Weymouth, Dorset: Shona Hale

CONVICTED (2023) | Shona Louise Hale, born c.1991, of 161 Littlemoor Road, Weymouth DT3 6AF – for the severe neglect of two malnourished dogs found in poor living conditions and with untreated ailments.

Convicted animal abuser Shona Hale from Weymouth, Dorset. Picture Facebook

Hale, a self-employed doula trading under the name Amba Bump & Beyond, was found guilty of animal cruelty in relation to two wire-haired lurcher-type dogs named Branna and Sky

Branna and another dog, Sky, were neglected by Shona Hale from Weymouth, Dorset

Branna was in particularly poor health with a chronic skin disease, which had caused major fur loss and scabby skin all over her body, plus visible scabs on her back, tail and legs. Live fleas could be seen crawling on both dogs, who were living in poor conditions.

On June 25, 2022, RSPCA rescuers were called to the address Hale shares with husband Callum Hale and their two children after concerns were raised about the welfare of the dogs.

Branna and Sky were neglected by Shona Hale from Weymouth, Dorset

RSPCA inspector Patrick Bailey said: “Sky was of thin body condition, with her spine and hips bones prominent. She had thinning fur on her lower back and the base of her tail and her skin was pink and inflamed.

“Branna was worse in condition. She had fur loss on her lower back, her hind legs and her tail as well as her stomach, chest, underneath her neck and thinning fur on her front legs. She had scabby skin all over, there were visible scabs on her back, tail and legs, particularly her back legs.

“You could also feel scabs on the skin of her head, neck and behind her ears, although they were concealed by slightly thicker fur in these areas.

“The fur that was present on her back legs was matted into knots. Live fleas could be seen crawling on both dogs. Both dogs were trying to rest on the sofa but constantly interrupted by itching which caused them to scratch, lick and nibble themselves.”

Branna and Sky were neglected by Shona Hale from Weymouth, Dorset

Mr Bailey persuaded Callum Hale to allow him to take the dogs to a vet for a welfare check. The veterinary examination found Branna was suffering unnecessarily due to a chronic skin infection, malesia and flea infestation and vets confirmed neither dog had had their needs met fully.

The dogs were taken into the care of an RSPCA rescue centre where there was a significant improvement in their condition after just two weeks of treatment.

The skin on both dogs was a normal colour and was no longer greasy or smelly. There were no fleas and a significant reduction in the amount of scabs on Branna, who also had some new hair growth on her lower back.

Sky in healthier times. Source: Shona Hale, Facebook
Sky in healthier times. Source: Shona Hale, Facebook

The kennel staff also reported that the dogs had stopped scratching within 24 hours of their first bath on arriving at the RSPCA centre and their character had improved along with their physical condition.

Hale, who also keeps horses, was convicted of causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal (Branna) by failing to provide adequate or effective professional veterinary care and attention for her severe and chronic skin disease. She was also convicted of failing to ensure the needs of animals she was responsible for were met.

Speaking after the case, RSPCA inspector Charlotte Le Brun, who investigated for the animal welfare charity, said: “Our plea to all animal owners is to make sure they always receive care and treatment from veterinary experts when they need it.

“Hale had been previously offered assistance from the RSPCA, including help with vet care for the dogs, but she did not take her dogs to the vet.

“Pets are completely reliant on their owners to ensure their needs are met and they are kept safe and healthy. Owning an animal is a privilege – and ensuring appropriate veterinary care is a key part of the responsibility we have towards our pets. It’s so sad that, in this instance, that responsibility was not met.”

Sentencing | two-year conditional discharge; £26 victim surcharge. Five-year ban applicable to dogs only (expires October 2028).

DorsetLive
Dorset Echo

Burnley, Lancashire: Brandon Lawlor

CONVICTED (2023) | wildlife persecutor Brandon Lawlor, born 29 December 1999, of Lowerhouse Lane, Rose Grove, Burnley BB12 6HZ – goaded two dogs into fighting with a badger.

Badger baiter Brandon Lawlor from Burnley, Lancashire

Irish traveller Lawlor, a former jockey and employee of Sue Smith Racing, was prosecuted alongside accomplice Carl Harwood (sentenced in February 2021) after footage on his mobile phone showed him illegally fighting two dogs with a badger in Lancashire.

One of the dogs had 22 individual scarred puncture wounds on the side of his head from the incident.

Toby suffered a litany of injuries consistent with badger baiting
Toby suffered a litany of injuries consistent with badger baiting

The “absolutely horrific” film, which was recorded in Burnley in June 2021, was described by an RSPCA inspector as “very difficult to watch and to listen to”.

Lawlor pleaded guilty to one offence contrary to the Protection of Badgers Act 1991 when he appeared at Blackpool Magistrates’ Court on September 21, 2023, in a prosecution brought by the RSPCA.

There had been a warrant out for his arrest.

Magistrates were told police found the disturbing footage on his mobile phone on August 13, 2021, after he was being investigated for non-related offences.

Two dogs, including a 14-month-old bull lurcher called Toby, were seen attacking the badger on the head, throat and back, with a male voice encouraging them on.

RSPCA inspector Lyndsey Taylor, along with the charity’s Special Operations Unit (SOU) and Lancashire Police’s Ribble Valley rural task force, visited the defendant’s house on October 19, 2021.

The court heard how they went into the living room and saw Toby being held on a lead.

The dog, who was wearing the same type of collar as that seen in the mobile phone footage, had a significant scar which ran lengthwise along almost the entire length of the top of his head.

On the left-hand side of the lower jaw and surrounding area there were 22 individual scarred puncture wounds, and on the right-hand side there were nine.

Badger baiter Carl Harwood from Burnley, Lancashire
Harwood was convicted in relation to the same incident and sentenced in February 2023

More recent scarring and scabbing was seen underneath the dog’s left hind paw and lower leg.

Carl Harwood, who was at the property with Lawlor, told the officers the injuries had been sustained while out lamping and ratting.

Inspector Taylor was concerned about Toby’s welfare and he was seized by police and taken by the RSPCA to be seen by a vet.

In her evidence to the court, inspector Taylor described the mobile phone footage.

She said: “It was filmed in the dark but two dogs can be seen attacking a badger as initially, when the recording begins, a bright light can be seen being shone on the animals.

“The footage is very difficult to watch and to listen to, it is absolutely horrific.

“All the way through the footage the badger can be heard screaming in pain and it is extremely distressed, with the dogs heard panting also.

“At around eight seconds, when Toby has lost interest and has left the badger, a male voice can be heard to say something like ‘here Toby, Toby get it, get it.’

“The dog can then be seen joining the first dog in attacking the badger again.

Badger baiter Brandon Lawlor from Burnley, Lancashire

“The men heard to be present during the recording made no attempt or effort to get the dogs under control and prevent them from fighting and attacking the badger.”

Her colleague, inspector Chris Haywood from the RSPCA’s special operations unit, which investigates wildlife crime, also gave evidence.

He said: “In my opinion, and based on previous experience, these wounds were caused by close combative contact with a badger.

“In 34 years of dealing with dogs I have never seen these types of injuries on any other breeds other than lurchers, bull lurchers and terriers, and known them to be caused by any other means than by a badger.”

In his evidence, the vet who examined Toby said the scars on his head, muzzle, throat and chest, represented skin injuries that had healed and had therefore occurred at least four weeks prior to his examination.

“In my opinion, Toby would have been caused to suffer in the absence of timely and appropriate veterinary care at the time of skin injury,” he said.

“With regards to the video footage, the person present at the time the two dogs were attacking the badger failed to take reasonable steps to intervene and bring the dog under close control in order to prevent him from continuing to fight with the badger, thereby failing to protect these animals from injury, pain and suffering.”

In mitigation, the court heard Lawlor had been a jockey who had come over from Ireland after his career had ended because of injury.

He said he accepted badger baiting was abhorrent and apologised for his actions.

Toby was cared for by the RSPCA. The whereabouts and owner of the other dog seen in the video are unknown.

Speaking after sentencing, inspector Taylor said: “This case has taken a long time to conclude but I’m pleased that both men who were involved in this case have been held to account for their actions.

“Illegal badger baiting causes significant pain, suffering, huge distress and even death to the animals involved, all for the enjoyment of people who take part in it and shockingly, find pleasure in such activities.

“We would urge anyone with information about incidents like this to report them to the RSPCA or their local rural crime team.”

Co-defendant Carl Harwood, of 16 Cobden Street, Padiham, Burnley BB12 8DS, was given a 16-week prison sentence, suspended for 12 months, and disqualified from keeping animals for five years in February 2023.

Sentencing | jailed for eight weeks.

Lancashire Telegraph
Manchester Evening News

Kingston upon Thames, South-West London: Garineh Azarian

CONVICTED (2023) | Garineh Azarian, aka Karina Azarian, born c. 1970, of Ridge House, Morecoombe Close, Kingston upon Thames KG2 7JQ – starved a puppy to death.

Garineh Azarian from Kingston upon Thames, London, allowed Havanese Coco to slowly starve to death
Garineh Azarian from Kingston upon Thames, London, allowed Havanese Coco to slowly starve to death

Azarian was convicted of causing unnecessary suffering to her one-year-old Havanese Coco – who an RSPCA inspector said was “the thinnest dog” she’d ever seen.

She initially pleaded not guilty to animal cruelty and did not accept that Coco had suffered – nor did she accept responsibility for his condition.
Wimbledon Magistrates Court heard that Azarian was of previous good character and was a “vulnerable” person. However, she was found guilty of the offence.

Garineh Azarian from Kingston upon Thames, London, allowed Havanese Coco to slowly starve to death

Azarian took Coco to a vet in October 2022 when he became lethargic and started vomiting, but would not let the vets give him antibiotics when they were made aware of his painfully emaciated condition. The vet gave him a body condition score of just one out of nine.

RSPCA inspectors Francesca Tambini and Dale Grant went to the vet practice to try and get Coco seized by police. He died not long after they arrived.

“When we arrived, I thought that the dog looked dead already,” Ms Tambini said: “There was a blanket over him, so that his head was visible and it appeared to be on some sort of drip supplement.”

She said it was upsetting to see his condition. “When the blanket was pulled back, the ribs on the dog were visibly protruding and he was missing quite a lot of fur… The dog looked like a skeleton. A few minutes after we arrived, the dog passed away.

Coco in healthier times | source: Garineh Azarian, Facebook
Coco in healthier times | source: Garineh Azarian, Facebook

Staff tried to resuscitate Coco, but they were unsuccessful. Ms Tambini said one vet was “extremely upset and crying”.

One of the veterinary staff members that treated Coco said the dog “could not have had appropriate veterinary care in the past” given his extreme condition.

“Despite the investigation and intensive treatment that Coco had with us, I believe that he was suffering prior to arrival and it was far too late to be able to save him.”

When RSPCA inspectors interviewed Azarian she told them she followed a raw and plant-based diet for the dog. She claimed she had been feeding him a normal 3% of his presumed body weight of three kilos since March 2022.

Azarian believed Coco’s scratching had been due to overeating and acid in his diet, and that the hair and weight loss was a normal response to detoxing. She also stated she did not believe in vaccinations, antibiotics or worming.

Garineh Azarian from Kingston upon Thames, London, allowed Havanese Coco to slowly starve to death

Vet experts later said the dog’s post mortem examination showed chronic malnutrition led to his death.

“There was also evidence of a high lungworm burden, which is a preventable disease with the use of routine worming treatments,” they added.

“In my opinion, the dog’s needs were not being met as per the Defra code – the owner failed to recognise signs of malnutrition, weight loss, poor condition, and seek veterinary advice within a reasonable time frame,” the continued, “which allowed their condition to deteriorate, and ultimately caused suffering and death”.

Sentencing | 300 hours of community work; court costs. Banned indefinitely from keeping animals.

Kingston Nub News
My London

Wednesbury, West Midlands: Carl Price

CONVICTED (2023) | backyard breeder Carl Kevin Price, born c. 1974, of 69 Dorsett Road, Wednesbury WS10 0JF – kept 11 spaniels in squalid faeces-riddled home.

Scumbag breeder Carl Price of Wednesbury, West Midlands, kept dogs in cramped cages with no bedding. One puppy was found dead at the scene.
Scumbag breeder Carl Price kept dogs in cramped cages with no bedding. One puppy was found dead at the scene.

An RSPCA inspector found five adult spaniels and six spaniel-type puppies inside crates and covered in excrement in Price’s disgusting home.

In the corner of one crate was a dead puppy alongside four other puppies and adult dog. In two other crates were a spaniel and three more young puppies. All of the animals were matted with faeces and urine.

Scumbag breeder Carl Price of Wednesbury, West Midlands, kept dogs in cramped cages with no bedding. One puppy was found dead at the scene.

Describing the horrific scene that greeted her RSPCA inspector Vicky Taylor said: “there was a strong smell of faeces and urine as I walked through the front door. Inside the front room there was a small dog crate with a spaniel named Millie, with four young pups all covered in urine.

“There was faeces all over the crate which was wet with urine. There was no bedding and a dead pup in the corner of the crate. In the kitchen, which had faeces all over and was extremely dirty, there were two more crates on top of one another, which were also extremely dirty.

Scumbag breeder Carl Price of Wednesbury, West Midlands, kept dogs in cramped cages with no bedding. One puppy was found dead at the scene.
The dogs’ fur was matted with faeces and urine

“In the top crate there was another dog, a black and white spaniel named Misty, in the crate with three young pups. They were all dirty and wet with faeces with urine. I was informed she was not the mother to these pups, that all the pups belonged to the spaniel in the front room. In the conservatory area, there was also excrement all over the floor and up the walls.”

In court, Price admitted two animal welfare offences.

Sentencing | 12-month community order with 15 rehabilitation activity requirement days; £114 victim surcharge and £186 costs. Banned from keeping animals for just three years (expires October 2026).

BirminghamLive
Express & Star

Milton on Stour, North Dorset: Chris Feeley

CONVICTED (2023) | Christopher M Feeley, aka Christopher Campbell, born 13 May 1981 of Whistley Waters, Milton on Stour, Gillingham SP8 4PT – failed to take his mysteriously injured dog to the vet.

Animal abuser Chris Feeley aka Chris Campbell from Milton on Stour, Gillingham, Dorset

Feeley, who with wife Amy-Rose Feeley owns and operates self-catering holiday lodges in Milton on Stour, near Gillingham in Dorset, admitted causing unnecessary suffering to wire-haired Vizsla Goose by failing to provide veterinary treatment for an unexplained injury to a rear leg.

Goose is having to get used to life on three legs following months of neglect by Chris Feeley
Goose is having to get used to life on three legs following months of neglect by Chris Feeley

He left the eight-year-old dog to suffer for six months, leading to the leg having to be amputated.

Goose is having to get used to life on three legs following months of neglect by Chris Feeley

Despite having at least one other pet – another wire-haired Vizla, Feeley was not banned from owning animals but was ordered to relinquish Goose, who is now available for rehoming with the Cotswolds Dogs & Cats Home.

Sentencing | fined £326 and ordered to pay a victim surcharge of £130 and £1,521.60 costs.

SomersetLive
GloucestershireLive