Tag Archives: sentence – suspended custodial

Chartham Hatch, Kent: David Stanbury & Aylesham, Kent: Jack Stanbury

Animal abuser Jack Stanbury is shown on the left wearing a camouflage jacket outdoors beneath a cloudy sky, with another person’s arm resting on his shoulder. On the right, animal abuser David Stanbury appears in formal attire, wearing a white shirt and dark vest, standing outdoors with greenery blurred behind him.
Jack Stanbury and David Stanbury, the father‑and‑son wildlife persecutors whose phones revealed brutal hunts, trophy videos and the suffering of both wild animals and dogs.

This case concerns father and son David and Jack Stanbury, whose long‑running persecution of wildlife was exposed after David was arrested at a wild boar hunt in the Forest of Dean on New Year’s Eve 2024.

Animal abuser Jack Stanbury is shown outdoors at night wearing camouflage clothing, holding the head of a large deer lying on the ground with visible blood at the neck. Artificial light illuminates the scene against a dark background.

When police seized his phone, they uncovered a vast archive of trophy videos, messages and images documenting the killing of deer, foxes and badgers, along with disturbing footage of dogs being mistreated, intimidated and forced into violent encounters.

Further devices seized during warrants in October 2025 revealed even more offences, implicating both men in sustained cruelty.

One of the dogs seen in the footage — a lurcher called Bear — was found at David’s home and removed to safety.

David Stanbury, born around 1972, lives at Denstead Lane in Chartham Hatch, Canterbury, where he runs an upmarket Airbnb lodge called Canterbury Cabin with his much younger Latvian wife, Viktorija.

The couple’s online presence projected a polished, idyllic lifestyle, but the content recovered from David’s phone told a very different story.

Animal abuser David Stanbury is shown outdoors in daylight, wearing a white collared shirt and dark vest, with greenery blurred behind him. Another person’s arm and hair are partly visible close to him, suggesting a candid moment.

He had previously been charged in June 2025 alongside Thomas Bishop, born c. 1992, of Grove Close in Pontefract, West Yorkshire, after a dead boar was found in the Forest of Dean. In that earlier case, David faced allegations of hunting a wild mammal with dogs, possession of bladed articles and causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal. Bishop pleaded guilty and was fined but Stanbury denied the charges. The outcome of that case against him is not known.

Animal abusers David and Jack Stanbury are shown at the father's wedding ceremony. Both are wearing dark suits.

Jack Stanbury, born around 1999 and living in Vale View Road, Aylesham, Canterbury, was drawn into the investigation when messages and videos on his father’s devices showed him participating in the hunting and abuse.

Although younger, Jack’s involvement was not peripheral; he was actively engaged in the persecution and mistreatment of both wildlife and dogs.

Animal abuser Jack Stanbury is shown seated in the driver’s seat of a vehicle, wearing a white dress shirt and dark vest. The car interior surrounds him, with the window and door frame visible, capturing a composed moment in formal attire.

Judge Fowler refused to allow the videos to be played in court due to their disturbing nature, relying instead on detailed descriptions of the content.

When warrants were executed at both men’s addresses, officers found Bear, the lurcher seen in the footage, living in poor conditions. He was seized and taken into RSPCA care.

Additional phones recovered during the searches revealed further offences, demonstrating that the cruelty was not isolated but part of a sustained pattern.

Sentencing

On 25 September 2026, both men were sentenced at Cheltenham Magistrates’ Court.

David Stanbury received a three‑year prison sentence, suspended for three years, along with 100 hours of unpaid work, 15 Rehabilitation Activity Requirement days, a nine‑month curfew between 9pm and 5am, and £5,000 in costs.

Jack Stanbury received an 18‑month prison sentence, suspended for two years, 100 hours of unpaid work, a six‑month curfew between 9pm and 5am, and £1,000 in costs.

Both men were banned from keeping animals for life.

In mitigation, the court heard claims that they were remorseful and had distanced themselves from the hunting community.

Statement by Investigators

RSPCA investigator Michelle Hare described the content found on David’s phone as revealing the true scale of the cruelty. She spoke of shocking videos showing wildlife being brutally killed, heartbreaking trophy images, and messages about hunting with dogs, highlighting the suffering inflicted on both wild animals and the dogs used in the crimes.

Police Sergeant Ross Haybourne of Kent Police’s Rural Task Force emphasised the importance of collaboration with the RSPCA, confirming that Bear was seized and taken to safety and stating that the force remains committed to bringing rural offenders to justice.

At a Glance

Offenders: David Stanbury (born circa 1972), Jack Stanbury (born circa 1999)
Addresses: Denstead Lane, Chartham Hatch, Canterbury CT4 7NL; Vale View Road, Aylesham, Canterbury CT3 3DD
Previous Case: 2025 Forest of Dean boar case involving David Stanbury and Thomas Bishop (outcome unknown)
Victims: Deer, foxes, badgers, and multiple dogs including Bear
Key Evidence: Trophy videos, messages, images, and footage of dogs being mistreated
Investigation: Gloucestershire Police, Kent Police Rural Task Force, RSPCA Special Operations Unit
Outcome: Lifetime animal bans for both men

Dogs Today


UKACF Commentary

What is most striking about David Stanbury is the gulf between the life he performs online and the cruelty he chooses in reality. His social media paints a picture of a blissful, upmarket lifestyle shared with his much younger wife at their Airbnb accommodation, Canterbury Cabin. But cruelty of this magnitude never stays neatly contained in a field or a forest. It speaks to a deeper absence of empathy, control and respect for life.

Men who revel in violence toward animals often wear extraordinarily convincing masks — charming, confident, wholesome, successful. Behind closed doors, those masks slip.

A man who laughs at suffering, who teaches cruelty to his own son, who treats life as disposable, does not transform into a gentle, safe partner at home.

Social media can present a fairy‑tale marriage, but the reality for women tied to men like this is often far more complex, shaped by power imbalance, image‑management and a version of him that exists only for the camera.

Holmfirth, West Yorkshire: Ryan Miller

Animal abuser Ryan Miller is shown standing on a carpeted staircase indoors, wearing a light button‑up shirt. He has short hair and a beard and is looking toward the camera.
Ryan Miller abandoned his dog and left her to suffer without food, care, or help.

Case Summary

In January 2026, American bully cross Mabel was found abandoned in a cold, dark cellar at a property on Greenfield Road, Holmfirth. Her owner, 44‑year‑old Ryan David Alfred Miller, had left her alone for around three weeks with no food, no water and no bedding other than a single sofa cushion. The cellar was filthy, unheated and entirely unsuitable for any animal.

Mabel was discovered by the landlord in a severely emaciated and dehydrated state. A vet later confirmed her body condition score was one out of nine, describing her level of suffering as “very high”. The RSPCA was told that had she not been found when she was, she would likely have died within days.

A behavioural assessment concluded that Mabel would have experienced fear, anxiety, panic and frustration throughout the prolonged period of abandonment.

Prosecutor Louise Freeman told the court that Miller was Mabel’s sole owner and had previously been reminded by the RSPCA that dogs must not be left for long periods.

Despite this, he left her without care for weeks.

Mabel was signed over to the RSPCA and has since been rehomed.

Miller, a father of five and a chef by trade, had previously lived at Batley Street, Moldgreen HD5 9DD, and formerly ran a catering street‑food business called Hungry Turtle Holmfirth.

At the time of the offence he was living at Greenfield Road, Holmfirth, but later moved to Kilburn, near Thirsk, North Yorkshire.

Animal abuser Ryan Miller is wearing a black leather jacket over a light shirt stands near a glass door with decorative lettering behind him. He is facing the camera in a casual pose.

In mitigation, the court heard that Miller claimed he had been threatened, beaten and warned not to return to the property due to debts, and had gone to stay with his ex‑partner.

His representative said he had “buried his head in the sand”, and that Mabel’s suffering was a consequence of his personal circumstances.

The probation officer told the court that Miller had given “no consideration for this dog whatsoever”, describing the neglect as wilful.

Sentencing

Miller appeared before Kirklees Magistrates’ Court on 9 October 2026 and admitted two offences under the Animal Welfare Act 2006.

He was sentenced to 38 weeks’ custody, suspended for 12 months, ordered to complete 200 hours of unpaid work, and given an indefinite ban on keeping animals.

He must pay £587 in costs, and magistrates granted the RSPCA an order to recover legal and veterinary fees, estimated at around £3,000.

Animal abuser Ryan Miller is wearing a black patterned bandana and a white shirt stands in a commercial kitchen, with a metal vent hood and equipment visible behind him

The court noted that Miller had been working at the time but was behind on rent and bills, and that the offence involved “serious animal cruelty and a long period of neglect”.

RSPCA Statement

The RSPCA said Mabel had endured extreme suffering during the weeks she was left alone in the cellar. A vet confirmed she was close to starvation and would likely have died within days had she not been discovered. The charity emphasised that Miller had previously been warned not to leave dogs for extended periods, yet still abandoned Mabel without any provision for her welfare.

At a Glance

Offender: Ryan David Alfred Miller
Born: circa 1982
Age at Conviction: 44
Addresses:
• Greenfield Road, Holmfirth (offence location)
• Batley Street, Moldgreen, HD5 9DD (previous address)
• Kilburn, near Thirsk, North Yorkshire (current address)
Occupation: Chef; former owner of Hungry Turtle Holmfirth street‑food business
Animal Victim: Mabel – American bully cross, severely emaciated, rehomed
Body Condition: 1/9
Injury Timeline: Approximately three weeks of abandonment; near‑fatal starvation and dehydration
Reporting Gaps: None noted beyond Miller’s claimed personal circumstances

YorkshireLive

Barrow, Cumbria: Penny Garner‑Carpenter

Several dogs are confined in tiered metal cages inside a dimly lit vehicle. Bowls, tools and scattered items lie on the floor, and the crates are stacked three levels high.

Penelope Garner-Carpenter has been banned from keeping animals for life after RSPCA inspectors discovered 21 pedigree Collie dogs and a cat living in filthy, cramped and dangerous conditions inside her van and caravan.

The animals were found stacked in heavily soiled crates, many without bases, with faeces and urine ingrained throughout the metal bars and plastic trays.

Side‑by‑side images of the same dog: on the left, thin and dirty on a concrete floor next to a sign marked “6”; on the right, clean, healthy and standing indoors on a blanket with toys and shelves behind.

Ten of the dogs were emaciated, anaemic and stained in faeces and urine, with pressure sores and matted fur. One Collie was later euthanised due to continuing ill health.

RSPCA officers rescued 21 Collies and a cat from filthy stacked crates inside a van and caravan in Barrow. Ten dogs were emaciated and one was euthanised. This video shows the moment inspectors uncovered the shocking conditions

Police first attended the scene on Walney Road on 14 July 2025 after emergency calls about dogs tied to a fence in the Farmfoods car park.

More dogs were then discovered inside a Transit van and a caravan being towed behind it.

A cluttered caravan interior with debris, bedding, bottles and household items covering the floor and benches. The space appears dirty, cramped and heavily disorganised.

RSPCA Inspector Carl Larsson described the cargo area of the van as having a strong, unpleasant smell of urine and faeces, with crates stacked three high in near‑darkness and extreme heat. An unopened pack of raw chicken thighs was found in the cluttered cab — the food Garner‑Carpenter claimed she was feeding them.

Two dogs are kept in separate metal cages inside a messy indoor room with bags, clothing and household items scattered around. One dog is standing while the other lies down.

The caravan was in a similar state. Dogs were housed in metal crates with missing bases, no bedding and extensive contamination. Many had diarrhoea and were sitting in it.

The cat, kept inside the caravan with some of the dogs, was terrified and unable to hide, causing extreme stress.

Two images of the same dog: on the left, slightly dirty and standing outdoors beside a sign marked “12”; on the right, clean and lying comfortably on a carpeted floor indoors.

A vet examined all the animals at the police station. Ten dogs had a body condition score of one out of ten — severely emaciated — and were covered in faeces and urine more than 24 hours old. All were extremely anaemic, a condition that would have taken months to develop, worsened by malnutrition. Several dogs had pressure sores, matted fur, diarrhoea and dehydration. One female Collie was so dehydrated she required overnight fluids.

The vet concluded that the suffering was entirely preventable with basic provisions such as flea control, adequate diet and appropriate housing. The cat had also suffered due to the crowded, dirty environment and inability to escape the dogs.

An empty white metal animal crate sits on a concrete floor with dirt visible inside. Two sheets of paper marked “7” and “8” rest on top of the crate.

Garner‑Carpenter told the RSPCA she had been “on the road” with her pets since June 2025 after losing her home, claiming she fed them raw chicken daily and rotated their time outside due to having limited leads. She admitted they spent too long in the crates but continued to deny the offences in court.

Sentence

Penelope Garner‑Carpenter, 67, was sentenced at South Cumbria Magistrates’ Court on 25 September 2026. She received a 22‑week custodial sentence, suspended for 12 months, for three animal welfare offences. The judge noted her poor health and the prospect of rehabilitation when deciding to suspend the sentence.

She was disqualified for life from owning, keeping, dealing in or transporting animals.

One dog was euthanised on veterinary advice; the remaining 20 dogs and the cat were successfully rehomed by RSPCA branch‑run centres and Animal Rescue Cumbria.

At a Glance

  • Defendant: Penelope Garner‑Carpenter (born 25 April 1959)
  • Original Location: Walney Road, Barrow, Cumbria
  • Later Address: Moss Road, Askern / Hatfield Woodhouse, Doncaster; links to Newcastle-under-Lyme in Staffordshire, Northallerton in North Yorkshire, and Trimdon Station in County Durham
  • Animals Involved: 21 Collies (16 female, 5 male) and 1 cat
  • Key Issues: Emaciation, anaemia, faeces‑soiled crates, extreme heat, lack of light, untreated medical conditions
  • Euthanised: One Collie
  • Rehomed: 20 dogs and the cat
  • Ban Length: Lifetime
  • Court: South Cumbria Magistrates’ Court

RSPCA Statement

Inspector Will Lamping, who led the investigation, said: “Keeping so many dogs in crates in these conditions was totally unacceptable. There would have been barely room to move, distress from excessive noise and the animals would have been forced to toilet in the small space they had been provided with.

“Crates should only be used for short periods of time, with suitable training, and should never be used as a permanent environment for a dog.”

He thanked Cumbria Police and the RSPCA’s network of centres for their work in rescuing and rehoming the animals.

The Mail
News & Star
RSPCA

West Bromwich, West Midlands: Qadeer Ahmed

Close‑up of Roxy, a Rottweiler, lying on a striped towel. She has visible patches of hair loss and irritated skin on her face and head. A grooming clipper and a gloved hand are nearby, indicating she is being examined or treated.
Roxy’s face showed the untreated injuries that caused her prolonged suffering.

On 7 January 2026, Roxy, a female Rottweiler, was taken to a veterinary practice in Stafford with multiple untreated bite wounds, including a deep, necrotic gash to her chest measuring 6cm by 4cm. Her owner, Qadeer Ahmed, 35, of Hartland Road, West Bromwich, had delayed seeking treatment for days despite the severity of her injuries.

A dog groomer in Birmingham had already told him to go to a vet immediately, but he failed to act.

By the time Roxy was finally examined, her condition had deteriorated so badly that euthanasia was considered the only humane option.

Roxy, a Rottweiler, lying on a patterned surface. She is wearing a black studded collar. A section of fur has been shaved around an injury on her body, with loose fur visible nearby, showing the area being prepared for examination.

A post‑mortem examination later confirmed that Roxy’s injuries had been inflicted at different times. In addition to the chest wound, she had bite wounds to her legs and ears, all at varying stages of healing. The examining vet estimated the chest injury had likely been present for six to eighteen days before Ahmed sought help. The vet concluded that Roxy’s suffering would have been reasonably foreseeable and avoidable with timely veterinary intervention.

Ahmed told investigators that another dog had bitten Roxy two to three days earlier, but this was contradicted by the veterinary evidence. He chose to travel 25 miles to Stafford rather than attend a local vet, further delaying treatment.

Roxy’s death prompted an RSPCA investigation, which resulted in Ahmed being charged with two offences under the Animal Welfare Act 2006.

Sentence

Court: North Staffordshire Magistrates’ Court
Date: 24 September 2026
Penalty: 16 weeks’ imprisonment, suspended for 12 months
Ban: 10‑year disqualification from owning animals (expires September 2036)
Costs: £350 court costs; £154 victim surcharge
Mitigation: Not reported

At a Glance

Defendant: Qadeer Ahmed
Born: April1991
Age at Conviction: 35
Address: Hartland Road, West Bromwich B71 3DB
Occupation: company director – Velor Vehicle Rental Ltd
Previous Convictions: Not reported
Additional Information: Ignored advice from a groomer to seek urgent veterinary care; travelled 25 miles to a vet despite local options; provided an inaccurate account of the injury timeline
Animal Victim: Roxy (Rottweiler)
Victim Fate: Euthanised due to extensive suffering and poor prognosis
Evidence: Post‑mortem findings; necrotic chest wound; multiple injuries at different healing stages; veterinary timeline estimate
Case Type: Neglect; failure to seek veterinary treatment; bite‑related injuries Locality: West Bromwich
Photos: RSPCA images
Reporting Gaps: No information on earlier incidents or other dogs involved

RSPCA Statement

Deputy chief inspector Tom Hall said the chest wound would have been obvious and required immediate veterinary attention. He noted that Ahmed ignored clear advice from a groomer to seek urgent treatment, resulting in prolonged suffering and Roxy’s eventual euthanasia. He reminded owners that prompt veterinary care is essential when an animal shows signs of injury or distress.

Birmingham Now
BirminghamLive
Express & Star

Slough, Berkshre: Jack Smith

A recent photo of Jack Smith indoors, smiling slightly, wearing a black quilted jacket over a blue collared shirt.
Jack Smith beat a defenceless puppy around the head, hid him injured in a bedroom, tied his mouth shut, and left him wrapped in a urine‑soaked blanket with a fractured rib and severe facial trauma.

Case Summary

Jack Smith narrowly avoided an immediate prison sentence after being found guilty of serious animal cruelty offences.

On 31 January 2025, Slough Borough Council’s animal welfare inspector attended a property in Ledgers Road, Slough, following reports that a man had been seen beating a puppy around the head repeatedly. Smith refused entry and denied owning a dog.

A brown and white puppy sitting on a beige rug, looking alert and healthy after recovery from injuries.

On 6 February 2025, the council officer returned to lawfully remove Smith from the property. After a forced entry, the officer and managing agent carried out a condition survey and found the flat in extremely poor condition, with large quantities of rubbish and waste items throughout.

A puppy was discovered hidden in a bedroom, wrapped in a urine-soaked blanket. The animal had severe injuries to his head, muzzle and face. Veterinary examination revealed multiple blunt-force trauma injuries, a fractured rib, and evidence that his mouth had been tied shut.

A close‑up of the injured puppy lying on a light rug, showing scabbing and irritation around the muzzle and nose.

The puppy also had injuries to his ears from attempts to remove the ligatures.

Smith continued to deny ownership, but a microchip check confirmed he was the registered owner.

After failing to attend initial hearings, a warrant was issued for his arrest. He later pleaded guilty at Reading Magistrates’ Court on 18 September 2026.

Offender Overview

A portrait of Jack Robert Smith, taken in 2017, showing him with short curly hair and light facial hair, wearing a dark collared shirt indoors.
Police‑appeal photo of Smith, taken in 2017 when he was reported missing.

Name: Jack Robert Smith
Born: May 1998
Age at Conviction: 28
Last Known Address: Ledgers Road, Slough SL1 2RQ
Occupation: Unknown
Previous Convictions: Not known
Additional Information: Prosecution brought by Slough Borough Council

Incident Details

Date of Offence: 31 January 2025
Location: Ledgers Road, Slough
Victim: Male puppy
Nature of Cruelty: Beating, blunt-force trauma, mouth tied shut, neglect, concealment
Discovery: Puppy found hidden in a bedroom, wrapped in a urine-soaked blanket

Animal Victims

Species: Dog (puppy)
Condition: Severe head and facial injuries, fractured rib, trauma from ligatures
Outcome: Taken into council care, fostered immediately, fully recovered and rehomed

Sentence

Court: Reading Magistrates’ Court
Date: 18 September 2026

Penalty:

  • 20-week prison sentence, suspended for 18 months
  • 6-week prison sentence, suspended for 18 months (to run consecutively)
  • 200 hours of unpaid work
  • £450 fine
  • 10-year disqualification from owning animals (expires September 2036)

Mitigation: Judge stated custody was appropriate but restricted by current sentencing limitations.

Council Statement

Councillor Zafar Satti, lead member for public protection and regulatory services, said:

“This is a sad case where an animal has suffered due to mistreatment from its owner and a lack of care. A prison sentence was narrowly avoided. We hope it acts as a serious reminder to people that owning a pet comes with responsibilities and a duty of care. If you cannot manage to look after your animals, look for support, and do not simply neglect them.”

Slough Express
Slough Observer


UKACF Commentary

Cases like this remind us that cruelty doesn’t always look like a dramatic headline — sometimes it’s a frightened puppy hidden in a bedroom, injured, silent, and hoping someone will finally intervene. What happened to this little lad wasn’t an accident, a moment of panic, or a lapse in judgement. It was sustained violence, followed by concealment, denial, and a complete refusal to take responsibility.

The fact that he survived is down to the council officers who refused to walk away, who pushed for entry, and who acted the moment they saw him. Their persistence is the only reason this puppy’s story didn’t end in the worst possible way.

But the outcome in court once again highlights the gap between the suffering animals endure and the consequences faced by those who harm them. A fractured rib, blunt‑force trauma, ligature injuries — and still no immediate custody. It’s a pattern we see far too often, where the gravity of the harm is acknowledged, yet the sentence stops short of reflecting it.

This puppy’s recovery and new life are the bright points in an otherwise bleak case. He was failed by the person who should have protected him, but he was saved by people who refused to ignore his suffering. That is what matters now: he is safe, loved, and living the life he deserved from the start.

For the public, transparency is essential. People have a right to know what happened behind that closed door, and to understand why cases like this continue to fuel calls for stronger, more consistent sentencing in animal cruelty offences. We share these stories not to sensationalise, but to ensure that the victims — the animals who cannot speak for themselves — are never forgotten.

Sawbridgeworth, Hertfordshire: Louise Sugar

Sugar has avoided jail after admitting her role in the abuse and death of a Dachshund named Millie earlier in 2026. She appeared at Stevenage Magistrates’ Court on 23 September 2026, where she admitted two charges of failing to prevent unnecessary suffering to an animal. Millie died in Bishop’s Stortford on 15 March 2026.

The court heard that Sugar permitted the abuse to occur or failed to take reasonable steps to prevent it, resulting in unnecessary suffering.

Very few details have been released publicly, and no other media outlet has covered the case.

Millie’s death was described in court as the result of sustained mistreatment, though the full circumstances have not yet been disclosed.

Sugar was handed a suspended prison sentence and a lifetime ban from keeping animals. The court noted she had shown remorse, but also referenced a “flagrant disregard for people and their property.”

Sugar’s maiden name may be Goggin, though this has not yet been confirmed.

Sentence

The case was heard at Stevenage Magistrates’ Court on 23 September 2026. Louise Sugar, 38, admitted two offences under the Animal Welfare Act relating to the unnecessary suffering of a Dachshund named Millie.

She received a 34‑week prison sentence, suspended for 18 months, and was ordered to complete 200 hours of unpaid work. She must also pay £85 in costs and a £187 victim surcharge.

Sugar was banned for life from owning or keeping animals.

At a Glance

  • Defendant: Louise J Sugar (38, born c. 1988)
  • Address: Wychford Drive, Sawbridgeworth CM21 0HA; previously of Dukes Ride, Bishop’s Stortford CM23 4BY
  • Possible Maiden Name: Goggin
  • Victim: Millie, a Dachshund
  • Offence Location: Bishop’s Stortford, Essex
  • Key Issues: Failure to prevent abuse, unnecessary suffering, dog died as a result
  • Sentence: 34-week custodial suspended for 18 months
  • Unpaid Work: 200 hours
  • Costs: £85 + £187 surcharge
  • Ban Length: Lifetime
  • Missing Metadata: Full incident details, veterinary findings, timeline of events, involvement of others, police/RSPCA statements, photos

WH Times

Consett, County Durham: John Bagnall

A man in a red shirt sitting indoors, facing the camera with a neutral expression.
John Bagnall caused prolonged suffering to his elderly terrier‑type dog, Jake.

Case Summary

John Bagnall, born 7 May 1988, of Wansbeck Grove, Consett, was banned from keeping animals for life after his elderly terrier‑type dog, Jake, died following months of suffering caused by blunt‑force trauma.

Offender Overview

  • Name: John Bagnall
  • Born: 7 May 1988
  • Age at Conviction: 38
  • Address: Wansbeck Grove, Consett DH8 6EW
  • Occupation: Unknown
  • Previous Convictions: Not stated
  • Additional Information: Court heard that Bagnall is autistic.

Incident Details

On 29  October 2025, RSPCA Inspector Christine Nisbet attended Bagnall’s home after reports that his dog had been beaten.

Bagnall claimed he found Jake dead the previous morning and had thrown the body onto nearby wasteland “so the foxes could eat it.”

A veterinary examination revealed multiple rib fractures of differing ages on both sides of the body, consistent with repeated blunt‑force trauma. The vet confirmed that Jake had suffered significantly.

Animal Victim

A small terrier‑type dog with a wiry brown coat and darker fur around the muzzle, looking toward the camera.
Jake, the elderly terrier‑type dog who suffered multiple rib fractures over time.
  • Name: Jake
  • Species/Breed: Terrier‑type dog
  • Age: 16 years
  • Condition: Multiple rib fractures; evidence of prolonged suffering
  • Fate: Deceased

Sentence

  • Court: Peterlee Magistrates’ Court
  • Date: 16 September 2026
  • Penalty: 24‑week custodial sentence, suspended for two years
  • Ban: Lifetime prohibition on keeping animals
  • Costs: £300 plus £154 victim surcharge
  • Mitigation: Defence claimed Jake had fallen down stairs; offender’s autism noted.

RSPCA Statement

Inspector Christine Nisbet said:

“It is awful to think of the suffering Jake endured over months. Every living creature deserves a life free from suffering and filled with compassion.”

ChronicleLive
Northern Echo

Middlesbrough, North Yorkshire: Thomas Buckworth

Animal abuser Tom Buckworth is shown wearing a white dress shirt, light pink tie, and grey trousers, standing indoors at a formal event. Part of another person in a white dress is visible beside him, with decorative artwork in the background.

Incident Details

This case concerns a one‑year‑old Cavalier King Charles Spaniel Maggie, who was brought to a veterinary practice on 5 November 2025 in a catastrophic state of neglect. She belonged to a traveller named Thomas Buckworth, who goes by Tom Adams-Buckworth, who is from Ormesby, Middlesbrough.

A small spaniel lying on a light‑coloured carpet with wet, matted fur and visible debris on her coat. The dog is positioned on her side indoors, appearing weak and neglected.

The tiny dog was severely emaciated, motionless, soaked, infested with mites, and covered in matted faeces. Her breathing was described as “gasping, almost agonal”, and she made a “haunting, howling noise” as she struggled to lift her head.

The vet confirmed she was dying. Maggie was euthanised to end her suffering.

A post‑mortem examination found diffuse muscle loss, no visible body fat, and clear evidence of prolonged malnutrition. The report concluded she had endured a sustained period where her calorie intake was far below what a young dog needs to survive.

Tom Adams-Buckworth in a white sleeveless shirt guiding a brown horse through a body of water. The horse is partially submerged and wearing a red bridle, while he holds the reins beside it

Buckworth, who has strong family links to the Stokesley area of Middlesbrough, pleaded guilty to causing unnecessary suffering.

Sentence

Buckworth received a 15‑week prison sentence, suspended for two years, and a 10‑year ban on keeping animals, which he cannot contest for eight years. He was also ordered to pay £1,082 in legal and veterinary fees.

RSPCA Statement

RSPCA Inspector Natalie Hill said: “Poor Maggie had clearly been suffering for some time… It is heartbreaking to think of any animal suffering in this way.”

At a glance

Tom Adams-Buckworth is shown standing on a paved area next to a dark‑coloured car, wearing a light blue long‑sleeve polo shirt and blue jeans. Behind him are a wooden fence, grass, trees, and a brick building.

Offender: Thomas Buckworth (aka Tom Adams‑Buckworth)
DOB: 25 April 2003
Age at Conviction: 23
Background: Traveller; backyard breeder; strong family links to Stokesley, Middlesbrough
Location: Premier Road, Ormesby, Middlesbrough
Victim: Maggie — one‑year‑old Cavalier King Charles Spaniel
Offence: Causing unnecessary suffering
Condition: Severe emaciation; prolonged malnutrition; mites; matted faeces; agonal breathing; euthanised due to critical condition
Sentence: 15 weeks’ imprisonment (suspended 2 years); £1,082 costs Animal Ban: 10‑year ban; cannot contest for 8 years (expires September 2036)
Court: Teesside Magistrates’ Court
Date: 15 September 2026

TeessideLive
Northern Echo

Brownhills, West Midlands: Robert Walker and Lynne Chetter

Side‑by‑side images showing two individuals: a woman facing the camera and a man standing outdoors beside a car. These are Robert Walker and Lynne Chetter, convicted of  animal neglect charges at their business MHS Horse Disposals.
Robert Walker and Lynne Chetter, operators of MHS Horse Disposal, convicted of multiple Animal Welfare Act offences.

Case Summary

Sick, elderly and vulnerable horses sent to MHS Horse Disposal for humane euthanasia were instead left to suffer in appalling conditions.

Environmental health officers and the RSPCA found carcass bins overflowing, equines left loose in fields in distress, and other animals — including a blind duck with a broken leg and an injured turkey — kept in filthy, untreated conditions.

Underweight pony seized from MHS Horse Disposal alongside other neglected equines.

Several horses were so underweight and neglected that vets ordered immediate euthanasia.

The business operates from Streetway Farm in Norton Canes, Cannock, Staffordshire, a site already known for serious animal welfare concerns due to its long‑standing association with circus big cats kept in cramped, inadequate conditions.

The defendants’ neglect occurred in a commercial setting where animals should have had a dignified end.

Offender Overview

Robert Walker

  • Name: Robert Walker
  • Born: 10 October 1946
  • Age at Conviction: 79
  • Last Known Address: Friezland Lane, Brownhills, Walsall WS8 7DA
  • Occupation: Co‑owner/operator, MHS Horse Disposals
  • Previous Convictions: Unknown
  • Additional Information: Elderly; mitigation referenced poor health.

Lynne Chetter

  • Name: Lynne Chetter
  • Born: 11 October 1961
  • Age at Conviction: 64
  • Last Known Address: Friezland Lane, Brownhills, Walsall WS8 7DA
  • Occupation: Co‑owner/operator, MHS Horse Disposals
  • Previous Convictions: Unknown
  • Additional Information: Owned the duck and turkey found suffering at the site.

Incident Details

MHS Horse Disposal operates from Streetway Farm, Watling Street, Cannock WS11 8LX, a location with a long history of animal welfare controversy.

A green sign reading “MHS Horse Disposal – Licensed by DEFRA” displayed at the entrance of the premises involved in the animal neglect case.

The farm previously housed circus lions and tigers belonging to the Chipperfield family, kept in cramped cages on trailers beside the M6 toll road.

Investigations by Animal Defenders International documented big cats confined to grubby transport containers, limited exercise, muddy quagmire conditions, and inadequate space — all while the site also hosted an abattoir marked “MHS Horse Disposal.”

This background reflects a pattern of poor welfare standards at the premises.

On 5 July 2024, environmental health officers and the RSPCA attended the knacker yard and found:

A white duck stands inside a dirty wooden hutch with a muddy floor and a bowl of murky water, highlighting severe neglect and inadequate living conditions.
Blind duck left in a filthy hutch with a broken leg at MHS Horse Disposal
  • Body bins overflowing with carcasses, forcing horses intended for euthanasia to be left loose on fields in distress.
  • Ernie, a dark bay stallion, severely underweight, suffering hoof issues, and with no teeth — euthanised immediately.
  • Beach, another stallion, extremely thin with ribs and spine visible; later diagnosed with motor neuron disease and euthanised.
  • Four more underweight equines left grazing in fields:
    • Elizabeth (elderly mare)
    • Buttercup (bay filly)
    • Two Shetland ponies with severe hoof deformities
  • One Shetland’s back hooves had twisted like corkscrews, spiralling around despite her still being mobile.
  • A blind duck with a broken right leg left in a filthy hutch.
  • A turkey with a large untreated wound on its back.
  • Both birds were euthanised at the scene.
Close‑up of a horse’s lower legs showing hooves that are extremely overgrown and curled forward, indicating long‑term lack of farrier care.

A vet concluded all equines had suffered due to inadequate environment, diet, body condition, dental neglect, hoof neglect, parasitic issues, and lack of timely euthanasia.

The sentencing judge described the conditions as “appalling” and the neglect as “prolonged”, occurring in a commercial setting where animals should have had a dignified end.

Animal Victims

  • Ernie — dark bay stallion; underweight; hoof issues; no teeth; euthanised immediately.
  • Beach — stallion; extremely thin; motor neuron disease; euthanised.
  • Elizabeth — elderly mare; overgrown hooves; dental issues left untreated for two years; euthanised after a year in RSPCA care due to lameness.
  • Buttercup — bay filly; underweight; lameness; euthanised months later.
  • Two Shetland ponies — severe hoof deformities; both euthanised.
  • Blind duck — broken leg; filthy hutch; euthanised.
  • Turkey — large untreated back wound; euthanised.

Fate of animals: Multiple equines euthanised due to suffering; others died or were euthanised after rescue due to chronic neglect.

Sentence

Court

Stafford Crown Court

Date

17 September 2026

Penalty

  • Robert Walker:
    • 15 months’ imprisonment, suspended for 24 months
    • 12‑year disqualification from owning all animals except dogs
    • 15 Rehabilitation Activity Requirement days
    • £187 victim surcharge
    • £200 costs
  • Lynne Chetter:
    • 10 months’ imprisonment, suspended for 24 months
    • 12‑year disqualification from owning all animals except dogs
    • 15 Rehabilitation Activity Requirement days
    • £187 victim surcharge
    • £200 costs

Mitigation

Walker: elderly, poor health.
Chetter: limited mitigation noted; responsible for birds found suffering.

RSPCA Statement

Inspector Laura Baker described the scene as “horrifying”, with vulnerable horses left alive and suffering despite being sent for humane euthanasia. She emphasised that knacker yards must be held accountable for the way they conduct their business and cannot leave animals waiting to be dispatched in pain. She thanked Cannock Chase District Council and West Midlands Police for enabling the prosecution.

World Horse Welfare Field Officer Charlotte Melvin said the case “really stands out” due to the heartbreaking discovery of horses trusted to the yard for humane euthanasia who were instead left alive and suffering considerably.

BirminghamLive

Bradford, West Yorkshire: Paul Wright

A close-up portrait of dog killer Paul Wright sitting indoors against a grey brick wall, wearing a dark sleeveless top with white trim. He has short hair and a beard and is looking directly at the camera.
Paul Wright left a dog to starve in a dark cellar, scratching at the door in her final days. A lifetime ban is the least he deserves.

Case Summary

A spaniel named Biscuit died after being deliberately left to starve in a dark, rubbish‑filled cellar for at least ten days.

Scratch marks on the cellar door showed her desperate attempts to escape.

A worn wooden cellar door showing multiple scratch marks across its surface, indicating repeated attempts by Biscuit to claw her way out. The surrounding frame is dirty and deteriorated, reflecting the neglected environment she was confined in.
Scratch marks on the cellar door where Biscuit tried desperately to escape.

When found, Biscuit’s body was emaciated, weighing less than half of a healthy dog of her size.

The environment contained no food, no water, no bedding, and faeces on the floor.

Paul Wright pleaded guilty to causing unnecessary suffering but avoided immediate custody. He received a suspended sentence and a lifetime ban on keeping animals.

Offender Overview

  • Name: Paul Wright
  • Born: 5 February 1989
  • Age at Conviction: 37
  • Last Known Address: Hawkshead Drive, Little Horton, Bradford BD5 0TJ
  • Previous Address: Southfield Lane, Little Horton, Bradford BD7 3NN
  • Occupation: Unknown
  • Previous Convictions: Unknown
  • Additional Information: Unrepresented in court; admitted Biscuit had not seen a vet “for years.”

Incident Details

Biscuit was discovered on 26 November 2025 in the cellar of Wright’s former property on Southfield Lane.

The body of Biscuit, a small spaniel, lying on the cellar floor amid clutter, rubbish, and debris. Her frame appears severely emaciated, confirming long‑term neglect. The environment is filthy and chaotic, with discarded items and dirt surrounding her.
Biscuit’s skeletal body found in the cellar

The cellar was described as dark, cluttered with household rubbish, and without any visible food or water. There was faeces on the floor, no identifiable bedding, and Biscuit’s body was found under a plastic chair.

Scratch marks on the rear of the cellar door indicated prolonged distress and attempts to escape.

A close-up selfie of Paul Wright indoors, sticking out his tongue toward the camera. Another person is partially visible beside him. The background shows household items out of focus.

A vet assessed Biscuit’s body condition score as 0.5/5, noting no muscle mass, severe emaciation, and an untreated parasitic infection. Biscuit weighed just 7kg; a healthy dog of her size should weigh around 15kg.

The RSPCA stated Biscuit’s suffering lasted at least 10 days, potentially longer, and that her deterioration would have been obvious. Wright failed to seek any veterinary assistance.

Animal Victims

  • Name: Biscuit
  • Species: Dog
  • Breed: Spaniel
  • Sex: Female
  • Age: Unknown
  • Condition: Emaciated; body score 0.5/5; untreated parasitic infection
  • Fate: Died of starvation
  • Photos: Not available
  • Additional Notes: Severe prolonged neglect; found in filthy cellar environment

Sentence

Court: Bradford Magistrates’ Court
Date: September 2024

Penalty:

  • 6‑month prison sentence, suspended for 12 months
  • 6 RAR days
  • 150 hours of unpaid work
  • £400 costs
  • £154 surcharge

Mitigation:

  • Wright offered no mitigation; stated only that Biscuit had not seen a vet “for years.”

Animal Ban:

  • Lifetime ban on keeping or caring for animals
  • Not eligible to appeal for 10 years

RSPCA Statement

Louise Freeman, prosecuting for the RSPCA, described the case as “prolonged negligence culminating in Biscuit’s death in an emaciated state.” She detailed the appalling conditions, the absence of food and water, the scratch marks on the cellar door, and Biscuit’s extreme physical deterioration.

Telegraph & Argus
YorkshireLive


UKACF Commentary

Biscuit’s final days were not a momentary lapse or a single act of carelessness — they were a slow, agonising descent into starvation, fear, and isolation.

Ten days trapped in a dark cellar, scratching at the door in desperation, surrounded by rubbish and filth, with no food, no water, and no comfort. Her suffering was prolonged, obvious, and entirely preventable.

Paul Wright standing outdoors on a street lined with autumn trees, wearing a white T‑shirt with a printed design. Another person is partly visible on the left side of the frame.

Cases like this expose the quiet cruelty that happens behind closed doors: not explosive violence, but the cold indifference of simply doing nothing while an animal wastes away. Biscuit didn’t die quickly. She died inch by inch, losing muscle, strength, hope — until her body could no longer fight.

Her weight, half of what it should have been, tells its own story. The scratch marks on the cellar door tell another. Together they paint a picture of a dog who tried to survive, who tried to escape, who tried to be seen — and wasn’t.

A lifetime ban is the least society can offer in response to suffering like this. Biscuit deserved better than a dark cellar and a slow death. She deserved care, companionship, and dignity. Her story will not be forgotten.