Category Archives: badger baiting

Worksop, Nottinghamshire: Thomas Marvell and Mell Gibson

CONVICTED (2012) | badger baiters Thomas Marvell, born c. 1987, of 41 Vicars Walk, Worksop S80 2HJ and Mell Gibson, born c. 1991, of 48 Shrewsbury Road, Worksop S80 2TU

Badger baiters Thomas Marvell and Mel Gibson from Worksop, Nottinghamshire
Thomas Marvell (left) and Mell Gibson

Career criminals Thomas Marvell and Mell Gibson were prosecuted by the RSPCA following the charity’s ongoing investigation into crimes against badgers.

Warrants were carried out in March 2012 at addresses linked to Marvell. A brown terrier called Milo and various pieces of suspected hunting paraphernalia were seized from his home.

Three dogs were discovered at Mell Gibson’s home, including one called Smudge who had an untreated septic hole in the side of his face.

The pair were prosecuted by the RSPCA following the its ongoing investigations into crimes against badgers.

Chief superintendent Barry Fryer, from the RSPCA’s special operations unit, said: “Our investigations into organised animal crime and deliberate animal cruelty are always ongoing. Every day our inspectors are following up more leads.”

“Both Marvell and Gibson are prime examples of what fate is likely to fall on those who think they can get away with turning a blind eye to the law and inflicting terrible suffering on both wildlife and domestic animals.”

“Our officers are constantly digging further into the cruel and murky world of animal crime. Anyone who thinks they are getting away with it might soon find themselves getting a knock on the door from the RSPCA.”

Inspector Steve Cartwright said these prosecutions should send out a message that animal cruelty will not be tolerated.

“We are very lucky in Worksop to live in a rural district boasting some beautiful natural attractions. These locations are home to an array of flora and fauna and they should be treated with respect and consideration,” he said.

“While wildlife and pets may not be able to speak of the pain they suffer at the hands of people, stringent mechanisms are in place to try to protect them. We work very closely with our partner agencies, such as the RSPCA, to bring individuals like Thomas Marvell and Mel Gibson to justice, and in turn send out a clear message that such cruel behaviour will not be tolerated.”

Sentencing:
Marvell – 10 weeks in custody for killing a badger, and six weeks for possession, to run consecutively. He was also banned from keeping dogs for 10 years (expired September 2022).

Gibson – 12-month conditional discharge; £150 costs. Banned from keeping dogs for five years (expired 2017).

Worksop Guardian


Additional Information and Updates


In April 2015 Thomas Marvell was jailed for 16 years for armed robbery.

In October 2012 Mell Gibson, whose other convictions include motoring offences, was sentenced to 42 months in prison after being caught in possession of a large quantity crack cocaine.

Royston, Hertfordshire: Billy and Ricky Crotty and associates.

PROSECUTED | William Crotty, born November 1981, and Ricky Crotty, born March 1990, both of Royston – charged with killing a badger alongside Scott Brown of Boldon Colliery, Tyne and Wear, Kevin Barry Cowell and Gabrielle Freeney, both of Enfield, London and David Fox of Ongar, Essex.

L-R Billy Crotty, Ricky Crotty, Scott Brown (top) and Kevin Cowell

The men denied three charges each in total – interfering with badger setts, digging for badgers and wilfully killing a badger – and were cleared by a jury.

They were charged after they were caught with spades and a lurcher-type dog in a field near Bassingbourn, Cambridgeshire on November 6, 2011.

“Innocent” Scott Brown from Boldon Colliery. Image: Facebook

The court had viewed a video filmed from the police helicopter, showing five men with spades and a lurcher-type dog standing around a hole in a field which Pc Timothy Gawler said “had the appearance of a grave shape”.

Pc Gawler, who spotted the group from the helicopter at 1.55pm, said the men then started to fill the hole in.

Three of the men left the scene in a red truck with a sixth man, the driver, while another two left the scene on foot, and all were later arrested.

Despite the evidence, the men were found not guilty.

Speaking after the verdict, boxing promoter Billy and tree surgeon Ricky, who are members of the travelling fraternity, complained that their businesses and families’ lives had been affected by the case.

“We’ve even had the animal rights people on our backs”, he said bitterly.

Billy denied that the group were badger baiting “as we are aware that it is illegal”. Instead, he said that they were pursuing foxes and had been given permission by a local farmer to be on the land.

He added that he and his brother “do voluntary pest control for a number of farmers”.

North West Hunt Saboteurs


News and Updates

In June 2018 Ricky Crotty was jailed for 11 years after being caught trafficking Class A drugs.

Swadlincote, Derbyshire: Richard Atkins

CONVICTED (2012) | Richard Alan Atkins, born 12 June 1967, of 178 Oversetts Road, Newhall, Swadlincote DE11 0SW – bred dogs to hunt and kill foxes and badgers

Richard Atkins was jailed after he bred dogs to hunt down and kill foxes and badgers so he could film it for a sick thrill.

Atkins was sentenced to 24 weeks behind bars after a photo showed him smiling with glee as he held a still live fox by the throat.

The father admitted nine charges including causing animals to fight, keeping dogs for the purpose of animal fighting, causing unnecessary suffering and animal welfare offences. when he appeared at Burton upon Trent magistrates on 29 June 2012

The badly  mutilated face of Patterdale terrier Pudding. The little dog, who was also blind in one eye, was successfully rehabilitated and rehomed but passed away some time later. Phone on the right shows bloodsports fanatic Richard Atkins holding a still live fox by the throat.
The badly mutilated face of Patterdale terrier Pudding. The little dog, who was also blind in one eye, was successfully rehabilitated and rehomed but passed away some time later. Phone on the right shows bloodsports fanatic Richard Atkins holding a still live fox by the throat.

Atkins also received a lifetime ban on keeping all animals and the forfeiture of all his dogs and equipment used for baiting and hunting.

Atkins trained his terriers to hunt down and attack wild animals. He then filmed the sickening attacks on a digital video camera which he showed to his equally twisted associates.

Bloodsports fanatic, fox hunter, badger baiter Richard Atkins from Swadlincote, Derbyshire
Richard Atkins inflicted malicious and sadistic acts of cruelty on wild animals, which also caused immense suffering to his dogs.

The RSPCA were able to successfully bring the prosecution to court when forensic examination of badger baiting footage seized from a digital video camera proved a voice heard in the background was that of Atkins.

The court saw graphic footage of Atkins’s black Patterdale terrier, later named as Pudding (pictured above) and bull lurcher-type dogs carrying out attacks on two badgers and a fox in separate incidents.

In another clip a badger is seen having its leg torn off, while men – including Atkins – can be heard laughing in the background.

Bloodsports fanatic, fox hunter, badger baiter Richard Atkins from Swadlincote, Derbyshire

As well as the harrowing clips which showed the wild animals being attacked, the dogs used by Atkins also suffered sickening injuries during the fights.

The defendant admitted that he would attempt to treat his dogs’ injuries at home, rather than take them to a vet and raise suspicion.

Both the Patterdale terrier and bull lurcher seen in the footage were found at Atkins’ home when a warrant was carried out by police and the RSPCA.

The Patterdale terrier had suffered huge injuries to her jaw and she was partially blind in one eye. Four other dogs – also believed to have been bred for fighting and hunting – were seized during the warrant, along with paraphernalia, digging equipment and search lights.

Bloodsports fanatic, fox hunter, badger baiter Richard Atkins from Swadlincote, Derbyshire

Atkins had a similar conviction from 1999 when he was found guilty of digging for a badger in 1999 alongside Lee Robert Burton of Tower Road, Hartshorne.

Three dogs were found on the site and they all had scratches on their faces. A dead badger was found at the scene and the body was still warm. When they were taken back to their house there was a concrete badger on the front garden which all three dogs immediately attacked.

Both men were sentenced to two months in prison.

Magistrates ordered all equipment recovered by police to be destroyed and disqualified both men from owning a dog for three years.

The three dogs were found new homes.

Sentencing (2012): jailed for 24 weeks and banned from keeping all animals for life.

North West Hunt Saboteurs Vermin Patrol
Daily Mail


Update August 2021

In August 2021 Atkins was jailed for 22 months after ramming a car and stabbing two brothers following a bitter family feud. The crazed attack on the men – Atkins brothers-in-law – was witnessed by the 12-year-old son of one of the victims, as well as members of the public.

The court heard how Atkins rammed the men’s vehicle from behind as they drove home.

He then mounted a pavement, got in front of them to block them in, got out and stabbed both men as they tried to defend themselves.

He then told one of them “I told you, you were going to have it” before going on to say he “didn’t care” if he ended up in prison.

Jailing him for 22 months, Judge Jonathan Bennett said: “It was a horrific incident that could have led to more serious injuries.

“The red mist descended.

As well as the prison sentence, Judge Bennett handed Atkins a seven-year restraining order not to contact the victims and a third named individual.

Derby Telegraph

Carlisle/Shap, Cumbria: Ryan Lowe and Brian Sanderson

CONVICTED (2012) | Ryan Lowe, born c. 1982, of 5 Baird Road, Carlisle CA1 3AE, and Brian Sanderson, born c. 1972, of 1 West Lane, Shap, Penrith CA10 3LT – hunted foxes and badgers with dogs

Ryan Lowe from Carlisle who went hunting for foxes and badgers with dogs

The court heard that Ryan Lowe and accomplice Brian Sanderson had crossed the Scottish border on a hunting expedition for foxes and badgers. With them were four lurcher-type dogs and terrier wearing a locator collar. They were apprehended in the area of Westerkirk, near Langholm.

The men pleaded not guilty to possessing items contrary to the Protection of Badgers Act – including spades, walkie-talkies and a quantity of electronic equipment – but were found guilty after a three-day trial.

They were found not guilty of approaching a badger sett with the dogs, disturbing entrances and causing a dog to enter the sett.

Sentencing: Lowe – community payback order of 180 hours of unpaid. Sanderson was ordered to pay £1,000. Neither man was banned from keeping dogs.

ITV News
North West Hunt Sabs

Keighley, West Yorkshire: Anton Lee

CONVICTED (2012) Anthony Alastair Lee, born 24 March 1989, formerly of Coronation Way, Keighley and from 2019 of 26 Ethel Street, Keighley BD20 6AN – urged his dog to attack and kill badgers and kept footage of the fights on his phone

Badger baiter Anthony 'Antwon' Lee from Keighley, City of Bradford, is banned from keeping animals for life
A magistrate wiped away tears while watching three videos of animal fights that Anthony Lee recorded.

Lee, who goes by the nickname ‘Antwon, admitted taking part in an animal fight on May 5, 2010, and causing his dog to fight a badger on June 30 and December 30, 2010.

Bradford and Keighley Magistrates were so horrified by snippets of video found on Lee’s phone that they jailed him for 23 weeks and imposed a lifetime ban on keeping animals on him.

The RSPCA said the case was “as bad as one can get” and described Lee’s actions as “twisted and sick”.

In the first video played to the court, a badger could be heard squealing alongside the sound of laughter from Lee and another person.

The second video showed a badger being killed after being shaken around in Lee’s dog’s mouth while another dog had hold of it.

The third video showed a dog fighting a badger in its sett.

Badgers suffer an “extreme amount of pain” as a result of badger baiting and the dogs involved also suffer injuries, prosecutor Nigel Monaghan told the court.

He added: “In terms of animal cruelty the RSPCA regard this case as bad in terms of suffering and cruelty as one can get.”

Chairman of the bench Robert Thornton said: “This is the most serious case we can think of.”

Badger baiters draw no financial benefit from their actions, RSPCA investigator Carroll Lamport said after the hearing.

He said: “It is just for their own twisted and sick kicks and there is a really high level of cruelty.”

Sentencing: 23 weeks in jail (three-week discount on the maximum sentence because he pleaded guilty. Banned from keeping or looking after animals for the rest of his life with no right of appeal for 50 years. Lee appealed the latter and will now be allowed to ask for the lifetime ban to be reviewed after just 10 years, i.e. 2022.

BBC News


News and Updates

March 2013: Lee was jailed for 18 months for attacking an RAF serviceman, fracturing his jaw.

Lee approached Reece Barnes with a large iron bar and struck him in the face with his fist while on bail for badger baiting.

He pleaded guilty to unlawfully wounding Mr Barnes who needed surgery to reconstruct a double fracture of his jaw. The court heard that Lee had previous convictions for assault, attempted robbery and battery.

July 2020: Lee is now presenting himself as a wildlife photographer of all things under the name Yorkshire Image Photography.

Carcroft, Doncaster: Richard, Lee and Nathan Whinfrey

PROSECUTED (2012) | alleged badger baiters Richard Whinfrey, born 10/10/1968 and son Nathan Whinfrey, born 04/12/1986, both of 35 Milton Road, Doncaster DN6 8QL, plus Lee Mark Whinfrey, born 04/03/1984, of 61 New Street, Doncaster DN6 8EJ

Alleged badger baiters Nathan, Lee and Richard Whinfrey
L-R Nathan, Lee and Richard Whinfrey. All three men were charged with badger baiting.

The three men appeared before Selby magistrates on 16 April 2012 charged with digging for badgers.

All were charged with interfering with badger setts, hunting a wild mammal with dogs and digging for badgers.

Richard Whinfrey is also charged with causing unnecessary suffering to a dog named Jake, and failing to ensure his welfare of the dog.

The defendants were admitted to conditional bail – not to enter North Yorkshire unless attending court – until a three-day trial at Selby from 29 August 2012 (no updates available).

Source: North West Hunt Sabs

Uddingston, South Lanarkshire: Andrew Mullen

CONVICTED (2012) | leader of a badger baiting ring Andrew Lennox Mullen, born 09/11/1974, formerly of Hickory Crescent, Uddingston, and more recently McCracken Drive, Uddingston G71 5ND

Andrew Mullen from Uddingston admitted keeping dogs for animal fighting and was banned from owning animals for life.
Andrew Mullen admitted keeping dogs for animal fighting and was banned from owning animals for life.

Mullen was found to have a haul of photographs showing images of dogs fighting badgers, foxes and deer when his home was raided by police and animal welfare officers following an undercover Scottish SPCA investigation.

The officers taking part in the raid also discovered five seriously injured dogs in the garden of his home in Uddingston in Lanarkshire.

Mullen, who pleaded guilty to animal cruelty charges, was the first person in Scotland to be convicted of keeping dogs for baiting wild animals since the Animal Health and Welfare (Scotland) Act 2006 came into effect.

Andrew Mullen from Uddingston admitted keeping dogs for animal fighting and was banned from owning animals for life.

The court was told that Mullen, who is unemployed, had organised illegal dog fights against foxes, badgers and deer and kept five dogs for the purposes of animal fighting.

His home in Uddingston was raided in March 2010 and officers discovered a laptop with 340 photographs showing Mullen and his associates goading dogs into fighting and attacking other animals. Mullen was also pictured holding up dead foxes or laying them on the ground, apparently as trophies.

Five dogs, three lurchers, a brown terrier-type puppy and a terrier bitch were found with “terrible” injuries in kennels in Mullen’s back garden. A veterinary examination revealed that three of Mullen’s five dogs had injuries consistent with badger baiting.

Andrew Mullen from Uddingston admitted keeping dogs for animal fighting and was banned from owning animals for life.

Mullen had denied actively using his dogs to fight badgers, but accepted that he allowed others to use them and that he knew the dogs he kept were to be used on badgers.

He admitted breaching the 2006 Animal Health and Welfare Act by keeping five dogs for the purposes of animal fighting between 1 January 2009 and 31 March 2010.

Scottish SPCA chief superintendent Mike Flynn welcomed the lifetime ban imposed by Sheriff Stewart.

“We are delighted that Andrew Mullen has been convicted of keeping dogs for the purpose of fighting following our investigation and that a life ban on keeping animals has been imposed,” he said.

“It is very encouraging to see that Scotland’s animal welfare legislation is being used successfully for the protection of both domestic and wild animals. This result sends out an important message that keeping dogs for the purposes of animal fighting is illegal and will not be tolerated.”

He added: “Badger baiting is a heinous crime against badgers. We will continue to actively target badger baiters and we urge anyone with information on those involved in this horrific blood sport to call us, even anonymously, to raise any concerns they might have.”

Sentencing: six-month curfew; 200 hours of community service. Banned from owning animals for life.

BBC News

North Yorkshire Badger Baiters: Alan Alexander, Richard Simpson, Paul Tindall, William Anderson, Christopher Holmes and Malcolm Warner

CONVICTED (2012) | badger baiting ring Alan ‘Bok’ Alexander, born 03/04/1979, of Bramham Grove, York YO26 5BH, Richard Lee Simpson, born 24/11/1974, of Bramham Grove, York YO26 5BH, Paul Ian Tindall, born 30/03/1978, of Boroughbridge Road, York YO26 6AL, William Edward Anderson, born 29/05/1985, formerly of Hillside Farm in Pickering but as of April 2020 residing at the Jam House, Alne Hills, Great Alne, Alcester, Stratford on Avon B49 6JT, Christopher ‘Tiffa’ Martin Holmes, born 04/03/1983, of Byland Avenue, York YO31 9AY and Malcolm David Warner, born 21/02/1983, of Tedder Road, York YO24 3JD

Badger baiters Richard Simpson, Alan Alexander, Paul Tindall, William Anderson

Scarborough Magistrates’ Court heard how the group of six men and a 17-year-old boy dug out two badgers and laughed as they set a pack of 13 dogs on them. The horrific incident took place on farmland at Howsham, near York, in January 2011.

An RSPCA inspector involved in the case said it was the worst incident of badger baiting he had ever seen.

Sobia Ahmed, prosecuting, told the court that two witnesses, including wildlife photographer Robert Fuller, heard the sound of dogs barking excitedly and a badger squealing in distress and went to investigate.
When they reached the scene, they saw two large dogs attacking a badger.

Ms Ahmed said: ‘They had hold of it in their mouths and were shaking it violently. They said the dogs were playing tug of war with the badger.’

Mr Fuller recalled in court how the men ‘laughingly’ encouraged the beasts before they spotted him and fled the scene.

Wildlife photographer Robert Fuller managed to take this picture showing Alan Alexander snatching at a badger in the dog's mouth
Wildlife photographer Robert Fuller managed to take this picture showing Alan Alexander snatching at a badger in the dog’s mouth

After some time, the badger was shot dead by Anderson and the men, who had become aware of the witnesses and tried to cover their tracks by throwing the dead badger into the undergrowth.

They then buried a second dead badger – a pregnant animal which had been torn to pieces by the dogs – back into the hole from which it had been dug.

Ms Ahmed said witnesses called the police and the men and teenager were arrested a short time later.

Police and RSPCA inspectors who visited the scene found animal intestines and badger foetuses scattered around and areas of congealed blood, believed to be from where the badger had been shot.

When they recovered the two badgers, one was found to have been shot at close range and had a fractured skull and jaw.

Badger baiters Christopher Holmes and Malcolm Warner
Badger baiting ring members Christopher Holmes (left) and Malcolm ‘Mally’ Warner were given suspended prison sentences

The other had part of its abdomen missing and injuries consistent with being attacked by a dog.

Mr Fuller later gave his pictures to the police and RSPCA and they were used to convict the gang.

When they investigated, the authorities established the men had killed three adult badgers and three unborn cubs.

Ms Ahmed said the pregnant badger suffered ‘a sustained attack by a number of dogs that had caused the badger to be torn to pieces and eventually it bled to death’ while the other had a ‘gunshot wound to the head immediately after a severe and sustained attack by a number of dogs’.

Ms Ahmed described the operation as a ‘sophisticated enterprise’ in which the men used equipment to track down the badgers.

Speaking after the sentencing, RSPCA Inspector Geoff Edmond said: “I was there on the day and was responsible for removing a pregnant badger which had been buried in a hole, which had been ripped to bits by dogs.

“That’s horrific, barbaric, and these badgers had been tortured by these dogs on that day.”

Alexander, Simpson, Tindall and Anderson were jailed for 16 weeks after being found guilty of wilfully killing a badger, hunting a mammal with dogs, digging for badgers and interfering with a badger sett.

Alexander and Simpson were also convicted of causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal.

All four men were each ordered to pay £750 costs and £100 compensation.

Badger baiter Alan Alexander pictured outside court
Alan Alexander

Holmes and Warner were handed 12-week custodial sentences suspended for 12 months after they pleaded guilty to wilfully killing a badger, digging for badgers and interfering with a badger sett. They were told to pay £250 costs and £100 compensation

The 17-year-old boy, who could not be named for legal reasons, was given a youth rehabilitation order.

An eighth person, James Doyle from Westfield Avenue, Knottingley, was acquitted.

The men were represented by Clive Rees.

BBC News
Daily Mail
NWHSA

Burnley, Lancashire: Jeff Johnson

CONVICTED (2011) | Jeffrey Johnson aka JJ Johnson, born c. 1977, of 37 Forfar Street, Burnley BB11 4ER – convicted of hunting badgers with dogs.

Jeff ‘JJ’ Johnson with Leanne ‘LB’ Buck/Johnson

Johnson told the court that he had been digging close to a badger sett in Altham because his terrier had got trapped after chasing a rabbit down a hole. He denied having any interest in badgers but was convicted after a trial.

Johnson, a part-time window cleaner and father of three, was seen stood in a three foot deep hole with a spade in his hand by a badger enthusiast.

The enthusiast challenged Johnson and another man as to what they were doing and Johnson said something about digging for a fox.

He said they then ran off before the police arrived.

Johnson told the court he was walking his dogs, the terrier and a lurcher, in the area and they had been chasing rabbits. He said the dogs ran off and he found the lurcher near the entrance to what he now knew to be the badger sett.

Johnson could hear his dog crying underground and when she did not respond to his calls decided to go home for a spade so he could try and dig her out. He said he blocked the entrance to the sett so the dog would not get out and run away in his absence.

Johnson said he came back with a friend and while he was digging the dog emerged from the sett and his friend caught her.

Magistrates did not believe his version of events, however. Finding him guilty they fined him £270 and ordered him to pay £265 in costs.

Wildlife Guardian

Scarisbrick, West Lancashire: Craig Edwards

CONVICTED (2011) | Craig Alan Edwards, born June 1984, of 69 Jacksmere Lane, Scarisbrick, Ormskirk L40 9RT – left his dog with a large infected open wound believed to have been caused by a badger.

Edwards, who previously ran a pub in Buxton, High Peak, Derbyshire, was found guilty after a trial of six animal cruelty charges in relation to the unnamed dog.

Magistrates heard the dog had been kept in the upstairs accommodation which was bare, had mould, rubbish, an uncarpeted floor and dog mess everywhere.

Vets found two large substantial wounds to the lower jaw were infected and covered in a substantial amount of pus discharge. Surgery was not an option as the wound was too extensive and too infected.

Expert opinion was that the wound had been sustained in a fight with a badger.

Sentencing | jailed for 12 weeks. Banned from keeping animals for 10 years with the right of appeal after five (ban expired 2021).

NWHSA


Updates

As of May 2022 Edwards still lives at the property in Jacksmere Lane. In 2021 he registered a construction company named ‘Craigs Properties Ltd‘.