Tag Archives: Cambridge

Ditton Fields, Cambridge: Sam Duckworth

CONVICTED (2022) | grand prix dressage rider and horse breeder/trader Sam Duckworth, born July 1980, director of Five Star Stud Ltd, 589 Newmarket Road, Ditton Fields, Cambridge CB5 8PA – convicted of multiple counts of cruelty in relation to five young horses.

Grand prix dressage rider Sam Duckworth was jailed and banned from keeping all animals for life after showing a "cavalier" attitude to animal welfare.
Grand prix dressage rider Sam Duckworth was jailed and banned from keeping all animals for life after showing a “cavalier” attitude to animal welfare.

Duckworth was convicted of causing unnecessary suffering to the three fillies and two colts by failing to investigate and address the cause of their poor body condition and weight loss, and for failing to take steps to meet their needs. He was also found guilty of failing to provide an adequate parasite control plan, required farriery and a suitable diet, and failing to seek veterinary attention in respect of the animals’ poor condition.

Horses abused by dressage rider Sam Duckworth from Cambridge

The charges applied from December 2020 to January 2021, when the horses were seized by the RSPCA from a site in the village of Wichenford, Worcestershire.

Horses abused by dressage rider Sam Duckworth from Cambridge

Prosecutor Sara Pratt said that of the five horses, one was owned by Duckworth while the others were entrusted to his care. Sadly, one of the seized horses died in RSPCA care, having become unwell.

Ms Pratt said: “The prosecutions says Mr Duckworth ignored warnings and professional advice given to him.

“He was dismissive of the RSPCA and the advice he was given by RSPCA vets and his own. We find he failed properly to follow advice on feed and worming.”

Ms Pratt said Duckworth also ignored warnings about the horses’ welfare from the provider of the premises where the horses were kept, Melvin Sanders, and part-time employee Lauren Ball.

Horses abused by dressage rider Sam Duckworth from Cambridge

District judge Ian Strongman said that Mr Sanders was “put upon” by Duckworth to care for the horses.

“[Mr Sanders] did so because he felt for the animals and didn’t want to see them without,” Mr Strongman said.

He added that Ms Ball was highly experienced but only employed for an hour each day, “but she did an awful lot of extra work because she was concerned for the horses’ welfare, and ignored instructions from Mr Duckworth about feeding them,”

Mr Strongman said. “She felt they needed more feed, and but for her, the animals could have been in a worse condition.”

The court heard the horses’ body condition scores were one at 0.5 on the 0-5 scale, three at one and one at 1.5.

Sam Duckworth - horse abuser

Ms Pratt said that Duckworth “displayed what might be called a cavalier attitude to these horses in his care and failed to follow advice given by professionals. ”

She added that his behaviour appeared to be “bordering on arrogance, of knowing better than anyone, so we feel this likely to extend to other animals in his care. He’s simply unable to see his own failings or follow advice.

She concluded: “According to him, he had the financial means to look after the horses but simply chose not to.”

Horses abused by dressage rider Sam Duckworth from Cambridge

Duckworth’s lawyer, Stuart Jessop, argued that the case was serious but not as serious as many that come before court and that his client was “a man of good character” .

He said his client’s neglect of the horses was not prolonged and there was evidence of “ample hay, bedding and feed”.

He conceded that Duckworth “didn’t attend much” but said this was during Covid, which limited his ability to be on the premises.

Jessop said Duckworth’s only income was less than £1,000 per month from his parents, but Mr Strongman rejected this. He said: “I understand … he had about 100 horses and breeding 60-80 foals a year, which he presumably sells. I find him an unreliable witness and I don’t think anything he could say would change my mind.”

There was dispute over the ownership of the horses but Mr Strongman said that as he had not seen sufficient evidence to suggest otherwise, he ruled that all belonged to Duckworth so a deprivation order was made on them.

Horses abused by dressage rider Sam Duckworth from Cambridge

Jailing Duckworth, Mr Strongman said: “It’s one of those cases where appropriate punishment can only be achieved with an immediate custodial sentence.”

Speaking about the case, RSPCA inspector and equine officer Suzi Smith said: “As an experienced horsewoman, it is very difficult for me to see any horses in such poor condition, especially for these youngsters who have been given such a poor start in life, when they should have been receiving professional care.

“It is always frustrating when a horse owner does not follow veterinary advice. It’s unacceptable for anyone to cause an animal to suffer, and particularly someone who is responsible for animals in a professional capacity.”

Sentencing | immediate 18-week prison sentence; ordered to pay £68,860 in costs, including the care of the horses since the seizure. Banned from keeping all animals for life and cannot apply to reverse this for five years.

Horse & Hound

Cambridge: Benjamin Rudge and Olena Lobunets

CONVICTED (2019) | Benjamin Rudge, born September 1975, and Olena Lobunets, born December 1971, both of Richard Foster Road, Cambridge CB2 8DW – left a herd of fallow deer to starve to death in a field.

The deer left to starve at Clermont Hall by callous Benjamin Rudge and Olena Lobunets from Cambridge. The surviving animals have recovered well in the care of the RSPCA.
The deer left to starve at Clermont Hall by callous Benjamin Rudge and Olena Lobunets from Cambridge. The surviving animals have recovered well in the care of the RSPCA.

Benjamin Rudge and Olena Lobunets left 14 fallow deer in a paddock at Clermont Hall, Little Cressingham, Thetford, without food or shelter through the worst of the Beast from the East.

During a visit to the property in February 2018, RSPCA inspectors found one deer had died and another had collapsed. The collapsed animal and three others subsequently died.

Former company director Rudge and Ukrainian national Lobunets had been renting out the mansion and three cottages as a holiday home from £3,956 a week for up to 36 people at a time.

Jonathan Eales, prosecuting for the RSPCA, said a housekeeper was employed to look after the property and the fallow deer but he did not have money for animal feed.

He said the animal welfare charity visited the hall after it was contacted by walkers concerned at the condition of the deer.

Inspectors found the animals were emaciated, while their pen was bare of any grass and infested with molehills.

RSPCA workers began visiting to feed the animals, but three more died.

Mr Eales said post mortem examinations revealed the deer were severely underweight and emaciated.

He said: ‘These deer died as a result of neglect. They were malnourished, dehydrated, they were incapable of surviving in an enclosure where there was insufficient food and no shelter.’

Speaking after the hearing, a spokesman for the RSPCA recalled the state of the deer when they first arrived at the estate.

He said: ‘The deer were very skinny – you could clearly see their ribs and their hip bones were protruding.

‘We hoped to remove the animals but expert vets said they were too weak to be moved at that stage. Vets advised us to feed them and our officers, who had launched an investigation, visited them daily to monitor their condition.

‘Ongoing tests established that, in addition to underfeeding, there were problems with worms and poisonous ragwort in the field so the herd needed to be moved to new pastures before ragwort started to come through in spring.

‘The owners failed to move the herd so vets felt they needed to be taken into our care.’

The spokesperson added: ‘The deer have recovered well and are now living with a private deer keeper.

Sentencing | deprivation order to pass ownership of the surviving deer to the RSPCA. Banned from keeping deer for two years (expired). No costs were awarded and no further penalties were ordered against the couple.

Daily Mail
Eastern Daily Press

Cambridge: Sarah Pickup

CONVICTED (2018) | Sarah Pickup, born c. 1979, of Dennis Road, Cambridge CB5 – kept dogs, cats and lizards in appalling conditions at her home; 21 lizards and other exotic pets found dead.

Reptiles kept in appalling conditions at Sarah Pickup's home in Cambridge.

Pickup pleaded guilty to six offences under the Animal Welfare Act for mistreating dogs, cats and lizards.

Prosecutor Janita Patel told the court that the case came to light after the RSPCA was contacted by someone who had been asked to look after the animals while Pickup was on holiday.

The person was shocked by the conditions in the house and discovered numerous dead reptiles, some of which had been put in plastic bags – while the live reptiles were living in poor conditions.

They also found a Cavalier King Charles spaniel with a buster collar on and a swollen infected ear.

Pickup’s offences in full:

  • Causing unnecessary suffering to a Cavalier King Charles spaniel called Freddie by failing to seek veterinary care and attention for his ear condition
  • Failing to meet his needs for adequate flea control
  • Failing to meet the needs of a cat called Flower, 21 leopard geckos, one chameleon, one plated lizard, one blue-tongued skink, two axolotls, one gecko, and one corn snake, by failing to provide them with a suitable environment
  • Failing to meet the needs of a chameleon
  • Causing it unnecessary suffering by failing to investigate and address the cause of its poor bodily condition and weight loss
  • Failing to meet the needs of 15 leopard geckos and one axolotl by failing to provide an appropriate environment

In total, 26 live reptiles, two amphibians, 21 dead reptiles and 20 dead African land snails were found at the property.

RSPCA inspector Alex Coghlan, who investigated the incident, said: “The conditions at the home were appalling. There was a terrible smell coming from the home and there were dead reptiles just dumped in plastic bags in the garden.

“Many of the live reptiles were being housed in inappropriate conditions, with no water, light or heat, yet the vivariums which did have heaters were just not plugged in or the bulbs had gone out.

“It was heartbreaking to see so many animals just left in such awful conditions.

“Exotic animals need specialist care and sadly these animals had not been looked after appropriately.”

All animals were signed over into the care of the RSPCA and taken to a specialist facility.

Sadly one leopard gecko had to be put to sleep to prevent further suffering.

Sentencing: 12-week custodial sentence, suspended for 12 months; total of £415 costs and charges; 40 hours of rehabilitation with the probation service. Banned for life from keeping animals.

CambridgeshireLive

Cambridge: Christopher Boswell

CONVICTED (2017) | self-styled ‘cat hunter’ Christopher Storer Boswell, born c. 1973, of Eden Street, Cambridge CB1 1EL – shot a Siamese kitten with an air rifle

Self-styled 'cat hunter' Christopher Boswell from Cambridge.
Neighbours of ‘cat hunter’ Christopher Boswell expressed concern that he may be responsible for the disappearance of up to 20 cats in the area

Christopher Boswell pleaded guilty to causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal at Cambridge Magistrates’ Court on Tuesday, June 20, 2017.

In June 2017 the then 73-year-old, who was described in court as a ‘cat hunter’ since he was 17 years old, was handed a 12-week prison sentence, ordered to pay £1,500 compensation and a £115 victim surcharge.

But Boswell appealed his sentence straight after the hearing, with an appeal then held at Cambridge Crown Court on July 20, 2017.

It was reported how Pia the white Siamese kitten, worth about £450, belonged to Cambridge resident Caroline King.

Ms King noticed her cat was missing from her garden about 7.20pm on April 7, 2017, and when she went round to ask Boswell about her missing cat, he told her he had been hunting cats since he was 17.

Boswell had told her: “I don’t like cats, I hate them. They are a menace to wildlife and birds.”

Ms King asked if Boswell was joking but he replied: “No, I’ve shot it twice – once in the head, once in the body and I have put it in the neighbour’s garden. You had better knock on their door.”

Ms King went to her neighbours’ garden where she saw her kitten lying motionless on the floor, making no attempt to move.

The kitten had to have her right leg amputated. One air rifle pellet caused a tear in Pia’s windpipe, while the other shattered her femur.

Ms King paid £5,168 for Pia’s veterinary treatment bills after the cat was rushed to a vet and spent more than a week at a Cambridge veterinary hospital.

In a victim impact statement, Ms King said: “I feel devastated and horrified and cannot fathom why somebody I do not know would carry out such an act.

“I cannot believe Chris would be so calm and calculated over what he has done as if he got some enjoyment from it – as he did not have to tell us and could have chosen to remain quiet.”

Following Boswell’s initial sentencing, a neighbour raised concerns he could have something to do with the disappearance of between 12 and 20 cats that have gone missing in the area in the previous five years.

Michael Magee, mitigating for Boswell in the appeal hearing, said Boswell became increasingly isolated and lived a very solitary existence after his retirement.

He told the court that at the time of the incident, Boswell was on painkillers to deal with chronic arthritis and an itching rash “much like scabies” which had spread over his body.

Mr Magee added: “He became increasingly housebound and this led to a deterioration in his mental state.

“In terms of culpability, one can understand how he fostered his little garden and the birds that came into that garden…that was his very small connection to the previous active life that he had.

“With the background of the mental health issues, he picked up an air rifle while in drink, which belonged to his son, and stupidly shot the cat.

“His desire was to protect the birds, not to cause the cat harm.

“With matters of his pain, the cancer, the severe itching rash that had covered the vast majority of his body, the loneliness and perhaps the focus on his family of birds, he called it; he took that relatively stupid decision.”

Mr Magee said Boswell was a rowing coach for many years and had recently been volunteering two nights week for the Cam Rowers charity.

He urged the court to suspend Boswell’s prison sentence, telling them he had sought help for his alcohol addiction entirely by himself and that he was now in a position to be more active in his life.

After retiring to consider the appeal, Recorder Sandeep Kainth warned Boswell that his actions were “grave and serious” but said he felt satisfied that Boswell’s prison sentence could be suspended.

He added: “This was a deliberate attempt to cause suffering; this is evidenced by your actions of shooting the cat two times not one.

“But there are more mitigating features than aggravating features in this case.

“You have an excellent work ethic, you are a man of good character, this incident was isolated and you have shown genuine remorse.

“The risk of you offending again is very low; we accept that your motive was to protect the birds in your garden.

“It’s disappointing that at the age of 73 you find yourself before the courts, but we accept that for you this is a salutary lesson in itself.”

Sentencing: Boswell’s immediate prison sentence earlier handed down by magistrates was amended to a 12-week sentence, suspended for one year.

The court heard that Boswell had paid the £1,500 compensation to Ms King and his air rifle had been forfeited and destroyed.

Cambridge News
Daily Mail

Arbury, Cambridge: Andrea Impey

CONVICTED (2011) | Andrea Louise Impey (aka Andrea Brown), born 25/02/1981, of 38 Nicholson Way, Cambridge CB4 2RR – left her cats to die a “slow, lingering death” while she went on holiday because she no longer wanted the “burden” of caring for them.

Andrea Impey, who left two cats to starve to death

The court heard that Impey deliberately withdrew all food and water from pet cats Tigger and Fluffy until they died. A post-mortem examination revealed that they each weighed just over 2kg each and had very prominent spines, ribs and pelvic bones. They also had empty stomachs and intestines, and were infested with fleas.

Impey was caught by the RSPCA as she tried to dispose of the two emaciated animals in a bin bag outside her then home in Ekin Road, Cambridge. She had found them curled up together, dead, under a table in her lounge.

Impey said she had the cats from 2004 when they were kittens but had been unable to afford to keep them so she left them to die while she and her boyfriend went to Wales.

When Impey was asked by the RSPCA in an interview why she had not asked for help in looking after the cats, she replied: “Stubbornness”.

She had also previously admitted that she had hoped the animals would die so she would not be burdened with them anymore.

RSPCA inspector Chris Nice, who found the animals, said they experienced “extreme suffering”.

Mitigating for Impey Jim Dignan said his client was remorseful, adding that she had “suffered as a result of this prosecution. This case was reported in the local and national press and there has been a backlash, including anonymous letters through her door, Facebook communication and abuse from people she knows.”

In response to the sentencing, RSPCA Inspector Nice said: “It was her intention, and frankly a shameful one, that these animals should die. Once more a person’s failure to take responsibility for their animals has resulted in extreme suffering.

“I hope that the disqualification will mean that she does not come to our attention again. However, a longer period would have made this more certain.”

Sentencing: 18-month community order, costs of £200; five-year ban on keeping animals (expired 2016).

Express