neighbour, who lived next door to the defendants, said: ‘I have seen the dog on a few occasions in the garden whimpering.

‘The dog always looked tired and unenergetic.

‘The smell was so bad that in the summer we could not even open the windows.”

Sentencing:
Kathleen Crowley – two-month prison sentence, suspended for 12 months

Vanessa Crowley – 12-month community order with a 15-day activity condition and ordered to complete 60 hours of unpaid work.

David Wright – 12-month community order with 50 hours’ unpaid work.

The defendants were ordered to pay £260 towards costs which totalled more than £5,000.

All three were banned from keeping animals for life.

Daily Mail
Telegraph & Argus

Cannock, Staffordshire: Christine Smith

CONVICTED (2013) | Christine Smith, born 30 July 1962, of Maycroft Close, Hednesford, Cannock WS12 4SJ – failed to treat her elderly dog’s severe skin condition, leaving her in agony.

In April 2013 psychiatric nurse Christine Smith was sentenced to six months behind bars for allowing her 12-year-old collie Lucy to suffer with a skin infection so severe even vets, who were forced to put the dog to sleep, were shocked.

But just seven days later a Stafford Crown Court judge reduced the sentence to 20 weeks and suspended the jail term for 18 months.

Judge John Wait heard how Smith had failed to take Lucy for treatment, telling RSPCA officers she had been afraid she would lose the dog which she had cared for since she was three weeks old and saw her as a ‘child’.

After the pet suffered for eight weeks and with Smith on holiday, her 21-year-old son decided the dog’s condition had got so bad he took her to the vets. The vet carrying out the post mortem described the skin condition – called deep pyoderma – as the worst case he had ever seen in his career.

During initial sentencing, chairman of the bench Mr Paul Ensor criticised Smith for going on holiday when the pet was in obvious pain.

She was found guilty in her absence of a charge of causing unnecessary suffering to an animal, and another of being a person responsible for an animal and failing to ensure its welfare between June and August 2012.

But at the appeal hearing, the prison sentence was suspended. Miss Jo Clark said the sentence had been ‘excessive’ and had not taken into account Smith’s previous good character.

She added Smith, who works in Cannock as a psychiatric nurse for children and adolescents, was remorseful and risked losing her job if she was kept locked up.

Judge Wait said it was a ‘sad’ case as she had ‘let Lucy down’ in the last two months of her life. The ban of 10 years for keeping pets was not altered.

Sentencing: 20-week custodial sentence suspended for 18 months; 200 hours of unpaid work; contribution of £1,200 towards costs. 10-year ban on keeping animals (expires April 2023).

Express & Star

Newton-le-Willows, Merseyside: Paul McCaw

CONVICTED (2012) | Paul McCaw, born 03/09/1985, of 66 Laurel Avenue, Newton-le-Willows WA12 8JA – stabbed an arthritic terrier to death before burying her in his back garden

Dog killer Paul McCaw from Newton-le-Willows, Merseyside

Staffy Cheech “died an absolutely terrible, violent death” at the hands of her owner McCaw.

RSPCA inspectors visited McCaw’s home after a tip-off from neighbours who noticed Cheech was missing. Some reportedly heard the dog’s cries and yelps the previous evening.

Prosecuting, Peter Mitchell said: “He said that the dog collapsed in pain, so he took it into the back garden and he strangled it.”

But when inspectors dug up the body, they found the ten-year-old dog covered in multiple stab wounds and soaked in blood.

Victim Cheech
RSPCA inspectors found Cheech, pictured, covered in blood and stab wounds buried in the back garden

Mr Mitchell said that one of the wounds looked as if McCaw had attempted to “slash its wrist”. Cheech also had wounds to her head, chest and neck.

In total Cheech suffered 40 wounds – with one puncturing a lung – causing her to collapse. The dog eventually died, drowning in her own blood.

Mark Brown, defending, told magistrates: “He was of the view that Cheech was suffering and needed to be put out of its misery.”

He said McCaw tried to smother the dog, but it didn’t work, so he stabbed her.

Dog killer Paul McCaw from Newton-le-Willows, Merseyside

RSPCA inspector Louise Showering said: ‘This dog suffered an absolutely terrible, violent death at the hands of an owner who had been responsible for her for almost her entire life.

‘Though he says he thought he was putting her out of her misery, he actually caused her to suffer much more with the actions he took. First trying to suffocate her then stabbing her many, many times.

‘I can’t imagine what this dog’s final hours must have been like at the hands of someone she loved.

‘It certainly wasn’t the dignified and pain-free end most owners hope for their beloved pets.’

Sentence: jailed for 18 weeks. Banned from keeping animals for 20 years (expires November 2032).

Daily Mail

Blurton, Stoke on Trent: David Nicholls

CONVICTED (2012) | David P Nicholls, born 24 June 1957, of 94 Magdalen Road, Blurton, Stoke on Trent ST3 3HU – chained his elderly dog to a shed for up to three weeks, forcing him to drink his own urine to survive; previously abandoned a dog in the park.

Serial dog abuser David Nicholls from Stoke on Trent
2019 photo of David Nicholls

Callous David Nicholls tied his 16-year-old pet dog, named Nato, in freezing conditions in February 2012. When he was discovered by RSPCA officers, the Jack Russell was so weak he could barely stand and was covered in weeping sores.

He was forced to drink his own urine and eat his faeces to survive.

Jack Russell Nato was chained to a shed for three weeks in freezing conditions and forced to drink his own urine to survive
Jack Russell Nato was chained to a shed for three weeks in freezing conditions and forced to drink his own urine to survive

Vets were forced to remove the dog’s eye after an easily treatable infection had gone septic, which Nicholls had ignored.

Nicholls admitted causing unnecessary suffering to an animal and had been convicted previously for mistreating another dog.

The neglected Jack Russell had a multitude of untreated ailments including skin lesions
The neglected Jack Russell had a multitude of untreated ailments including skin lesions

RSPCA officer Laura Bryant said: ‘Nato would have needed only basic treatment if Nicholls had taken him to the vet but leaving him for so long made his injuries horrific.’

Appallingly, Nicholls was convicted in May 2011 of mistreating another dog, a Staffordshire terrier, after he bought her in a pub and left her tied to a park bench.

Serial dog abuser David Nicholls from Stoke on Trent
Dog abuser David Nicholls pictured outside court in 2012

In sentencing him over Nato’s unnecessary suffering, Chairman Doug Hood said: ‘This matter of causing unnecessary cruelty to the dog is a serious case.

‘Anyone would have realised that the dog needed treatment.

‘This is also compounded by your previous discharge for a similar matter.’

Sentencing: 18-month community order; vet cost of £465. 10-year ban on keeping pets (expired October 2022).

Daily Mail

Feltham, West London: Alan Vincent

CONVICTED (2012) | postman Alan Vincent, born c. 1973, formerly of Taylors Court, Feltham and as at December 2017 living in New Road, Feltham TW14 8HR – battered a pet cat to death with the lid of his mail trolley

Alan Vincent

Neighbours heard “meowing and screeching” as Vincent repeatedly bashed the lid of his postal trolley down on Tiddy, a 14-year-old tortoiseshell cat. When confronted by shocked residents he threw the dying animal over a garden hedge and told them to ‘F*** off’.

Vincent initially denied the offence in court, but magistrates did not believe his version of events and jailed him for six months.

Vincent was sacked from his job as a postal delivery worker.

Sentence: jailed for six months.

London Evening Standard

Bilston, West Midlands: Donna Edwards

CONVICTED (2012) | Donna Edwards (aka Donna Wright), born 2 March 1978, of Bank Street, Bradley, Bilston, Wolverhampton WV14 8PA – left her elderly pet dog to waste away in her back garden

Donna Edwards

Mother-of-three Edwards kept her 13-year-old dog chained up outside her home in Bilston, with a shelter that was completely open to the elements.

Police attended the house for another matter and officers discovered the animal in a collapsed state in the garden.

He was skeletal, infested with maggots, soaking wet and surrounded by faeces.

The RSPCA was alerted and the dog was rushed to a vets, who put him to sleep to end his suffering.

Donna Edwards

Mr Roger Price, prosecuting for the RSPCA, told the court how police officers found the dog lying on wet concrete and initially thought he was dead.

Mr Price told the court the dog was in an “atrocious” state.

He weighed just 12.5kg when an ideal weight for a dog of his size would be 30kg.

“The dog had no body fat at all,” Mr Price added. “He was extremely weak and maggots were crawling out of its skin. This dog had been abandoned.”

Donna Edwards

He revealed there was a chain attached to the back of Edwards’ house and the garden was full of dog mess.

He added: “The shelter was wet inside and open to the elements.

“The dog suffered a urine scald and had a pressure sore.

“The emaciation was to such a degree that the skeletal structure was visible and there was a total lack or absence of any body fat.”

Edwards pleaded guilty to three charges of causing unnecessary suffering and two counts of failing to take reasonable care of the animal.

Sentencing: 18-week prison sentence, suspended for two years ; 200 hours of unpaid work. Ordered to pay £2,297 in costs and £43 in compensation to the vets. Banned from keeping animals for life.

Express and Star

Walsall, West Midlands: David Timms

CONVICTED (2012) | David John Timms, born 17/03/1983, most recently of Lower North Street, Walsall WS4 2BB – banned from keeping animals for life after having an emaciated pet dog at his home

Dog abuser David John Timms from Walsall is banned from keeping animals for life
David Timms from Walsall is banned from keeping animals for life

Elderly German Shepherd cross Bengi was so weak he struggled to stand up after weeks of unnecessary suffering. The 13-year-old dog had dropped to nearly half his ideal weight.

The RSPCA was called to Timms’ previous address in Reedswood Gardens, Walsall, on August 31, 2011, after neighbours became growingly concerned for the dog’s welfare.

Veterinary examination showed Bengi weighed just 8.4kg when the ideal weight for a dog of his breed would be n the region of 16kg.

The malnourished animal was kept on behalf of the RSPCA and gained nearly 6kg in just a few weeks.

Mrs Gaynor Sutton, prosecuting on behalf of the RSPCA, said: “The dog was so weak and so thin it was unsteady on its legs. The vet said the dog had been exposed to unnecessary suffering for a significant period of time of at least four weeks.”

When interviewed by the RSPCA Timms said the dog was fed regularly most days but he had been struggling for cash.

Mrs Sheila Hicklin, defending, said her client suffered from learning difficulties and had not purchased the animal but it had been deposited at his home.

She said he tried to call the RSPCA but when the line was busy he didn’t persevere.

Bengi recovered and was rehomed.

Sentencing: community order with 12 months of supervision; ordered to pay £500 RSPCA costs. Given a lifetime ban on having pets with right of appeal after 10 years (i.e. around January 2022).

Express & Star