CONVICTED (2022) | puppy dealers Joseph John Lowther (known as John Lowther), born 8 July 1977, of the travellers site at Kidacre Park, Kidacre Street, Leeds LS10 1BD, and Marina Lowther, born 30 December 1979, of 1 Westway, Farsley, Pudsey LS28 5HU – kept worm-infested dogs and puppies crammed into a livestock trailer at Appleby Horse Fair.
Both Lowthers pleaded guilty to four charges of causing unnecessary suffering to animals under the Animal Welfare Act 2006.
They were prosecuted for neglecting 10 of the 14 animals that the RSPCA took in.
The RSPCA followed up a report that a number of dogs were in a trailer parked near to Winter’s Farm in Appleby during the travellers fair on 13 August 2021.
RSPCA inspectors Keith Hogben and Deborah Beats discovered the dogs were being kept in unhygienic conditions in five cages and some were unwell. They were advised by vets, who were in attendance, to have them seized which took place under police supervision.
Inspector Hogben’s described in his witness statement how he had found an underweight German Shepherd dog who was struggling to stand upright because the cage she was in with her five puppies was too small.
Inside a plastic dog kennel there was a border terrier and three puppies, all of whom were found to be suffering from lice infection.
Inspector Hogben said: “There were many dogs contained in cages. There was very little natural light in the trailer and a strong smell of ammonia and faeces.
“As the dogs were being removed from the cattle trailer… the situation became heated as John Lowther and a young boy tried to stop the dogs being removed and loaded into the transport that had arrived.”
Examinations were carried out on all the dogs at an Appleby veterinary practice, but sadly despite treatment the condition of one of the German Shepherd puppies deteriorated.
Vet Helen Gould stated in her report: “It is my opinion that this pup died due to a high worm burden with subsequent intestinal damage and secondary bacterial infection.”
She said that other pups, who were around six weeks old, all had “a massive worm burden and lice”, but responded to treatment with antibiotics and parasiticides. Their mother also needed treatment for lice and worms.
“These pups were suffering and had been for all of their lives. This could have been avoided by worming them from two weeks of age and treating them for lice,” said the vet.
RSPCA Chief Inspector Rebecca Lowe, who attended at the vets’ practice, said in her statement: “One of the puppies whilst in the crate was trying to toilet and had nothing but worms coming out of its rear end. There was no faeces, just worms.”
RSPCA vet Roxane Kirton concluded the dogs were housed in accommodation that failed to meet their needs, even if it was only for the duration of the fair.
In mitigation, the court was told that John Lowther had suffered from poor mental health exacerbated by the death of a close relative.
Magistrates said there was evidence of “extreme suffering and prolonged neglect”.
The dogs involved in the case have since been re-homed.
RSPCA Inspector Will Lamping said after the court hearing: “It was an upsetting scene that we were confronted with as the puppies were in a really sorry state riddled with worms and parasites.
“At the vets we observed many worms physically crawling from the behind of the pups while they were examined.
“One of them had to be put to sleep, but these infections could have been prevented easily, with proper worming treatments and routine preventive care.
“Thankfully all of the other pups pulled through and they and their mothers have since been re-homed.
“Unfortunately, we have seen a huge increase in people breeding puppies to sell and unscrupulous dealers breed them in poor condition with no thought for their health and wellbeing.
“While we’d always encourage people to rescue a dog we know that lots of families want to take on a puppy and to help them ensure they find a responsible breeder who prioritises the health and welfare of the dogs we believe it is incredibly important that they use a Puppy Contract from the RSPCA website.”
Sentencing |
Joseph John Lowther: 12-week prison sentence suspended for two years (expires May 2024). Eight-week curfew; costs and charges of £213.
Marina Lowther: 12-month community sentence with six-week curfew; costs and charges of £160. No ban.
Disgraceful should of got a prison sentence of at least 5 years each and banned for life, no excuses on his health behaviour, the law does not enough to protect these poor defensive animals, should do the same to them makes me very upset and angry.
I Agree. Not much of a sentence, for the heart breaking situation of what those poor Dogs went through. Not even Banned from keeping them. Absolutely Disgraceful.