Tag Archives: abuser photo wanted

Clayton, Manchester: Colin Birch

CONVICTED (2024) | Colin Birch, born c 1956, of Auden Close, Clayton, Manchester M11 4WD – for the mistreatment of several reptiles.

RSPCA prosecution. Manchester animal abuser Colin Birch allowed one iguana to roam freely around his home and two others plus a lizard were crammed into a small fish tank with only rotting food.

Birch was found guilty in his absence of two offences. The first – which took place in February 2022 – involved the neglect of three iguanas and a spiny-tailed lizard; while the other involved the neglect of five further iguanas in June 2022.

The RSPCA first visited Birch’s flat in February 2022 after concerns were raised about the welfare of ‘lizards’ in the property.

The RSPCA officer – accompanied by police – entered the property and found three iguanas and a lizard being kept in very worrying conditions.

One of the iguanas was roaming free around the dangerously cluttered and overheated flat and another two iguanas plus a spiny-tailed lizard were crammed into a very small fish tank with only rotten or dried up food.

There was no source of UV (crucial to the health of iguanas), no temperature controls and no thermometer.

Given these conditions, the police seized all four reptiles and after being checked by a vet, the RSPCA organised for them to be cared for at a specialist boarding establishment.

RSPCA prosecution: Manchester animal abuser Colin Birch allowed one iguana to roam freely around his home and two others plus a lizard were crammed into a small fish tank with only rotting food.

In June 2022, the RSPCA was called back to the same property – now unoccupied – to check on five more iguanas who had been left alone to fend for themselves in the flat.

This time, two very young iguanas were found in a pet carrier, one adult was found in a fish tank with no access to drinking water, and two were found roaming loose in the hazardous flat.

Again, the animals had no access to UV or appropriate food or water.

These additional five iguanas were also taken away to be safely cared for in a specialist boarding establishment.

A specialist in exotic pets was provided with photographs from both incidents and stated that the property was full of potential dangers, and the tanks were not not the right size to provide an appropriate environment for these types of animals.

From the February incident, there were too many animals in one tank. In addition, the temperature and humidity required for the reptiles’ needs would not have been met.

RSPCA Animal Rescue Officer, Dan Tomlinson said: “Pet reptiles rely on their owners to provide an environment in which their welfare needs are met, which sadly didn’t happen in this case, even after detailed advice was offered to the defendant.

“The needs of exotics can be challenging to meet by members of the public because the pet animals’ needs are just the same as they would be if they lived in the wild and require conditions that can be difficult to replicate in a home.

“The RSPCA advises that prospective owners of exotic pets should thoroughly research the needs of the particular species and what is required in the care of the animal, using expert sources, and only consider keeping one if they can ensure they are fully able to provide for these needs.”

He added: “Every year, my colleagues and I are called out to rescue many hundreds of exotic pets which have been neglected or abandoned. These are wild animals and meeting their needs in captivity can be incredibly challenging. We believe that people may buy exotic pets with little idea of how difficult they can be to keep. They often end up in our care after people realise they’re not easy to care for, or once the novelty wears off and the commitment hits home.”

Exotic pet owners need to make sure they can give their animal the environment it needs and that they have the facilities, time, financial means and long-term commitment to maintain a good standard of care, as required under the Animal Welfare Act 2006.

Sentencing | nine-month community order with 15 days of rehabilitation activity; fine of £100 and a victim surcharge of £95. Banned from owning animals for five years (expires February 2029).

Manchester Evening News

Kidlington, Oxfordshire: Daniel Bayley

CONVICTED (2024) | Daniel Bayley, born c. 1981, formerly of Kidlington, Oxfordshire, but now no fixed abode – caught hitting his pet dog and dragging him by the collar.

Bayley pleaded guilty to hitting the dog, a Staffordshire Bull Terrier called Bailey, and intentionally sitting on him.

He was also seen dragging the dog by his collar.

It was ordered the dog was removed from Bayley, now of no fixed abode, and he was banned from owning an animal for five years.

He was also fined £200. There were court costs of £85 and a victim surcharge of £80.

Oxford Mail

Taunton, Somerset: Mark Baker

CONVICTED (2024) | Mark Baker, born c. 1975, of Lyngford Place, Taunton TA2 7EP – neglected an injured and emaciated elderly horse so badly the animal had to be euthanised.

An equine vet said that Squealy suffered for a prolonged period after Taunton man Mark Baker, who had him on loan, neglected him
An equine vet said that Squealy suffered for a prolonged period after Taunton man Mark Baker, who had him on loan, neglected him

Baker was loaned 25-year-old horse Squealy between December 14, 2022 and February 16, 2023.

But instead of being kept in a clean and tidy stable, the elderly horse was found shut in filthy conditions with two rugs on. One rug had slipped and rubbed until it caused a large open sore on the horse’s back. His teeth were also in a poor condition and he was unable to properly consume his food.

An equine vet said that Squealy suffered for a prolonged period after Taunton man Mark Baker, who had him on loan, neglected him

The RSPCA launched an investigation with specialist equine vets horrified by Squealy’s condition. In their report, they wrote that there had been “no attempt … to palliate the horse or alleviate his pain, let alone investigate the cause of his poor body condition.

“He was not free from pain, injury or disease. His needs were not being met as specialist dental care was not sought or provided and his diet was not adequate given his additional needs.

“He was not free from hunger since he did not have access to a diet to maintain his health and vigour. He was exclusively confined to his stable in the barn alone and was denied freedom to exhibit normal behaviour since he did not have company of his own kind.

“His environment was not comfortable given the wet and soiled bedding he was found on. He was not free from discomfort. From my findings, it is my opinion that pain and suffering had been ongoing for many months.”

Due to the severity of Squealy’s condition, a decision was taken with the support of his owner for a vet to euthanise him on site.

In court Baker admitted two charges of causing or failing to prevent unnecessary suffering to a protected animal and failing to ensure the needs of an animal were met between December 14, 2022 and February 16, 2023.

Sentencing Baker to a 15-year ban on keeping equines, the judge told him: “Looking after an animal is a privilege and you failed in that privilege and the court cannot allow you to fail again.”

RSPCA Inspector Jo Daniel, who investigated for the animal welfare charity, said: “As a result of this not being noticed and addressed, the rug continued to rub and caused a large ulcerating wound. The degree of granulation suggested the wound wasn’t recent and either had not been treated or hadn’t even been noticed.

“Squealy also had very worn painful teeth and it was very evident from the environment that he had been dribbling his food for a considerable time as large amounts of dried food was stuck to his stable door. He was hungry but unable to consume the calories needed to maintain good health.”

Sentencing | 150 hours of unpaid work; £1,200 costs. 15-year disqualification order against keeping equines (expires 2039).

SomersetLive

Palmers Green, North London: Jay Mayor-Carty

CONVICTED (2023) | Jay Joseph Patrick Mayor-Carty, born December 1995, of Hedge Lane, Palmers Green, Enfield N13, but with links to Lower Edmonton, London and Southampton – filmed slamming a dog onto a balcony floor.

Kobe was nursed back to health in the RSPCA’s care and returned to his owner after she and Jay Mayor-Carty had gone their separate ways

Mayor-Carty, a former company director and self-styled “entrepreneur”, was found guilty at Willesden Magistrates Court of causing unnecessary suffering to a French bulldog called Kobe.

The RSPCA was called in after Mayor-Carty was filmed slamming the dog down onto a balcony floor at Waldegrave Point, Green Street, Park Royal, Willesden, three times and possibly stamping on the dog on August 6, 2022.

When RSPCA Inspector Francesca Tambini arrived at the address later that day, Kobe was present

Kobe belonged to Mayor-Carty’s then girlfriend, but he was apparently looking after him while she was away for a few days.

Kobe appeared to have very red eyes, which Mayor-Carty claimed was due to heatstroke.

Suspecting a more sinister reason Inspector Tambini attended with police the next day to take the dog to the vet.

When the inspector and police arrived, the dog’s owner had since returned and said Kobe was being treated for skin allergies.

The vet confirmed that the haemorrhaging and swelling of Kobe’s eyes were not consistent with heatstroke or allergies, and that he was fearful and head shy when being examined.

The vet suspected injuries caused by blunt force trauma and concluded that he had suffered for a number of days.

An expert vet confirmed that the severity of the injuries was not consistent with an allergy, heatstroke or the dog running into another dog or hard object.

He added: “In my opinion Kobe was caused to suffer due to the person responsible for the welfare of this animal failing to seek prompt veterinary advice regarding the eye condition.”

Mayor-Carty and Kobe’s owner have since split up and Kobe was returned to her following recovery.

The RSPCA said Mayor-Carty denied slamming the dog into the balcony three times but accepted that he was found guilty of this.

Inspector Tambini said: “This was an awful case, Kobe had suffered terrible cruelty at the hands of a man who was supposed to be caring for him while his owner was absent.

“His owner had no idea that her partner was capable of such a violent act.

“Witnesses described seeing him being slammed onto the ground three times and possibly stamped on.

“His injuries were consistent with blunt force trauma and it’s clear he would have suffered, especially given the lack of vet attention following the incident.

“We’re pleased that Kobe is now safe.”

Sentencing | 12 month community order, with 150 hours of unpaid work and 15-day rehabilitation activity requirement. Banned from keeping pets for ten years (expires December 2033).

Enfield Independent

Tottenham, North London: Tiago Da Silva

CONVICTED (2023) | Tiago Da Silva, born c. 1995, of Steele Road, Tottenham, London N7 – battered a bull mastiff puppy to death and lied that she had drowned in the shower.

Brazilian national Tiago Da Silva was banned from owning pets indefinitely after an RSPCA investigation revealed his eight-month-old dog, Diva, had died from horrifying injuries.

Da Silva, previously of Seven Sisters Road, Islington, had claimed the puppy must have fallen and blocked the drain – but a post mortem revealed she died of internal bleeding from a blow to the liver, with other bruising and bleeding on her body.

The thug was found guilty at Willesden Magistrates Court on December 5, 2023, of failing to protect Diva from injury, despite his denials.

Diva’s limp body was taken to a vet on January 24, but she died despite attempts to resuscitate her.

Da Silva told vets he had put her in the shower after she defecated in his house and he thought she must have fallen and blocked the drain.

But assessments revealed bruising in her left ear, signs of recent haemorrhaging around the left eye, and marks on her lips.

The vet called the RSPCA.

Inspector Shahnaz Ahmad led the investigation and asked an expert vet to examine Diva’s body and decide if she had suffered.

The vet’s report said a post mortem found Diva had died as a consequence of “significant blood loss” into the abdominal cavity as a result of physical damage to the liver.

This was consistent with “blunt force trauma”, with further evidence of blows at the back of the skull and the chest.

It added: “The post mortem findings do not support death by drowning and it is difficult to explain how a dog may have sustained multiple blunt force trauma injuries while in the home environment accidentally while being showered by her owner.

“The suspicion of non-accidental injury (physical abuse) is raised.”

The report concluded that Da Silva had not protected Diva from injury, and that she may have suffered pain and distress as a result of trauma to her abdomen.

In mitigation, Da Silva said his failure to meet welfare needs was not intended and he denied that the injuries were caused by blunt force trauma.

Following sentencing, Inspector Shahnaz Ahmad said: “We are grateful to the vet for reporting this incident to us. If they hadn’t we would have never found out that an offence had been committed.

“We always encourage vets to report suspected animal abuse cases to us so that we can investigate and where necessary, pursue a prosecution.”

Sentencing | 20-week suspended jail sentence; 150 hours of unpaid work; victim surcharge of £114. Indefinite ban on owning animals.

This is Local London

Runcorn, Cheshire: Carrie-Anne Renwick

CONVICTED (2023) | Carrie Anne Renwick, born c. 1970, of Meadow Row, Castlefields, Runcorn WA7 2LN – moved out of her squalid flat, leaving seven cats to starve to death.

RSPCA inspectors found the decomposing bodies of seven cats in Carrie-Anne Renwick's squalid and flea-infested Runcorn flat
RSPCA inspectors found the decomposing bodies of seven cats in Carrie-Anne Renwick’s squalid and flea-infested Runcorn flat

The deceased animals were surrounded by rubbish and overflowing litter trays in a flat that was so cluttered some of the rooms were inaccessible.

The cats’ owner, Carrie-Anne Renwick had vacated the property in Primrose Close, Runcorn, months earlier leaving her abandoned pets behind to die.

The court heard how the deceased animals were removed by RSPCA inspector Nadine Pengilly on July 5, 2023.

In her evidence, Inspector Pengilly said: “As I approached the front door, I was attacked by hundreds of fleas escaping via the letterbox.

“We went to the back of the property and I could clearly see the flat was in a filthy condition, with overflowing litter trays and bags of rubbish all over the floor.

“The place was full of clutter and there was a mass flea infestation.

“The first room on the right was the bathroom which was dirty and cluttered. I found two dead cats on the floor.

“The first room on the left was the main bedroom, where there was a dead cat on the bed, two in the wardrobe, one near the door and one behind the curtains on the floor.

“The bedroom was cluttered with items and made access hard as I had to climb over bags of shopping.

“The black cat found in the wardrobe looked like he hadn’t been dead long as he still had flesh on his body and was being eaten by maggots.”

RSPCA inspectors found the decomposing bodies of seven cats in Carrie-Anne Renwick's squalid and flea-infested Runcorn flat

RSPCA inspector Leanne Cooper, who also attended the address, added: “There was a foul smell coming from the property that I could smell from standing outside the front door.

“I could see live and dead flies on the windows and hundreds of live and dead fleas. These actually jumped on me when I opened the letterbox.”

The deceased animals were taken into possession by police and their bodies examined by a vet.

The cat found in the wardrobe had died at least 36 hours earlier while, the other six carcasses were dried out and rigid, suggesting they had been dead for some time.

“Decomposition was so marked that the bodies were not suitable for a post mortem examination,” Ms Cooper said.

“Reviewing the carcasses along with the environmental evidence, starvation and dehydration cannot be ruled out as potential causes of death due to the lack of water and fresh food.

“I would expect a responsible owner to seek veterinary attention should their pet become underweight.

“Moreover, if their animal became weak or lethargic. Starvation and dehydration cause weakness and debilitation.

“This will have been uncomfortable and severely impacted the cats’ everyday lives and their ability to ambulate, to obtain food or water and even to play.

“Emaciation can cause mental suffering through having a constant hunger that is never fulfilled.

“It is reported to take at least four days for a cat to starve to death – a slow, painful and prolonged process as the body shuts down. This will have been unpleasant.”

Renwick had previously been given advice by the RSPCA about appropriate flea treatment but had turned down offers of help to rehome the cats.

In mitigation, the court heard she had health and alcohol issues.

Before sentencing, deputy district judge Price highlighted that only a custodial sentence was appropriate in this case due to the nature and seriousness of the offences.

However, taking Renwick’s guilty pleas into account, the judge agreed to suspend the sentence.

Sentencing | 16 weeks in prison suspended for 12 months; 20 rehabilitation activity requirement days; alcohol treatment programme; costs and surcharge totalling £354. A 10-year ban on owning or keeping animals (expires December 2033).

CheshireLive
Runcorn and Widnes World

Monsall, Manchester: Frank Rogers

CONVICTED (2023) | Frank Rogers, born 1 December 1955, of 276 Queens Road, Monsall, Manchester M40 8JW – failed to get vet treatment for a dog found bald, unable to walk and riddled with infections.

Manchester man Frank Rogers' dog Buster had been left to suffer for many weeks and was put to sleep for humane reasons
Frank Rogers’ dog Buster had been left to suffer for many weeks and was put to sleep for humane reasons

Rogers was prosecuted after RSPCA officers found his terrier cross Buster in ‘very poor condition’. The court heard the dog was suffering with chronic skin disease, which had left him almost bald of fur, ingrown nails that were so bad he was unable to walk, and ear disease.

Rogers said Buster was ‘okay’ when he got him from a friend a year earlier and that he had only just lost his fur.

He pleaded guilty to one offence under the Animal Welfare Act 2006..

RSPCA animal rescue officer (ARO) Helen Chapman went to Rogers’ home on April 14, 2023, to investigate a report of concern about a ‘bald dog’ at the property.

In a statement to the court, the officer said: “The dog was laying on its side on a chair, covered over with a blanket apart from his head and he made no attempt to move. I could see Buster was in very poor condition, with bald, dry pink skin.”

Manchester man Frank Rogers' dog Buster had been left to suffer for many weeks and was put to sleep for humane reasons

Rogers agreed to let the animal rescue officer take Buster to the RSPCA Greater Manchester Animal Hospital. Sadly, he was in such poor health that in a vet’s expert opinion the kindest course of action to end his suffering was to put him to sleep.

The vet who examined the dog found he was suffering from infections in both ear canals, overgrown nails and alopecia which had caused extensive irritation. Buster was also underweight with a low body condition score of two out of nine.

The vet stated that given the severity of Buster’s condition, he would have been suffering for many weeks and likely longer.

“His overgrown nails will have been a source of pain,” she said.

“Secondary changes such as lichenification of the skin and stenosis of the ears indicated the skin and ear disease was chronic in nature. The ear infections too will have caused discomfort and would have made it difficult for him to settle. He was shaking his head and getting no relief,” said the vet.

Sentencing | 12-month community order with 100 hours unpaid work; costs of £100 and a victim surcharge of £114. A 10-year ban on owning animals.

Manchester Evening News
Salford Media

Gleadless, Sheffield: Martin Butlin

CONVICTED (2023) | Martin John Butlin, born c. 1963, of Fleury Road, Gleadless, Sheffield S14 1QW – starved and severely neglected two emaciated greyhounds kept on an allotment.

Martin Butlin from Sheffield kept two starving and neglected former racing dogs on an allotment
Surviving dog Fury was emaciated. The other dog Mick had already succumbed to starvation and was brought into the vet in a builder’s bag by Butlin.

Butlin admitted two animal welfare offences in relation to former racing greyhounds Mick and Fury., whom he kept on an allotment in Wadsley Bridge, Sheffield. He was prosecuted by the RSPCA after a veterinary practice in South Yorkshire contacted the charity over concerns for the dogs’ welfare. The dogs had been brought into them in an emaciated condition.

One of the greyhounds, called Mick, had already died and had been taken to the practice in a builder’s bag in the boot of Butlin’s car.

The court heard how two-year-old Fury had been taken to the veterinary practice on May 13, 2023, for elective euthanasia after Butlin had reported weight loss and diarrhoea over a period of a few weeks. The dog weighed 23.6 kg (52 pounds) and was given a body score condition of just 1/9.

Based on the clinical examination and Fury’s age, trial treatment and/or further diagnostics was advised by the vet before euthanasia, the court was told, but Butlin was adamant that neither would be considered.

However, he did agree to sign the dog over into the care of the vets.

Martin Butlin from Sheffield kept two starving and neglected former racing dogs on an allotment
Butlin took two-year-old Fury to a vet for elective euthanasia but ultimately agreed to sign him over. Fury was nursed back to health and is now in a loving new home.

Ravenous when offered food, Fury began to gain weight over the following weeks and weighed 29.6kg (65.25 pounds) just over three weeks later. He has since been adopted by a veterinary nurse from the practice and renamed Alfie.

The deceased dog Mick was extremely emaciated and had sunken eyes, visible pressure sores and callouses, some of which had appeared to expose the underlying bone.

Butlin had spoken to the vets two days earlier and said Mick had stopped eating over the last few weeks, lost weight, and gone ‘off his feet’. When advised to bring the dog in straight away he had refused and instead booked an appointment for June 1, 2023.

In her evidence to the court, the vet said: “When Fury was initially admitted it was uncertain whether there was a medical cause for his weight loss. Blood tests and faecal samples tested over the next few days were unremarkable. After admission he did not have diarrhoea, and he was ravenous when offered food. Over the next few weeks, he started to gain weight.

“In my professional opinion there was no justification for the animal to be euthanised, and there was no medical problem with Fury other than issues relating to starvation and neglect. We expect the sores on his legs were caused from extended periods laying on a hard surface, and that he had been suffering for a period of several months.

“Subsequently a further greyhound called Mick was presented by Mr Butlin for examination by a colleague on June 1. This dog was dead on arrival and showed signs of neglect and starvation. His body condition score was 1/9 and he had open sores on his legs similar to Fury.

“In my professional opinion Mr Butlin presented one animal for euthanasia for no other reason than mistreatment, followed by a second animal for disposal which also showed clear signs of neglect.”

In mitigation, magistrates were told that Butlin had caring responsibilities. He was said to be ashamed and deeply upset about the suffering he had caused. He was described as a caring man who had had dogs all his life, but he accepted the level of attention and care he had provided to Fury and Mick had broken down.

Other dogs being kept by Butlin were rehomed or signed over into RSPCA care during the course of the investigation. Because of the disqualification order, any that still remain in his care will also have to be rehomed.

RSPCA inspector Ben Cottle-Shaw, who investigated said: “There is never an excuse to allow pets to suffer such wilful neglect and suffering.

This was such a sad case but I do take some comfort in the fact that Fur is now a thriving and healthy much-loved dog enjoying the life he deserves with his new owner.”

Sentencing | 12-month community order with 150 hours of unpaid work; costs of £400 and a victim surcharge of £114. Banned indefinitely from keeping dogs.

The Star
YorkshireLive
Yorkshire Post

Tooting, Wandsworth, South West London: Harry Booth

CONVICTED (2023) | Harry Booth, born c. 1996, of Dalebury Road, Tooting SW17 7HH – kicked his dog in the head during an angry outburst.

Harry Booth appeared at Brighton Magistrates’ Court on November 8, 2023, where he pleaded guilty to one count of causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal and one count of affray.

The court heard that in Brighton on May 17, 2022, he kicked a rottweiler repeatedly to the head in what was described as a “psychotic episode”.

Booth was “extremely unwell” when he attacked the dog after a row in Budgens in Queens Road, central Brighton, in the early hours.

Prosecuting, Benjamin Parkinson said Booth’s dog had lunged at a customer after he went into the Budgens at about 1am.

He said: “The defendant and the customer had a verbal argument and the dog again lunged at them.

“The defendant took the muzzle off the dog and made threats towards the customer, and threw a bottle.

“The customer paid and left the shop. The defendant made a threat to fight a member of staff.

“CCTV captures the defendant’s behaviour outside the shop and shows him kicking the dg multiple times.

“Police attended, and the defendant gave a false name and date of birth and could be hard saying on body worn camera footage ‘F*** the law.’”

The incident of affray took place on the same day during an altercation with train staff.

The court was told that Booth used his dog as a weapon during that incident.

Defending, Alison Reedy said Booth had suffered from mental health episodes since his teens, had been sectioned several times and sent to mental hospitals across the country.

But it was only recently he had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, was now receiving treatment for that and was “in a much better place.”

She said when he was told what he had been charged with, his main concern was his dog.

She said: “He’s clearly very fond of his dog and wants the best for him. He’s a lovely dog.

“He would never harm that dog intentionally – he’s horrified that he has done.

“He’s someone who forms a very strong bond with animals. He was able to give the dog a good life. They loved each other.”

Sentencing | six-month prison sentence, suspended for 18 months. Disqualified from keeping pets for two years (expires November 2025) and the rottweiler was confiscated from him.

The Argus
Brighton and Hove News
This is Local London

Biddulph Moor, Staffordshire, Charles Gibson and Alison Bailey

CONVICTED (2023) | Charles W Gibson, born c. 1972, and Alison Bailey, born c. 1979, of Leonards Farm, Hot Lane, Biddulph Moor, Stoke-on-Trent ST8 7HP – for the appalling neglect of dozens of animals found dead and dying on their squalid dairy farm.

Farming couple Charles Gibson and Alison bailey let cows suffer in squalor as multiple dead animals were found dead and dying

The couple, who left livestock to suffer and die in dung and slurry, stood ashen-faced in Telford Magistrates Court as a district judge condemned their “utterly disgraceful” animal neglect.

In a visit to Leonards Farm one officer had described the “stench of rotting animals to be overwhelming” and the scenes they found were appalling.

The court saw shocking videos of rows of dead and emaciated cattle who had been denied even water to drink for long periods. The judge said the videos he had seen showed dung and slurry had been ankle-deep at best.

Farm buildings had holes in the roof and even no roof at all while concrete floors had been covered in slurry and manure because Gibson “could not be bothered” to clean them out.

“It was utterly disgraceful,” said District Judge Kevin Grego. “Animals had died and been left where they lay. Dead animals were left in unguarded open pits which other animals could just walk into.

“Charles Gibson, you ignored any proper view of animal husbandry. All the animals in your care were very badly mistreated.”

Gibson pleaded guilty to 28 charges of causing unnecessary suffering and failing to ensure the welfare of cattle, sheep, goats, a herd of 26 cattle and a flock of 31 sheep including one blind ram.

His co-accused Alison Bailey admitted neglecting a flock of chickens.

She pleaded guilty to one charge of causing unnecessary suffering to an injured young hen, another charge of failing to ensure the needs of an animal were met, and another that she failed to protect a flock of more than 50 young and laying hens from pain, suffering, injury and disease.

The court was told that the number of charges had been reduced from more than 100 to the 28 that Gibson faced and the three against Bailey.

The judge said that the floors of farm buildings had been “unscraped for months” and “living beasts were left to rot and indeed die”.

The offences had been discovered between May and December 2020 by trading standards officers who had received a complaint from a member of the public.

Jane Sarginson KC, prosecuting, had told the court that a council officer had “never seen animals more desperate for water”. An officer was “mugged” by the animals when a bucket of water was taken into one of the pens.

Thirty-five calves on the site drank 75 litres of water in one go, she told the court.

A calf, she said, had a “tennis ball-sized lump on the side of its face” and a bull had been kept “deep in muck and slurry over a foot deep”.

In a visit to the farm one officer had described the “stench of rotting animals to be overwhelming” with five dead and rotting calves covered in fly and maggot infestation.

She added that one poor creature was thought to be pregnant but in fact had a prolapse and had to be put down on the spot.

A large number of animals had to be euthanised by vets, their condition being so poor, including a piglet that had been stuck in the mud. Some 29 calves had to be “humanely dispatched,” said Jane Sarginson.

Two burial pits had been found on the site, despite it being illegal to dispose of creatures in this way.

Adrian Roberts, mitigating for Gibson and Bailey, asked the judge to be as lenient as he could as Gibson was earning £600 per week but had £20,000 in debts. Bailey, he said, had mental health concerns.

He asked the judge to allow them to keep their pets, including cats, dogs, chickens and goats, but this was denied.

They were given 48 hours to arrange for their domestic pets to be taken away from them.

Sentencing |
Gibson: 20-week prison sentence suspended for 12 months; 200 hours of unpaid work over the next 12 months; £4,000 in court costs.
Bailey: 80 hours of unpaid work; £1,000 in court costs.
They were also both disqualified from keeping all animals, including pets, and banned from being party to any control or influence, dealing and transportation of animals, indefinitely.

Stoke Sentinel
BBC News