Tag Archives: 2021 cases

Northwich, Cheshire: Claire/John Goodier

CONVICTED (2021) | transvestite Claire Goodier, born c. 1960, of Weaver View Flats, Spencer Street, Northwich CW8 1BP – had cocaine-fuelled group sex with a dog and possessed images of the depraved act.

Claire Goodier

Lifelong pervert Goodier, a twice-convicted paedophile previously known as John Ernest Goodier, admitted five charges, including one for the possession of seven half-gram bags of cocaine.

The most serious of the charges related to one where Goodier allowed himself to be penetrated by an Alsatian dog at an unspecified location in Bournemouth on December 15 and 16, 2018.

He also admitted being in possession of 31 extreme pornographic images of a German Shepherd dog having sex with a person, which were grossly offensive, disgusting or otherwise of an obscene character.

As well as admitting being in possession of other offensive images, Goodier also failed to comply with the notification requirements of the sex offenders register.

He pleaded guilty to a charge of failing to conduct his annual notification on November 5, 2020.

Goodier was caught after police attended her home on July 19, 2019, to carry out a routine check due to him being on the sex offenders register for life.

Officers took a laptop which contained evidence Goodier had searched the internet for bestiality content and when a full analysis of the equipment was finally completed some two years later, it emerged hidden folders contained 31 indecent images of Goodier taking part in the sex act with the dog.

Goodier told officers he had fantasised about it for a number of years and after talking about it with people in Northwich, was put in touch with others in Bournemouth.

He travelled down there in December 2018 and took part in the sex act with other people and the dog.

At the time of his arrest on June 17, 2021, police also found another pen drive in his handbag containing the same images and 3.5 grammes of cocaine.

When he committed the sex act, Goodier had also been in breach of a suspended sentence order, which had been imposed in May 2018 for failing to adhere to the terms of a sexual harm prevention order.

Goodier had also failed to comply with the terms of the sexual harm prevention order in November 2020, when he was 13 days late contacting the police after being in isolation due to Covid guidelines.

Sending Goodier to prison, Judge Steven Everett told him he agreed with the probation service assessing him as being a low risk of re-offending.

He told Goodier: “You are a long, long way from changing your life.

“You deceitfully took part in a cocaine-fuelled incident with other persons.

“Since the terrible offence took place you kept the images unashamedly for your own sexual gratification.

“In the middle of all this, you failed to comply with the terms of an order, which some might say is a minor breach, but it’s not for the first time.

“Your record is appalling and it could be said you were astonishingly lucky not to go to prison previously.

“A message must go out that if you commit such disgusting behaviour then you must go to prison.”

Goodier sobbed in the dock as he was told he will serve 20 months behind bars, which included the activation of the four-month sentence he had in suspension when committing the act.

Chester Standard


Additional information:

The Daily Mail reports that Goodier has been sent to a men’s prison because he is not legally female.

Goodier has identified as a woman for at least two years and was referred to as Claire and ‘she’ during his Chester Crown Court case.

He has been sent to Liverpool’s HMP Altcourse, which is .a Category B men’s private prison and Young Offender Institution.

A source said: “Prisoners go to whichever prison matches their legally recognised gender.

“This defendant is in a male prison, HMP Altcourse.”

Goodier was identified in court listings under a male name but with a note added to be addressed in the hearing as Claire. A Sexual Harm Prevention Order issued is under that female identity.

The Gender Recognition Act 2004 allows people to change their legal sex and obtain a Gender Recognition certificate proving it – which is valid in prisons.

St Austell, Cornwall: Rosie Zolla

#MostEvil | Rosie Zolla, born 12 November 1993, of North Street, St Austell PL25 – drowned her pet cat after he trashed her kitchen.

Zolla pleaded guilty to two counts of causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal.

On February 19, 2021, Zolla’s pet cat Nana McPhee, a black and white male, who she’d had for six months was acting up in the kitchen of her then-home on Trembath Crescent, Newquay.

She took the cat upstairs, placed him in the bath, and drowned him by – according to a post mortem examination – possibly holding him under the water.

Zolla then took the body of the cat and placed it in the freezer.

Prosecuting the case at court, RSPCA prosecutor Tamsin Murphy said: “RSPCA inspector Kempson attended on February 19 2021 with a police officer, following reports Zolla had deliberately drowned a cat and put the body in a freezer.

“She let them in and admitted that she had put the cat in the bath, and put its body in the freezer.

“She had the cat for about six months, and asked how it died she said she put it in the bath.”

On February 24, two other RSPCA officers interviewed Zolla at her home and asked for more information on what happened.

She told the officers that the cat ruined her kitchen, and that she left him in the bath because it “had something coming out of its bum.”

Zolla said she was unsure how exactly how the cat died.

Dr Taylor, a veterinary pathologist, determined that Nana McPhee died due to drowning, and that he had injuries including water, blunt trauma to the face, and a skin injury near its anus.

The pathologist also reported that the cat would have suffered for a long time leading up to his death, and that there was some evidence he may have been held under the water.

Ms Murphy further told the court: “There were no signs of a cancer condition, or any tumours, swelling or other diseases to the cat.

“There are no previous matters against Ms Zolla, but there was no remorse shown to the RSPCA as far as she is concerned about the incident.”

Zolla’s lawyer said, in her defence, that she had been “suffering from profound mental health problems and alcoholism” when she drowned the cat.

He added: “Since then there have been a lot of changes in her life, she’s engaging with support services like We Are With You for example.

“Simply put, she’s on track to put right the things she did wrong at the time of this awful offence.

“She has a much more stable family life now, in a serious relationship with a man who supports her and they’re expecting a baby in June.”

He further said she had been receiving treatment for her alcoholism.

The magistrates retired for quite some time to read a report prepared by the two sides about the case.

Upon their return, they told Zolla that she would not be going to prison immediately – but that she is on thin ice.

The bench said: “We considered the matter carefully and we reached the conclusion that it is certainly past the custody threshold. This was really horrible cruelty to an animal, and we have no doubts in our minds it past it. However I’ll tell you we’ll suspend the sentence and I’ll give you the details in a minute.

“But first I want it made abundantly clear that we found this whole act of animal cruelty abhorrent. Utterly unacceptable madam.

“The fact the sentence we’ll pass is being suspended is not to be taken as any indication of this bench feeling this is not of the upmost gravity. It is.”

The magistrates continued: “”We were asked by our legal advisor why we were suspending this. We actually have two reasons. The first is your previous good character, second we actually have some belief in rehabilitation here.

“That is the reason this is not an instant custodial sentence. Our guidelines quite clearly say we can only suspend a sentence if we honestly believe that if the power was not there to suspend it we would send you straight to prison today. I tell you quite candidly we passed that threshold without a doubt.”

The magistrates finished by instructing a probation officer to keep in touch with the local authority regarding Zolla’s pregnancy, citing “concerns” over her caring “for any animal, be it a human or a cat.”

Sentencing: 18-week prison sentence suspended for two years, £400 to pay in costs and £128 as a victim surcharge; mental health and alcohol treatment requirement; rehabilitation. Banned from keeping pets for ten years with no chance of it being appealed sooner, despite protestations from Zolla’s defence.

Cornwall Live

Kingston Upon Hull: Luke Harrison and Liam Tattersall

CONVICTED (2021) | Luke Harrison, born 25 April 1993, of Weighton Grove, Hull HU6 8NE, and Liam Martin Tattersall, born c. 2000, of Park Grove, Hull HU5 – launched a merciless attack on a family dog, leaving him in crying in distress.

Liam Tattersall (left) and cousin Luke Harrison.

The pair, who are cousins, were staying at the Skipsea Sands holiday park in East Yorkshire when witnesses saw them punching, slapping and kicking a Staffordshire bull terrier, known as Patchy.

Patchy. Picture: Yorkshire Post.
Abused pet Patchy

When questioned about their actions at a later date, Harrison said that was how they were taught to treat animals growing up, a court heard.

Harrison and Tattersall initially denied causing necessary harm to a protected animal.

During a trial held at Hull Magistrates Court on November 8, 2021, Tattersall entered a late guilty plea, and Harrison was found to be guilty in the trial that proceeded in his absence.

Luke Harrison is a father of two but his partner, Natasha Sylvester, has six children in the home where he lives.

RSPCA prosecutor Andrew Davidson told the court that Harrison, Patchy’s owner, was seen by a couple staying at a plot next to them being physically abusive to the dog on several occasions. The couple saw him hitting him with his fist twice while the terrified animal yelped in pain.

On another occasion, Tattersall was seen hitting Patchy twice on the head with force and kicking him.

Harrison and Tattersall moved out of their caravan into a tent at one point. During this time, through the reflection of the shadows, the couple could make out that one of the men was hitting the dog again,

Tattersall (left) and Harrison pictured during their court appearance.

Mr Davidson told the court. When the male witness approached the tent to stop the man, Harrison emerged and said: “What’s it got to do with you? Mind your own business.”

The witnesses called site security. When questioned about his actions, he said: “That is how we have been taught to treat animals.”

The next day, the witnesses saw the men punching the dog and swearing at it, telling it to “get out of the f**king way”

During an RSPCA investigation, Tattersall said he had seen Harrison treating Patchy in that manner and that was why he did the same.

Harrison said: “He was whinging and crying all day, what else was I supposed to do?”

Mr Davidson said: “On the whole this was an unnecessary and cruel assault on a defenceless dog.”

Nick Tubbs, mitigating for Harrison said he did not attend the trial due to childcare reasons, as there are six children in the house he lives in. He added that Harrison felt ‘enormous regret’ for what he did. He had most of his adult life and did not have issues with any of them.

Matthew Coggin, mitigating for Tattersall, said the defendant felt ‘extremely remorseful’.

“The reason behind his involvement was immaturity and influence from others,” Mr Coggin added.

Sentencing:
Harrison – 12-week suspended sentence, 80 hours of unpaid work. Disqualified from owning a dog for 15 years.

Tattersall – eight-week suspended sentence, 60 hours of unpaid work. Disqualified from owning a dog for 10 years.

HullLive
Yorkshire Post


Additional Information

Harrison’s partner, Natasha Sylvester, was also prosecuted by the RSPCA in relation to the same dog.

Natasha ‘Tash’ Sylvester

It’s not known if the charges against her were dropped.

Whitchurch, Shropshire: Peter and Debbie Rogers

CONVICTED (2021) | kitten breeders Peter Rogers, born c. 1957, and wife Debbie Rogers, born c. 1961, of Field Cottages, Alkington, Whitchurch SY13 3NE – allowed their cat to become emaciated and suffer with ruptured eyes.

Toffee. Picture: Shropshire Star.
Toffee

Persian cat Toffee was so poorly after months of neglect at the hands of the Rogers she had to be put down. The vet who examined Toffee said the case was one of the clearest cases of severe neglect that he had seen in the last decade.

The couple both pleaded guilty to two counts of causing unnecessary suffering to an animal.

RSPCA inspector Nayman Dunderdale visited the couple’s property on June 8, 2021, after the charity received a report about a matted silver tabby cat that was limping.

Peter Rogers told the inspector that Toffee, who was aged between four and five, had cancer and her eyes were missing. He said she needed to be put to sleep and it was his fault they had left it so long.

He said an appointment had been made at their vets for Toffee later that evening, but a check by the RSPCA inspector ten minutes later, revealed that while the practice had some of the couple’s other cats on their books, they did not have one registered under that name. Peter Rogers also told the inspector they were cat breeders.

In his statement, Mr Dunderdale said: “Mr Rogers brought the cat to me. Her eyes were closed and matted with green gunk and she looked very thin, with the bones of her hip spine and hind quarters easily visible.

“Mr Rogers asked me to take her, and said she needed to be put to sleep. I asked that Toffee be brought to my van so I could put her in a basket.”

Toffee was taken straight to a vet where she was examined and found to be emaciated, with a body condition score of just one out of nine. She weighed 1.1kg (2.4lbs) and should have been at least 2 to 2.5kg (between 4.4lbs and 5.5lbs).

Both her eyes had ruptured many days or even weeks before, indicated by the presence of thick dried discharge all over her eye sockets and cheeks, which were embedded with matted hair. The discharge was also present on both her forelimbs where she had rubbed herself in an effort to relieve the discomfort.

The vet who examined Toffee said: “She had a gentle nature despite the horrendous discomfort she was no doubt experiencing. Unfortunately, her welfare was so severely compromised, and with such a slim chance of returning her to an acceptable level of quality of life, that she was euthanised shortly after examination.

“Corneal pain is one of the most acute and severe pain an animal can experience as the cornea is incredibly sensitive to even the lightest trauma. Her owners plainly ignored obvious signs of severe pain and distress over a prolonged period of time. They also allowed her to become very underweight to the point of emaciation.”

He added: “I have been a practising small animal veterinary surgeon for over 15 years. I regularly see cats with sore eyes of varying severity in my daily work. I also work alongside a vet with an interest in veterinary ophthalmology and we communicate regularly about cases, so I am very familiar with corneal issues in cats. In the course of the last decade this is one of the clearest cases of severe neglect that I have seen.”

In mitigation, the court heard that there had been bereavement and illness in the family and Peter Rogers was having mental health difficulties and struggling to cope generally.

In total 15 animals which were owned by the couple have since been rehomed.

Speaking after sentencing, Mr Dunderdale said: “It was clear that Toffee had been suffering pain and distress for a long time and her owners should have done the right thing by her and sought treatment at the earliest opportunity. Her quality of life was so poor at the end that there was no other option but to end her suffering. We always urge people to seek help if they are struggling to look after their pets, rather than letting the situation deteriorate to the extent that it did with Toffee.”

Sentencing: 200 hours of unpaid work; total costs and charges of £345. Lifetime ban on keeping all animals.

Birmingham Live
Shropshire Star

High Halstow, Kent: Benny Eastwood

CONVICTED (2021) | Benny Joe Eastwood, born 20 May 2002, of 2 Acre Farm, Ropers Green Lane, High Halstow, Rochester ME3 8QP – for cruelty to two “hunting” dogs.

Eastwood pleaded guilty to three offences under the Animal Welfare Act relating to two dogs; a bull lurcher called Max and a terrier called Skip.

RSPCA officers and Kent Police went to an address in High Halstow on 14 April 2021, after receiving information from social media that suggested dogs were being used in wildlife crimes.

RSPCA Special Operations Unit spokesperson, Will Mitchell said two dogs who were suffering from injuries, consistent with encounters with a fox or badger, were taken away.

Officers said they also found two dogs living in a wooden kennel block. A black and white lurcher, called Max, who was curled up in a corner had “obvious facial scarring”. A black and tan terrier, called Skip, had its top lip missing.

Eastwood admitted that both dogs belonged to him.

Eastwood told investigators that the terrier had had a fight with another dog but enquiries disproved this account.

An independent vet who assessed both dogs and assisted with the investigation said the lurcher weighed 25kgs and that his ribs, spine and bones of the pelvis were easily visible.

In his witness statement, he said: “There were multiple scars on the muzzle, head and ears. The scars on the head were at different stages of healing and it appeared that the injuries…were not the result of a single incident.”

Skip was found to have multiple scars on the muzzle and head. His ears had no hair and had multiple cuts.

The terrier also had part of his jaw missing and the vet said he couldn’t see there had been “any attempt to treat this substantial injury.”

The vet concluded that both dogs had suffered unnecessarily for an estimated period of approximately two weeks.

The court heard that Eastwood was young and vulnerable, but accepted wrongdoing and was remorseful.

Sergeant Darren Walshaw of Kent Police’s Rural Task Force said: “We work closely with the RSPCA on a range of animal welfare issues. In this instance we carried out a warrant on behalf of the charity to allow them to gather evidence which led to a successful conviction for offences under the Animal Welfare Act. The offender’s actions were not only criminal but barbaric and cruel. “

Sentencing: 12 weeks’ custody, suspended for two years, and a community order with 200 hours of unpaid work; £485 in costs and charges. Disqualified from keeping all animals for life.

ITV News


A Naturewatch Foundation press release uploaded to pressat.co.uk on 21/12/2021 (but since deleted) highlighted the fact that Eastwood exposes his primary-school-age brother to illegal hunting activities including lamping foxes, hare coursing and digging out badgers.

Eastwood shared incriminating images and video footage on social media, including photographs of:

  • his young sibling proudly displaying a dead rabbit
  • both brothers at a dug-out badger sett with two dogs and a shovel
  • the pair smiling as they posed in a field with three dogs and a dead hare
  • two dogs playing ‘tug-of-war’ with a fox
  • a lurcher-type dog with a bloodied hare

Naturewatch Foundation’s wildlife crime campaign manager, Kate Parker, said: “It has been seen that, in some families, animal cruelty is somewhat of a family affair, with youngsters exposed to it and encouraged to take part in activities, such as illegal hunting, before they are old enough to understand the consequences. These practices are normalised, and passed on as a generational tradition, regardless of how barbaric and cruel it is. There is clearly a blatant disregard for the welfare of wildlife, their own animals and, ultimately, the children, being exposed to such cruelty.

“This investigation was a great result for all involved. I thank Kent Police for actioning our investigation package and the RSPCA for taking on the prosecution. We will continue to target those who choose to hunt wildlife with dogs and will not rest until the punishment suits the crime.”
One of Naturewatch Foundation’s other campaigns involves training police internationally on the link between human and animal abuse, and how witnessing cruelty to animals can affect young children.

Mark Randell, campaign manager for the charity’s police training programme, said: “There is a growing recognition of the impact that witnessing violence to animals has on a child’s development, and subsequent propensity to become involved in violent crime themselves.

“In Ukraine, where we train the police and others about the importance of animal abuse, the Criminal Code raises the maximum jail term to eight years when animal cruelty is committed in front of children. This sets an example to the rest of the world – including the UK. Treating animal abuse with the seriousness it deserves creates safer communities for both animals and people.”


Additional Information

Eastwood has multiple Facebook accounts:
https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100069140946143
https://www.facebook.com/bennyjoe.eastwood.52
https://www.facebook.com/bennyjoe.eastwood.5

Lynemouth, Northumberland: Douglas Oliphant and Michelle Wilkinson

CONVICTED (2021) | Douglas Oliphant, born c. 1964, and Michelle Wilkinson, born 14 December 1967, both of 107 Dalton Avenue, Lynemouth, Morpeth NE61 5TF – kept 23 ducks and chickens in tiny filthy cages.

Oliphant and Wilkinson kept the birds in plastic recycling crates covered with netting and rabbit hutches in their two-bedroom, mid-terraced house in Lynemouth.

Six cockerels were being forced to live in a single crate.

The pair also kept a dog and two cats in inadequately sized cages, which didn’t have a clean supply of fresh drinking water or suitable bedding.

All the animals were seized after an inspection by the RSPCA.

Oliphant and Wilkinson each pleaded guilty to three counts of failing to ensure animal welfare.

Alex Bousfield, prosecuting on behalf of the RSPCA, said the animals were seized on July 27, 2021.

“This is a case that involves quite a large number of animals, 26 in total, all housed in quite a small dwelling – a mid-terraced, two-bedroom house, which was entirely unsuitable for the occupation of these animals”, Mr Bousfield continued.

“It was so crowded and it was not suitable and not healthy for the defendants either.

“RSPCA inspectors intervened at an early stage so, thankfully, only one duck had any health issues and that was something to do with a leg and not related to its housing conditions.

“Six cockerels were being kept in a recycling tub with netting on the top and other birds were being kept in rabbit hutches.

“Clearly, they were being fed and watered as there were no problems with the animals’ weight.”

The court heard that the chickens and ducks were covered in their own faeces, as were the cages they were being kept in.

Mr Bousfield said Oliphant and Wilkinson had not been deliberately cruel but rather didn’t have the knowledge or capability to look after the animals.

Mr Harrison, defending, said the retired couple, who already owned the cats and dog, had bought the birds in a bid to make a “better and more simple” life for themselves.

He told the court that Oliphant was intending to keep them in his allotment but hadn’t got it ready in time.

“With a mixture of naivety and poor planning, the birds grew and their needs grew much quicker than anticipated,” Mr Harrison added.

The court heard that the pair, who had been living in “hoarding conditions”, had now cleaned out their home.

The couple were allowed to keep the two cats and the dog.

Sentencing | 12-month conditional discharge; £300 in costs. Banned from keeping fowl for 12 months (expired December 2022).

Chronicle Live

Basingstoke, Hampshire: Daniel Klusek

CONVICTED (2021) | Daniel Sebastian Klusek, born 22 November 1995, of Britten Road, Basingstoke RG22 4HP – failed to seek veterinary treatment for his elderly cancer-stricken dog.

Daniel Klusek left his elderly pet to suffer.

Klusek was convicted of causing unnecessary suffering to the Staffordshire Bull Terrier called Max in Basingstoke between December 29, 2019 and January 9, 2020.

He was found guilty of “failing to heed professional veterinary advice to adequately explore and address the cause of [his dog’s] poor bodily condition”.

Klusek’s partner, 19-year-old Emily Sawdon, was found not guilty by magistrates and had her case dismissed.

Sentencing: 100 hours of unpaid work; £1,400 in costs and a £95 victim surcharge. Disqualified from having custody of a dog or keeping a dog for five years.

Basingstoke Gazette (court roundup)

Spalding, Lincolnshire: James Adamson

CONVICTED (2021) | breeder and Kennel Club judge James Donald Adamson, born c. 1965, of 2 Birch Grove, Spalding PE11 2HL – kept ailing dogs in atrocious conditions.

Adamson, who trades under the name Peterwell German Shepherds, has been banned from keeping dogs for 10 years following a prosecution by the RSPCA.

He pleaded guilty to four offences:

  • causing unnecessary suffering to three German Shepherd type dogs by failing to provide adequate or effective professional veterinary care and attention for their chronic skin disorders;
  • causing unnecessary suffering to seven dogs by failing to provide adequate or effective professional veterinary care and attention for their conjunctivitis eye infections;
  • failing to provide seven dogs with a suitable living environment; and
  • failing to protect them from pain, suffering, injury or disease by failing to adequately maintain their coats in an appropriate condition.

RSPCA Inspector Andy Bostock attended Adamson’s home with police officers on July 15, 2021.

Inside a garage, he found four German Shepherd dogs held within two enclosures. Three of the dogs had matted coats and there was a strong smell of ammonia. None of the dogs had food or water.

A vet was contacted and shown footage of the conditions and confirmed the dogs were suffering. The dogs were then seized and taken into possession by the police.

Inside the property there were three further German Shepherd dogs in metal cages.

Inspector Bostock said: “The dogs were subdued and appeared to have skin conditions to varying degrees. There was an extremely strong smell of excrement and urine and the floor to the kitchen area was covered in excrement.

“The dogs appeared dirty and there was no food or water available for them inside the cages.”

The vet was again contacted and provided a vet certificate to say the dogs were suffering and they were also taken into possession by the police.

All the dogs continued to thrive in RSPCA care – and report by a vet who visited to keep tracks on their progress stated: “ If the owner of the dogs had followed the basic welfare guidelines and codes of practice and sought veterinary care, then the suffering to all the dogs could have been alleviated and avoided.”

Inspector Bostock added: “It was the vet’s professional opinion that the owner failed in their duty of care by not providing a reasonable and clean environment with adequate ventilation. The areas where the dogs were forced to live went from being unacceptable in the garage, to an environment which was not fit for human or animal habitation within the house itself in the kitchen area. Dogs are clean animals where they normally would defecate and urinate away from where they sleep.

“The vet also stated that whilst examining all dogs was fully aware of the stench of the coats on these animals which comes from living in a fetid environment which was totally unacceptable and inhumane. This was even more apparent from the poor, feted unkempt coats on three of the dogs where they were contaminated with pure filth.

“We had tried to work with the owner in the past and our advice and offers of help had not been taken on board.”

The court heard in mitigation that Adamson had been suffering from a number of personal problems.

The dogs have all recovered and are doing well in RSPCA care and the court made a deprivation order for ownership to be transferred to the RSPCA – who will now look to find homes for them all.

Sentencing: fined £1,000 and £300 costs and ordered to pay a £100 victim surcharge. Disqualified from keeping dogs for 10 years.

Spalding Voice
Spalding Today


Additional information

In January 2020, two six-year-old Afghan hounds – a brother and sister named Ice and Peaches – were seized from Adamson by the RSPCA. A witness described the conditions in which the dogs were being kept:

Two beautiful hounds … shut away from the outside world, neglected, abused, starved to emaciation, matted with filth, covered in urine burn sores, terrified and all alone. The RSPCA finally stepped in and saved them from imminent certain death.

Ice and Peaches

Ice and Peaches recovered from their ordeal and were rehomed.
Adamson faced no charges in relation to these dogs but a petition was launched following the publicity, urging the Kennel Club to strip him of his judging duties..

Limavady, County Londonderry: Paul Hasson

#MostEvil | Paul Hasson, born 25 October 1971, of College Mews, Greystone Road, Limavady BT49 0UT and previously of Slievemore Park, Londonderry BT48 8NJ – abandoned a dog, leaving her to starve to death.

Evil: Paul Hasson, previously of Londonderry and more recently Limavady

Hasson was convicted of abandoning without reasonable cause, causing unnecessary suffering to, and failing to ensure the welfare of, the unnamed terrier-type dog.

Derry City and Strabane District Council brought the charges against Hasson under the Welfare of Animals Act (NI) 2011.

Saddest sight: the horrific scene which greeted council animal welfare officers.

In a statement, the council said: “Proceedings followed an investigation by council’s animal welfare officers, following a complaint received in June 2020 that a dead dog had been found in a property at Slievemore Park, Londonderry.

“Animal welfare officers entered the defendant’s property and found the remains of a small terrier-type dog which appeared to have been pushed up against the wall with a brush on top of it.

“There was a pungent smell of urine and faeces in the property which was in a bad state of hygiene.

“The dog was very thin and had begun to decompose.

“The dog was seized by animal welfare officers on recommendation of the council-instructed vet.

Despite leaving his pet dog to endure an agonising death, Hasson was only given a 5-year ban on owning animals along with a financial penalty of a few hundred pounds.

“Mr Hasson admitted all offences. District judge King disqualified Mr Hasson from owning, keeping or participating in the keeping of animals and from being party to an arrangement under which that person is entitled to control or influence the way in which animals are kept for a period of five years.

“Mr Hasson was fined £500 and ordered to pay legal costs totalling £138.”

Sentencing: fine, costs and a five-year ban (expires December 2026).

Newsletter
Derry Daily

Thamesmead, South-East London: David Phillips

CONVICTED (2021) | David Christopher Phillips, born 10 May 1970, of 7 Eastgate Close, London SE28 8PJ – let his pet dog starve to death

Amber died from chronic starvation after her callous owner failed to feed her.
Amber died from chronic starvation after her callous owner failed to feed her.

Nine-year-old Staffy Amber was so badly neglected, an RSPCA inspector couldn’t even tell her breed or original colour. The charity investigated after the dog’s emaciated body was left at a Thamesmead veterinary hospital “for disposal”.

Following a post-mortem, it was found that the dog was only 8kg, almost half the weight of 14kg she had been when last brought into the clinic in 2019.

The post-mortem concluded that Amber had died of chronic starvation, and at the time of her death was suffering from a chronic, widespread, skin disease resulting from a mite infestation.

Amber’s owner David Phillips pleaded guilty to two two charges under the Animal Welfare Act 2006, namely causing the unnecessary suffering of the animal by failing to address its weight loss and failing to provide the necessary veterinary care for the animal’s chronic skin disease.

According to an investigating veterinary surgeon who provided testimony for the court, Amber’s case was one of the worst she’d ever seen in his career.

RSPCA Inspector Harriet Daliday who investigated the case told the court: ”Amber’s body was extremely thin, all her ribs were clearly visible, as were the bones in her head, shoulders, spine and hips.

“Most of Amber’s fur was missing, especially on her legs and underside, her claws were overgrown and there was dried faecal matter over her rear end.

“I was not able to determine the original colour or even what breed Amber was due to her poor body and skin condition.”

Inspector Dalliday added: “It’s very upsetting to imagine the suffering Amber endured at the end of her life, she was so thin and in such a poor state.”

Sentencing: jailed for 12 weeks; ordered to pay £690 in costs and a £128 victim surcharge. Disqualified from keeping animals for life.

My London