Condover, Shrewsbury, Shropshire: Ben and Alexandra Evans

CONVICTED (2017) | Ben and Alexandra Evans, born c. 1999, from the Pigeon Door travellers site, Condover, near Shrewsbury – left a badly injured lurcher in the boot of a car

Gypsy animal abusers Ben and Alexandra Evans from Shropshire

Gypsies Ben and Alexandra Evans were due to face cruelty charges in relation to a lurcher named Chico but failed to turn up at court. The case was proved in their absence, however.

Chico, a dog badly abused by gypsies Ben and Alexandra Evans from Shropshire

Mr Roger Price, prosecuting, said the RSPCA received calls from members of the public who said they suspected an injured dog was at the Evans’ address.

Chico, a dog badly abused by gypsies Ben and Alexandra Evans from Shropshire. Image dhows dog's emaciated conditon.
Chico, a dog badly abused by gypsies Ben and Alexandra Evans from Shropshire. Image shows the dog's leg lacerations.

An inspector visited the property on November 26, 2016, and Chico was found in the boot of a car.

Mr Price said the dog was ‘trembling’, appeared to be in pain and had wounds to his leg.

He said faeces and urine were also found in the boot along with some dog food and a washing-up bowl with water inside.

Alexandra Evans told the inspector that the dog belonged to her and her husband and they had only owned the animal since the previous day.

However, Mr Price said Alexandra Evans had reported a dog missing on November 12 2016 and the RSPCA believed it was the same animal.

After the report was made, the dog warden received numerous calls from people who believed they had seen the animal and noticed it looked thin and was limping.

Gypsy animal abusers Ben and Alexandra Evans from Shropshire

Mr Price said Alexandra Evans allowed the inspector to take the dog to see a vet and signed the animal over to the RSPCA on November 30, 2016, despite initially refusing to do so.

When the vet saw Chico, he said the animal was in poor body condition.

Mr Price said: “The dog yelped, cried and moved away during the examination.”

He said X-rays showed the dog had a broken elbow and a tension pin had to be fitted in surgery.

Chico also had a deep laceration to his leg.

Dog abusing traveller Alexandra Evans from Shropshire
Alexandra Evans

Mr Price told the court: “This is a charge that relates to a lurcher type dog.

“It is a case of unnecessary suffering being caused to the dog.

“The dog plainly should have been taken to a vet because it had a broken leg and infected wounds.

“The vet indicated in his report that the animal was clearly suffering.”

He said an inspector from the RSPCA had called the couple in December 2016 to request that they come in for an interview, but the pair refused.

Despite their non-attendance at court, magistrates found the defendants had each caused unnecessary suffering to the dog by failing to provide veterinary treatment for a broken leg.

They issued a warrant for the couple, who will have to come to Telford Magistrates Court on a future date to be sentenced.

Shropshire Star


Update | June 2017

The Shropshire Star reported that the Evans’ convictions had been quashed. They were due to face a retrial in November 2017 but no details were reported online.

Shropshire Star


Update | February 2023

Ben Evans was fined after being caught hare-coursing alongside accomplices Michael Toogood from Market Drayton and Joseph Smith from Stourport.

Alloa, Clackmannanshire: Lorna Wood

CONVICTED (2017) | Lorna Jacqueline Wood, born 26 September 1982, of Torridon Court, Alloa FK10 1PS – failed to feed two dogs in her care for a number of weeks

Lorna Wood from Alloa, Clackmannanshire, who starved two dogs over several weeks. Photo: Facebook

Single mother-of-three Lorna Wood admitted a charge of causing unnecessary suffering by failing to provide adequate nutrition resulting in lost body weight and failure to provide adequate care and treatment for the two dogs, named Maisie and Lola.

Maisie and Lola were emaciated after being starved by Lorna Wood from Allow. Image: SSPCA
Lola

Speaking about the investigation, Scottish SPCA Inspector Louise Seddon, said: “Maisie, the Border collie, was extremely thin under her coat and I could only feel bones rather than fat or muscle.

“All of Lola’s bones were visible, to the extent that her head looked too big for her body.

“After being taken to the vets it was revealed that both dogs weighed only 13.2kg, when they should have both weighed around 20kg.

“Although it was difficult to pinpoint an exact time frame as to how long they had been suffering, the vet confirmed that they had a lack of food for a number weeks.

Maisie and Lola have recovered in the care of the Scottish SPCA
Maisie and Lola have recovered in the care of the Scottish SPCA

“Whilst in our care it became clear to us that Maisie and Lola were simply not being fed as they quickly put on a significant amount of weight when they were fed adequately.

Lorna Wood from Alloa, Clackmannanshire, who starved two dogs over several weeks. Photo: Facebook

“We are delighted that Wood has been dealt with by the courts and hope she will give serious consideration to her ability to care for animals in the future.”

Sentencing: banned from keeping animals for three years (expired May 2020).

Alloa Advertiser
The Sun


Update March 2022

Wood’s pathetic three-year ban expired in 2020. Despite the SSPCA’s hope that she would recognise her unsuitability for owning animals, Wood appears to have two new dogs.

Lorna Wood uploaded this image of two dogs to Facebook  in March 2022

Reading, Berkshire: Martin Sama

CONVICTED (2017) | career criminal Martin Alie Sama, born November 1987, of Faringdon Walk, Reading RG30 3LD – attacked a police dog during a pursuit

Persistent criminal Martin Sama from Reading, UK, attacked PD Caesar during a pursuit.
Persistent criminal Martin Sama attacked PD Caesar during a pursuit. Fortunately Caesar recovered from his injuries and is back on duty while Sama was sent to jail.

Sama, who is originally from Sierra Leone, was convicted of causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal, assaulting a constable, possessing an offensive weapon in a public place, possessing cannabis, driving dangerously and driving while disqualified and without insurance.

The court heard that PD Caesar, a Dutch Shepherd, pursued Sama, who then attacked the dog and bit his handler.

It came after police constable Christopher Bushnell spotted a shredded back tyre on a Lexus, being driven by the persistent offender.

The officer pursued Sama, who drove through two red lights and swerved across multiple lanes.

The court heard how Sama then jumped out of the out of the moving car and sprinted down an alley. This prompted the policeman to release Caeser.

Giving evidence, PC Bushnell said: “Caesar chased the male down the alley way and I followed.

“I heard the male scream. Caesar had bit him in the buttock. The man was lashing out and swinging Caesar’s body. The man was striking the dog.

“Caesar released his grip and dropped off.”

Aware that Caesar, who had been working with him for nearly four years, could be in trouble, PC Bushnell called for backup and swung a punch at Sama.

Persistent criminal Martin Sama from Reading, UK, attacked PD Caesar during a pursuit.
2010 police mugshot of Sama

Sama bit the policeman’s fingers whilst he was being restrained, the court heard.

When more officers arrived minutes later they found Sama to be in possession of a small amount of cannabis and a 20-inch machete.

Limping Caesar was taken to a vets the following day and had to take four days off the beat.

Persistent criminal Martin Sama from Reading, UK, attacked PD Caesar during a pursuit.
Sama pictured outside court

Despite admitting he was driving the car, Sama denied the drugs were his.

“That cannabis was found in a cigarette packet on the alley floor,” he told District Judge Susan Cooper.

“It had nothing to do with me.”

He also claimed the machete was brought into the car by a mystery man he was giving a lift to and whose name he did not know, and that he did not hit the dog or bite PC Bushnell.

He continued: “I did not strike the dog at all. I wouldn’t do that to a dog.

“I also didn’t bite the officers finger’s. I was beaten so badly I even lost my shoes.”

However Judge Cooper was not convinced by Sama, who has previous dangerous driving and drug convictions.

The judge added: “It seems ludicrous to suggest the cigarette packet wasn’t on you.

“Two officers could see it was. I also believe you were travelling at speed.

“You have come to court today and told many lies.”

Sentencing: 27 months in jail.

Reading Chronicle

Sleaford, Lincs: Carol Bowditch and Daniel Galloway

CONVICTED (2017) | Carol Bowditch, born 13/07/1952, and paedophile partner Daniel Galloway, both of Paperchase House, Papermill Lane, Evedon, Sleaford NG34 9PD – participated in bestiality parties involving dogs

Perverted Carol Bowditch, the 64-year-old filmed having sex with three dogs, aided and abetted by her equally depraved partner Daniel Galloway
Perverted Carol Bowditch, the pensioner filmed having sex with three dogs, aided and abetted by her equally depraved partner Daniel Galloway

Carol Bowditch was filmed having sex with a St Bernard, a black labrador and an Alsatian, claiming later she did not realise that it was illegal.

Her sick activities were exposed as a result of an RAF Police investigation which centred on a man identified as organising a bizarre sex party .

Owners watched their dogs having sex with women, who then had sex with the men.

Details of the event were later posted on an internet forum specialising in bestiality.

The investigation led police to search the home shared by Bowditch and Galloway where they found a DVD and USB stick.

The seized devices included an eight minute video of Bowditch engaging in sex with a St Bernard dog named Oscar and still images of child pornography.

When Galloway was questioned by police he admitted aiding Bowditch to have sex with dogs and named two of the animals as “Badger” and “Rocky”.. He was also caught with over 12,000 indecent images of children as well as 191 extreme images of Bowditch having sex with dogs.

James Gray, in mitigation, said both Bowditch and Galloway had suffered considerable public humiliation.

Sentence: Bowditch – 12-month community order. Galloway – 12 months in jail. He must register as a sex offender for ten years and was made the subject of a Sexual Harm Prevention Order.

The Mirror 10/04/17
The Mirror 16/05/17

Aldingbourne, West Sussex: Martin Cox

CONVICTED (2017) | Martin James Cox, born c. 1964, of Hook Lane, Aldingbourne, Chichester PO20 – kicked his dog repeatedly in the ribs

Dog abuser Martin James Cox from Aldingbourne, Chichester, West Sussex, UK
Violent drunk Martin James Cox was banned from keeping animals until May 2020

Cox was walking his pet Rottweiler in Bognor Regis in the early hours of September 14, 2017, when a taxi worker saw him kicking his dog in the ribs.

Cox pleaded not guilty to the charge of causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal.

Cox said he had been at Bognor Regis beach earlier in the day with pet Rocky. He then went to a pub before making his journey home along London Road towards the railway station.

Nicole Redman, who works for Yellow Star taxis, told the court: “I was outside having a conversation with some drivers and I saw a man walking down the high street, staggering all over the place with a dog on a lead.

“My thoughts were that he was obviously drunk.

“I saw him kick the dog in the ribs at least three times. It was quite a forceful, purposeful kick like kicking a football. It upset me and made me worried for the dog.”

Ms Redman called the police after seeing the incident.

Officers arrested Cox at about 12.10am.

Giving evidence, Cox stated he had not kicked Rocky but ‘swiped along him with his foot’ to encourage him to walk in the right direction.

He added: “Rocky wanted to go towards the sea and he was pulling against the direction I was going.

“I would never kick Rocky, he is my baby and I love him.”

Giving the verdict, a magistrate said: “There is no dispute that you kicked him from the CCTV footage we have seen.

“Most reasonable people would identify what we saw as a kick.

“It is clear you have no real recall of that night, you were drunk.

“As a dog owner you should have known that the act of kicking would cause unnecessary suffering and your actions could have been avoided.”

Cox was found guilty of causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal.

Sentencing: ordered to pay a total of £882. Banned from owning or looking after any animal for three years (expired May 2020).

Bognor Regis Observer

Burngreave, Sheffield: Raeef Saeed

CONVICTED (2017) | Raeef Saeed, born c. 1992, of Melrose Road, Sheffield S3 9DN – glued a hamster to a plastic bottle in a ‘crucifixion pose’ for a sick Facebook selfie

Raeef Saeed from Sheffield posted a sick selfie to Facebook showing him torturing a hamster
Raeef Saeed from Sheffield posted a sick selfie to Facebook showing him torturing a hamster

In a prosecution case brought by the RSPCA, Saeed pleaded guilty to one offence under the Animal Welfare Act of causing unnecessary suffering to a small rodent by cruelly ill-treating the animal.

RSPCA inspector Jennie Ronksley said: “We got a call from a third party who had seen the ‘selfie’ then it ended up on Facebook and the post identified Saeed.

“I attended his house and he was shown a screenshot of the photo and admitted it was him. He was laughing and smiling – he couldn’t understand what all the fuss was about as he said he hadn’t killed it.

“He claimed the rodent was a wild mouse he’d caught on a glue board – though vets suspect it was in fact a pet Russian dwarf hamster and co-incidentally the defendant had owned a hamster and even showed me the empty cage.

“He said he’d prised the rodent off the glue board with a spoon and washed it under a tap with water during which time it was squealing.

“Glue boards are essentially just boards or trays of plastic, wood or cardboard coated in a extremely strong, immediately holding glue.

“They are horribly cruel and cause enormous suffering to the animals unfortunate enough to get stuck in them. The act of removing the rodent from this would have been horrific for the tiny creature.

“If that wasn’t enough he then stuck the poor animal to the bottle to take the photo before, he said, letting it go in the house somewhere.

“We don’t know what happened to it after that, no body was recovered, but it seems impossible that things ended well.”

Sentencing: 80 hours of unpaid work; costs and charges totalling £285. 12-month disqualification on keeping all animals.

The Sun

Lampeter, Ceredigion, Wales: Richard Samuel Morgan Jones

CONVICTED (2017) | illegal dog breeder Richard Samuel Morgan Jones, born c. 1985, of Moelfre, Llanwnnen, Lampeter SA48 7NY – kept poorly dogs and puppies in appalling conditions at his puppy farm

Vile: heartless illegal puppy farmer Richard Jones from Llanwnnen, Lampeter, kept dogs and puppies in darkness and squalor and failed to treat their numerous health conditions
Vile: heartless illegal puppy farmer Richard Jones from Llanwnnen, Lampeter, kept dogs and puppies in darkness and squalor and failed to treat their numerous health conditions

Ceredigion Council brought the prosecution against Jones after raids at two premises in June 2016 found 113 dogs and puppies suffering.

He was convicted of two counts of illegal dog breeding and 21 counts of causing unnecessary suffering to dogs following two raids in June 2016.

Jones operated illegal puppy farms at two premises: one at the Moelfre farm and another at Creuddyn Bridge, Lampeter.

The horrific conditions at a Welsh puppy farm which saw illegal breeder Richard Jones banned from dealing in dogs

Officers from Ceredigion County found 113 dogs and puppies at both venues.

The animals were described by the vet who examined them as mentally stressed with no exercise or social contact, with many dogs homed on their own.

The horrific conditions at a Welsh puppy farm which saw illegal breeder Richard Jones banned from dealing in dogs

Many of the animals were described as dangerously thin, with one suffering from gangrene and septicaemia and close to death.

Some pups had been so neglected they showed signs of extreme mental suffering, while many were ‘close to death’.

The horrific conditions at a Welsh puppy farm which saw illegal breeder Richard Jones banned from dealing in dogs

The dogs included Bichon Frise, rottweilers, Scottish and West Highland terriers, beagles, Cavalier King Charles spaniels and Yorkshire terriers.

Council vet Dr John O’Connor documented the suffering of the animals in each of the 21 charges.

Among them was a male Scottish terrier which he said had a “very advanced chronic skin condition and the thinness would have resulted in the dog suffering unnecessarily for a considerable length of time”.

“The dog’s ears were also badly affected with crusting indicating severe damage from long standing inflammation and scratching,” he added.

A Bichon Frise female was found with “advanced cataracts” and a “right ear flap [that] appeared to be exhibiting the early signs of gangrene”.

The horrific conditions at a Welsh puppy farm which saw illegal breeder Richard Jones banned from dealing in dogs

Another Bichon Frise puppy, just a few days old, had to be “immediately removed” from the premises when found as “it was so thin and cold that it could no longer suck”.

“It was so thin that the body condition score would have been close to death,” Dr O’Connor previously told the court.

Jones had been running a licensed premises known as “The Shed” near Lampeter with over 70 dogs from 2010.

Its licence was renewed yearly until 2015 when the local authority decided not to renew it because of concerns.

The application was for 70 dogs to breed 40 litters a year.

In 2016, an application was not made by Jones, but he carried on breeding.

Searches of both his premises was carried out with 56 dogs found at “The Shed” and 38 puppies and 19 dogs found at Moelfre farm.

Illegal puppy farmer Richard Jones from Lampeter, Wales

Jones’ defence claimed he was devastated by the refusal for a licence in 2015 after making considerable investments at “The Shed” and felt he had been dealt with disproportionately by the local authority.

Matthew Paul, for Jones, told the court his ability to care for the dogs had been affected by personal issues including depression, and the need to care for the family farm.

“It was not deliberate neglect, but circumstances overtook him”, he said.

The court said all dogs should be removed from his premises by 2 March, 2017.

Sentencing:
Nine-week suspended prison sentence. 200 hours of unpaid work. Banned from keeping dogs for four years – later overturned on appeal with Jones being allowed to keep dogs for “hill farming”. He is banned from “dealing in dogs” for six years (expires February 2023). 

BBC News
WalesOnline 09/02/2017
WalesOnline 12/05/2017
Ceredigion Council report on the prosecution

Oldbury, West Midlands: Susanne Nulty

CONVICTED (2017) | Susanne Nulty (aka Susie Harrison), born 22/05/1977, most recently of Tatbank Road, Oldbury, West Midlands but with links to Lichfield, Staffordshire and Nuneaton, Warwickshire – moved out of her house, leaving her Cavalier King Charles spaniel to die in a locked toilet

Susanne Nulty from Lichfield, Staffs abandoned Cavalier King Charles Spaniel Todd in an empty house with no food or water for six weeks.
Susanne Nulty from Lichfield, Staffs abandoned Cavalier King Charles Spaniel Todd in an empty house with no food or water for six weeks.

Cruel Susanne Nulty left her pet dog Todd to starve to death in a locked toilet when she abandoned her home on Milne Avenue, Lichfield. The spaniel was found dead on a pile of rubbish by shocked bailiffs when they entered the property.

Initially, they thought he was a toy dog – but on closer inspection realised he was dead.

Susanne Nulty from Lichfield, Staffs abandoned Cavalier King Charles Spaniel Todd in an empty house with no food or water for six weeks.
Todd’s body was found on top of a pile of rubbish inside the locked bathroom.

Todd’s emaciated body was found six weeks after Nulty had left the property having been served an eviction notice. Scratches on the bathroom door showed his pitiful attempts to escape.

Susanne Nulty from Lichfield, Staffs abandoned Cavalier King Charles Spaniel Todd in an empty house with no food or water for six weeks.

Mother-of-four Nulty pleaded guilty to causing unnecessary suffering to the 11-year-old dog.

RSPCA inspector Laura Bryant, who investigated the case, said: “Nulty had left Todd in the house, with no food or drink, and made no provisions for anyone to take care of him.

“Nobody knew the dog was in the house, not even the neighbours as they didn’t hear any barking.

Susanne Nulty from Lichfield, Staffs abandoned Cavalier King Charles Spaniel Todd in an empty house with no food or water for six weeks.
Todd was locked in a bathroom to die by Nulty whom the RSPCA said had failed him “in the worst possible way”.

“There were two levels of suffering – the physical suffering of starvation and dehydration, and the mental suffering of anxiety and stress, not knowing if anyone was coming for him or when he would be fed.

“It is so sad to think that Todd was locked in this small toilet, with no stimulation, no fresh air, barely any room to move and no contact with another human or animal – on top of the fact that he was slowly starving to death.

“It would have been a miserable existence for him, living in this small, dark room which was covered in rubbish and faeces.

“It is just absolutely awful and stomach-churning to think of the slow, painful and distressing death Todd suffered.

“There is no excuse to do this to an animal. Pet-owners have a legal responsibility to ensure their animals do not suffer – sadly, Nulty failed Todd in the worst possible way.”

Sentencing: 12-week prison sentence suspended for 12 months; 100 hours of unpaid work; costs and charges totalling £415. Lifetime disqualification order on all animals.

Birmingham Mail
Express & Star


Additional Information

Old FB profile: https://www.facebook.com/susanne.harrison.12

Abertillery, South Wales: Paul James

CONVICTED (2017) | Paul James, born 25/05/1961, of 56 Arrael View, Abertillery NP13 1ST – wrapped his poorly dog in an old carpet and dumped him at the roadside

Poorly dog Max was dumped by his callous owner, Paul James of Abertillery, South Wales.
Poorly dog Max was dumped by his callous owner, Paul James of Abertillery, South Wales.

James pleaded guilty to three Animal Welfare Act offences at Cwmbran Magistrates’ Court on 24/04/2017.

These included an offence of failing to meet the needs of the dog – named Max – after he was dumped in a deteriorating physical condition near Fochriw Mountain, on August 12, 2016. The dog was found by a member of the public and later put down on welfare grounds.

James also admitted to causing the dog unnecessary suffering by failing to provide veterinary care and attention for a severely infected right ear, and for signs of illness.

Poorly dog Max was dumped by his callous owner, Paul James of Abertillery, South Wales.
Sadly Max was too ill to be saved

RSPCA Cymru, who identified the dog’s owner after a social media appeal, say the case highlights the potential consequences of abandoning injured animals.

RSPCA inspector, Annie Simmonds, said: “It was heartbreaking that in this dog’s moment of need, instead of companionship and compassion, his owner chose to dump him like this, to die alone and suffering.

“We are grateful to the public for their support, following our initial appeal for information.”

Sentencing: 18-week custodial sentence for each offence, suspended for 12 months and to run concurrently. Ordered to pay costs and charges totalling £515. Banned from keeping any animal for the rest of his life.

South Wales Argus
Metro

Swadlincote, Derbyshire: Julia and Rachel Nall

CONVICTED 2017) | Julia Nall, born c. 1969, and daughter Rachel Nall, born c. 1994, both of New Street, Measham, Swadlincote DE12 7JN – left horses to die in their own faeces

Horse abuser Rachel Nall from Swadlincote, Derbyshire
Horse abuser Rachel Nall is banned from keeping equines for life along with her mother Julia Nall and brother Simon Nall

Julia and Rachel Nall had left two horses to rot while the four horses left alive were so malnourished one was suffering from pneumonia.

RSPCA inspectors said one horse was so badly decomposed they could not establish a cause of death, in the worst case of its kind they had ever seen.

Horses died after being abandoned by Julie and Rachel Nall from Swadlincote, Derbyshire
Several horses starved to death in a filthy stable after being abandoned by Julie and Rachel Nall and their bodies were then left to rot

A piebald colt called Storm, belonging to Julia Nall’s son Simon Nall, who was prosecuted separately and convicted, also died while two bay mares, Twinkle and Poppy, a grey gelding called Bugs and Dotty, a Shetland mare, were starved.

The Nalls admitted unnecessary suffering by failing to explore and address the cause of the horses’ poor bodily conditions at their stable in Overseal, South Derbyshire.

The RSPCA was contacted after the decomposing bodies of two horses were found in the stable in a field.

Horses died after being abandoned by Julie and Rachel Nall from Swadlincote, Derbyshire

RSPCA inspector Laura Bryant, who investigated, said: ‘I have never seen a horse in such a bad way before. ‘One of the horses in the stable was so decomposed and rotting that we could not establish how he died.

‘The other horse, named Storm, had died more recently and we were able to establish through a post-mortem examination that he had died as a result of emaciation.

‘He was in such a bad way before he died – he had untreated laminitis, was lying in his own faeces and his hooves were severely deformed, as they had overgrown by around nine inches.

‘It was terrible to see. On top of that, the stable was completely filled with faeces and was not a suitable environment for horses to be kept in.’

The four surviving horses were assessed by a vet, where they were all found to be in poor body condition as a result of not having enough food.

Inspector Bryant added: ‘The horses were being fed, but only small amounts of hay and not enough to sustain healthy body weights.

‘As a result, they began to suffer because of the effects of emaciation.

‘Horses are expensive animals to look after and it is so important that people realise just how much they can cost.

‘In this case, Julia Nall and Rachel Nall were not able to afford to keep six horses, which resulted in them all suffering.

‘Keeping horses is an incredible privilege however we hope that this case highlights how demanding equine-care can be.’

The four surviving horses have all since recovered and have been re-homed.

Sentencing: 18-week custodial sentence suspended for two years; ordered to pay £500. Lifetime ban on keeping equines.

Metro
Horse & Hound